Colorado is a dessert lover’s paradise! From the bustling streets of Denver to the quiet mountain towns, this state hides some of the most irresistible pie shops you’ve ever tasted. Each slice tells a story—of buttery crusts, silky fillings, and toppings piled high with love. Imagine biting into a warm, gooey cherry pie while gazing at the Rockies, or savoring a classic apple slice after a chilly hike. These aren’t just pies—they’re tiny celebrations on a plate. Whether you crave timeless flavors or crave daring combinations, Colorado’s bakeries deliver in ways that make every visit unforgettable. Your sweet tooth won’t just be satisfied—it will be thrilled. Get ready to mark your map, follow your nose, and chase the scent of sugar and spice through seven of the state’s most mouthwatering pie shops. Adventure has never tasted this good!
The Emporium
Nestled in the heart of Fort Collins, The Emporium offers a charming ambiance with pies that taste like a warm embrace.
The rustic decor and friendly staff create a welcoming environment, perfect for savoring their famous apple pie topped with caramel drizzles.
Each bite is a nostalgic trip to Grandma’s kitchen, making it a beloved spot among locals. Don’t miss their seasonal specials, showcasing the best of local ingredients.
14 Sweet & Savory Pi Bar
For those who love both sweet and savory, 3.14 Sweet & Savory Pi Bar in Denver is a must-visit.
Their menu creatively balances flavors, offering pies such as bourbon pecan and mushroom truffle.
The modern, sleek atmosphere adds a dash of elegance, attracting foodies and pie lovers alike. Their signature bourbon pecan pie is a symphony of rich, nutty flavors.
City O’ City
City O’ City in Denver is a unique spot where pies are celebrated in all their vegetarian glory.
Their innovative approach to pie-making sets them apart, with offerings like curried vegetable and vegan chocolate silk.
The eclectic atmosphere invites a diverse crowd, ensuring a memorable pie-eating experience that’s both fulfilling and fun.
The Huckleberry
Housed in a historic building in Louisville, The Huckleberry offers a taste of history with each slice of pie.
Their huckleberry pie, crafted from locally sourced berries, is a standout, bursting with sweet, juicy flavors.
The vintage decor and warm service transport you back in time, making every visit a delightful journey through Colorado’s culinary past.
The Village PieMaker
Nestled in the heart of Colorado, The Village PieMaker is a tribute to classic pie-making traditions. Their dedication to quality is evident in every slice, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere. Step inside and be greeted by the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked pies.
Each pie is crafted with care, using only the freshest local ingredients. From tart cherry to creamy custard, there’s a flavor to tempt any palate. Despite its popularity, this shop maintains a friendly, down-to-earth vibe.
Fun Fact: The Village PieMaker uses family recipes passed down through generations, ensuring authentic taste.
High Mountain Pies
In the scenic surroundings of Colorado’s mountainous regions, High Mountain Pies offers more than just a sweet treat; it’s an experience. Known for their adventurous flavor combinations, each pie promises a burst of unique taste.
The rustic charm of the shop, with its woodsy décor, complements the natural beauty outside. Their pies, from fruity delights to rich chocolates, are made with precision.
Did you know? High Mountain Pies sources its ingredients from local mountain farms, supporting sustainable practices while delivering fresh flavors.
Me Oh My Pie
Situated in the picturesque town of Laporte, Me Oh My Pie offers a delightful pie experience. Their menu features a variety of flavors, each more tempting than the last.
Indulge in their seasonal fruit pies while enjoying the serene views from their outdoor seating. The cheerful staff adds to the welcoming atmosphere, making it a favorite among both locals and tourists.
Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite or a leisurely afternoon, Me Oh My Pie promises a slice of happiness.