In Mississippi, neighborhood pizza joints feel like the kind of places you wander into once and return to without thinking — red-checkered tables, familiar faces, and pies that never let you down. Some lean classic, some get creative, but all share that dependable, local-favorite charm.
These are spots where the crust comes hot, the toppings generous, and every slice tastes like the right choice after a long day. Easy, comforting, always on point.
Soulshine Pizza Factory, Jackson
In the heart of Jackson, Soulshine Pizza Factory serves up more than just great pizza; it brings music and community together. Known for its live music nights, it has become a meeting spot for friends and family alike. The unique combination of flavorful pizzas and a lively atmosphere keeps regulars coming back.
The pizzas here are crafted with fresh ingredients and creative toppings that cater to all taste buds. Whether you’re a fan of classic margherita or something more adventurous, Soulshine’s menu has got you covered. It’s a place where good times and great food go hand in hand.
Did you know? The name Soulshine is inspired by a song by The Allman Brothers Band, reflecting the joint’s musical vibes.
Lost Pizza Co., Oxford
Tucked away in Oxford, Lost Pizza Co. invites you into a world of quirky decor and flavorful pizzas. The interior is a feast for the eyes with its eclectic mix of memorabilia and art, creating a fun and relaxed vibe.
Pizzas here are an adventure in themselves, with toppings that range from the familiar to the unexpected. The laid-back atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for catching up with friends or enjoying a casual date night.
Fun fact: Lost Pizza Co. began as a small family endeavor and has grown into a beloved chain across several states.
The Pizza Shack, Jackson
In Jackson, The Pizza Shack has earned its reputation one slice at a time. This unassuming spot may look modest, but its pizzas are anything but ordinary. Known for generous portions and tasty toppings, it’s a favorite among locals.
The outdoor seating area provides a relaxed spot to enjoy your meal, especially on a sunny day. Regulars appreciate the friendly service and the sense of community that the Shack fosters.
A little secret: The Shack’s success lies in its homemade sauces, adding a special touch to every pie.
Tony’s Brick Oven Pizzeria, Gulfport
In Gulfport, Tony’s Brick Oven Pizzeria brings a slice of Italy to Mississippi. The centerpiece of the restaurant is its traditional brick oven, which gives each pizza a perfect, crispy finish.
The staff’s cheerful demeanors enhance the dining experience, making everyone feel like part of the family. It’s a place where the aroma of freshly baked pizza lingers in the air, promising a delicious meal.
Did you know? Tony’s has been serving Gulfport since 2005 and continues to be a beloved fixture in the community.
Sal & Mookie’s New York Pizza & Ice Cream Joint, Jackson
Combining pizza and ice cream, Sal & Mookie’s offers a taste of New York in Jackson. The vibrant setting, complete with city-themed decor, brings a slice of the Big Apple to the South.
With an extensive menu, it’s more than just pizza; it’s about creating memorable dining experiences. From the first bite to the last scoop of ice cream, it’s all about indulgence.
Fun fact: Sal & Mookie’s was co-founded by two lifelong friends who wanted to bring their love for New York-style pizza to Mississippi.
Mugshots Grill & Bar, Hattiesburg
In Hattiesburg, Mugshots Grill & Bar is where pizza meets sports bar excitement. While known primarily for its burgers, the pizza here is a hidden gem that regulars swear by.
The energetic atmosphere makes it a popular hangout spot, especially during game days. Its menu caters to a variety of tastes, ensuring everyone leaves satisfied.
Interesting tidbit: Mugshots proudly serves pizzas with a signature blend of cheese that’s unique to their kitchen, adding a special flavor to each bite.
Brooklyn Pizzeria, Picayune
Bringing an authentic taste of New York to Picayune, Brooklyn Pizzeria stands out with its dedication to quality and tradition. The cozy setting is perfect for a family outing or a solo slice.
Pizzas here are crafted with love, and the thin crust is a true nod to New York style. Regulars appreciate the friendly service and the consistent quality that Brooklyn Pizzeria delivers time and again.
Did you know? The owner hails from Brooklyn, ensuring every pizza holds true to its roots.