Indiana doesn’t mess around when it comes to pizza—and neither do the people who keep lining up for it. This is the state where comfort wins, grease-stained napkins feel right, and the best slices come without a lecture. No white tablecloths. No precious plating. Just dough, sauce, cheese, and places that know exactly what they’re doing.
Across small towns and busy cities, these unfussy pizza joints have earned fierce loyalty. Locals argue over crusts. Families mark milestones by booths and barstools. Late nights end with boxes on car seats and sauce on sleeves.
These 13 Indiana spots prove that when pizza is done right, you don’t need frills—just another slice and a reason to return.
Futuro — Indianapolis, IN
In Indianapolis, Futuro is where Detroit-style pizza lovers find their haven. The pizza’s thick, square crust and crispy cheese edges are complemented by inventive toppings like hot honey and jalapeños.
The bold flavor combinations and relaxed, counter-service setting offer a unique dining experience. Locals appreciate the creative Detroit pies with a crunchy, caramelized crust.
Futuro has earned a spot among Yelp’s Top 100 Midwest pizza spots. Its popularity is a testament to how it’s become a local favorite.
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza — Indianapolis, IN
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza is known for its quirky combinations and loyal fanbase. Reader’s Digest named it Indiana’s top pizza place, praising its inventive pies and laid-back vibe.
The creative toppings and crust, both crisp and chewy, are a hit with long-time Hoosiers. The friendly, casual atmosphere makes it ideal for regular pizza nights.
Signature pizzas like the Lasagna or Slaughterhouse 5 draw visitors, creating a warm and welcoming dining experience.
Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse — Carmel, IN
Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse in Carmel is a local gem, known for pairing classic and creative pizzas with an excellent draft list.
The spot is celebrated for its attention to topping balance and crust texture, along with local craft beers that enhance the experience. It’s perfect for groups, game nights, or casual meals.
Its flavorful pizzas and welcoming pub atmosphere have made it a staple for dependable dining in the Carmel area.
Bazbeaux — Indianapolis, IN
Bazbeaux is a downtown staple in Indianapolis, celebrated for its fresh ingredients and hearty, hand-tossed pizzas.
The emphasis on quality and consistency is evident in every bite, with customizable toppings to suit every taste. Bazbeaux also offers a range of salads, pastas, and local beers.
Thousands of positive reviews highlight the balanced crust and vibrant toppings, making it a favorite for classic pepperoni or seasonal specialty pies.
King Dough — Indianapolis, IN
With a chef-driven menu, King Dough brings creative pizza to life in Indianapolis. The artisanal toppings and unique fusions, such as goat cheese and hot honey, delight visitors.
Quality ingredients and a fun, chef-driven menu set it apart from standard fare. King Dough is well-praised in local food coverage for its thoughtful, flavor-forward pies.
Vegetarian options and fresh dough add to its charm, making it a go-to spot for those seeking something different.
Brozinni Pizzeria — Indianapolis, IN
Brozinni Pizzeria is a slice of New York in Indianapolis, offering a thin, foldable crust that captures the essence of the Big Apple.
The chewy base, tangy sauce, and quality cheese make it a go-to for those seeking authentic NY-style pizza. Its classic approach keeps locals coming back.
Beloved by families and racing fans alike, Brozinni’s reliably good slices and large pies deliver a big-city pizza feel in Indiana.
I Tre Mori — Fishers, IN
I Tre Mori in Fishers offers authentic Italian pizza with a focus on wood-fired flavor and traditional toppings.
The thin, blistered crusts speak to its commitment to Italian technique and simplicity. This craft approach has ranked I Tre Mori among Midwest pizza favorites.
Its authenticity appeals to purists and anyone craving true Italian-style pizza in suburban Indy, creating a unique dining experience.
Pangea Kitchen — Evansville, IN
In Evansville, Pangea Kitchen stands out for its global flavors and creative pizzas, drawing locals and travelers alike.
The inventive combinations and fresh ingredients provide a distinct taste experience, featuring tradition mixed with innovation.
Recognized among top Midwest pizza spots, Pangea creates must-visit pizzas that showcase a blend of culture and creativity.
1000° Wood Fired Pizza — Mt Summit, IN
1000° Wood Fired Pizza offers smoky, high-heat pies with crisp crusts in quaint Mt Summit.
The wood-fired flavor and friendly service make it a beloved local establishment for unpretentious dining. Its pizzas are consistently dependable and enjoyable.
This hidden gem proves that you don’t need a big city to find standout Indiana pizza, with its unique wood-oven character.
Mother Bear’s Pizza Campus — Bloomington, IN
Mother Bear’s has been a Bloomington institution since the 1970s, offering customizable crusts and award-winning sauce.
Pan, deep dish, or toasted sesame, the crust options add a personalized touch. Its build-your-own approach with creative sauces and toppings keeps fans returning.
Named one of America’s best pizza joints, it combines a campus-friendly vibe with memorable pizza experiences.
New Bethel Ordinary — Wanamaker, IN
New Bethel Ordinary is cherished for its classic thin-crust pizza, perfect for casual dinners in Wanamaker.
The consistent, crowd-pleasing pies hit nostalgic notes for many patrons. Its welcoming, unpretentious setting feels like home for decades of Indiana pizza lovers.
Loyal fans praise the dependable pizzas and the warm hospitality that invites repeated visits.
Magoo’s California Pizza — Indianapolis & Avon, IN
Magoo’s specializes in Cali-style pizzas, offering a crispy, chewy crust and vibrant toppings.
The creative flavor profiles and welcoming vibe make it a favorite for casual nights out. It’s beloved for inventive pies and consistent quality.
With locations in Indianapolis and Avon, Magoo’s provides a delightful dining experience for groups and families alike.
Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub — Indianapolis, IN
Pearl Street Pizzeria pairs good food with a lively pub atmosphere in downtown Indianapolis, offering traditional pies and craft beers.
The relaxed vibe and wide beer selection create a perfect spot for post-theatre pizza or casual drinks with friends.
Its fun, social setting keeps crowds returning, with simple yet tasty pizzas that satisfy any craving.