In Rhode Island, some restaurants have a single dish that keeps diners coming back year after year. At these spots, calamari is the star — consistently tender, perfectly seasoned, and often the first thing people order before anything else.
Whether served classic, fried, or with a twist, the dish defines the experience, making it easy for locals and visitors alike to stick with what works. Here are 13 Rhode Island restaurants where calamari keeps the orders the same.
Matunuck Oyster Bar, South Kingstown
Nestled by the picturesque waters of South Kingstown, Matunuck Oyster Bar offers a calamari dish that embodies the ocean’s freshness. The calamari here is perfectly fried to a crisp, yet tender inside, with a tangy and savory lemon aioli that elevates every bite.
Locals swear by this dish, often paired with a glass of chilled white wine. The ambiance, with its view of oyster beds, sets the scene for a truly coastal experience.
The restaurant’s commitment to locally sourced ingredients makes their calamari not only delicious but a true taste of Rhode Island’s bounty.
Hemenway’s, Providence
In the heart of Providence, Hemenway’s offers a calamari dish that’s both sophisticated and comforting. Lightly breaded and accompanied by a spicy marinara, it’s a favorite among seafood lovers.
The artful presentation and seasoned perfection make it a must-try. Paired with the chic atmosphere of the restaurant, it’s an ideal spot for both special occasions and casual dining.
Hemenway’s dedication to quality ensures that every piece of calamari is cooked to perfection, making it one of Providence’s most talked-about dishes.
The Mooring, Newport
The Mooring in Newport is renowned for its breathtaking harbor views and innovative calamari preparations. Here, calamari is served with a unique twist, incorporating local flavors with a touch of Asian fusion.
A dipping sauce with hints of lime and chili adds an unexpected yet delightful kick. The nautical setting enhances the experience, making diners feel connected to the sea.
This dish is a testament to The Mooring’s creativity and commitment to crafting memorable seafood experiences.
Ten Prime, Providence
Ten Prime in Providence reinvents calamari with a modern flair. Presented with a sweet and spicy glaze, this dish is a favorite among those who love a little heat.
The restaurant’s sleek and vibrant atmosphere complements the bold flavors. It’s an ideal spot for those looking to enjoy a contemporary twist on a classic dish.
Each bite of calamari at Ten Prime offers a symphony of flavors, showcasing the restaurant’s innovative approach to dining.
The White Horse Tavern, Newport
Stepping into The White Horse Tavern feels like stepping back in time, but their calamari is anything but old-fashioned. Served with a zesty remoulade, it’s a blend of tradition and taste.
The historic setting, with its wooden beams and cozy atmosphere, adds to the charm, making it a favorite among locals.
This dish captures the essence of Newport’s history while providing a satisfying culinary experience that keeps patrons returning.
Waterman Grille, West Warwick
At Waterman Grille, the charm of West Warwick is reflected in their meticulously crafted calamari. Lightly battered and served with a unique pepper relish, it’s a dish that stands out.
The serene riverside location offers a tranquil setting that complements the flavorful dish. It’s a perfect escape for those seeking a peaceful dining experience.
Waterman Grille’s innovative approach to a classic makes it a standout in the local dining scene.
Coddington Brewing Co., Newport
Coddington Brewing Co. marries the love of craft beer with a standout calamari offering. The lightly fried rings, served with a tangy dipping sauce, are a perfect match for a cold brew.
The casual and friendly atmosphere invites diners to relax and enjoy. This spot is ideal for gatherings with friends or family.
Their commitment to quality and flavor makes this calamari a favorite among Newport locals and visitors alike.
Los Andes, Providence
Los Andes brings a piece of South America to Providence with its bold, flavorful calamari. Prepared with a unique blend of spices, it offers a culinary adventure for the taste buds.
The lively atmosphere, filled with vibrant decor and music, enhances the dining experience.
This dish is a testament to Los Andes’ ability to blend traditional Latino flavors with local ingredients, creating a must-try for those seeking something different.
The Coast Guard House, Narragansett
The Coast Guard House offers a calamari dish as captivating as its oceanfront views. Served with a delicate lemon aioli, each bite is a celebration of the sea.
The serene setting, with waves crashing against the shore, provides the perfect backdrop for this exquisite dish.
This restaurant’s commitment to fresh and local seafood ensures that their calamari is always a standout, drawing diners back time and again.
Persimmon, Providence
At Persimmon, fine dining meets creativity in their expertly crafted calamari dish. The presentation is nothing short of art, with flavors that match its visual appeal.
The intimate and upscale setting provides an ideal spot for those seeking a refined dining experience.
Persimmon’s innovative approach to traditional dishes makes their calamari a standout, leaving a lasting impression on anyone who tries it.
Clarke Cooke House, Newport
Clarke Cooke House is where history meets elegance, and their calamari reflects this blend. With a refined touch, the dish is served with a citrusy aioli that complements the tender calamari.
The historic charm of the restaurant adds to the allure, making it a favored dining location for both locals and tourists.
This dish is a testament to Clarke Cooke House’s commitment to quality and tradition, offering a taste of Newport’s rich culinary heritage.
Brick Alley Pub, Providence
Brick Alley Pub offers a comforting and hearty calamari dish in a welcoming pub atmosphere. With a classic marinara sauce, it’s a crowd-pleaser for those seeking traditional flavors.
The rustic decor and friendly staff create a homey environment where diners feel at ease.
Their dedication to hearty, satisfying meals makes this calamari dish a staple in Providence’s dining landscape.
Blue Water Café, Portsmouth
Blue Water Café in Portsmouth serves calamari that captures the essence of seaside dining. Lightly fried and accompanied by a zesty lemon dip, it’s a refreshing taste of the coast.
With views of the water, the cozy café provides a tranquil setting perfect for enjoying a leisurely meal.
The combination of fresh ingredients and a serene location makes this dish a highlight for those visiting Portsmouth.