One of the most talked-about cheap slices in Delaware comes from a shop mainly known for Italian water ice. It opens only from 2 to 7 in the afternoon, and its double slice gets star billing.
I love that detail. Who knew?
A great slice can show up where you least expect it, right beside a cup of homemade water ice.
That got me curious about the rest of the state. So I started digging for counters with slices ready to grab, thin crusts built for folding, and deals that keep lunch easy on your wallet.
The list includes busy downtown counters, college-town staples, and a beach spot with hand-tossed dough. One shop keeps a glass case stuffed with specialty slices, and another runs a Wednesday pizza deal.
So which one gets your next lunch break?
DiMeo’s Pizza
Downtown lunch breaks are short, and this Market Street counter seems built for that exact problem. You walk up, point at a New York-style slice, and you’re back on the sidewalk fast.
DiMeo’s Pizza keeps things simple in the best way. The menu leans on big, foldable slices and pepperoni rolls, which make a handy snack for later.
Single slices or double slices both work here, so you control the damage to your budget. That flexibility is a big reason this spot lands on a list about affordable pizza.
Want a pick that goes beyond plain cheese? The barbecue chicken pizza gets plenty of love, and it adds a sweet, smoky twist to your usual order.
Plan around the schedule, though. The shop opens at 10 AM Monday through Saturday, stays open later Thursday through Saturday, and closes on Sundays.
Parking downtown can be tricky, so walking over from a nearby office makes life easier. Afternoons on weekdays tend to be the busiest stretch, while Friday nights run quieter.
Got a crowd to feed at work? Catering is available, and high chairs are on hand if you bring little ones along.
Address: 831 N Market St, Wilmington, DE 19801
Dom’s NY Style Pizzeria
A whole counter devoted to ordering by the slice? Now that’s a pizzeria that understands your lunch plans.
Dom’s NY Style Pizzeria in Wilmington serves big, thin-crust slices with a crispy, light crust. The selection of slices is wide, so you can mix and match without committing to a whole pie.
The bacon chicken ranch pizza earns serious praise. It’s a hearty choice if plain cheese feels too tame for your mood.
Slices here run inexpensive for their size, which is the whole point when your wallet is feeling thin. Add onion rings or mozzarella sticks if you want a little extra crunch.
The menu stretches past pizza too. Wings and cheesesteaks round things out, and there’s a full vegetarian menu for meat-free eaters.
Families get plenty of support here, with a kids’ menu and high chairs. Free Wi-Fi helps if you’re squeezing in some emails between bites.
Parking is usually easy, with a free lot and street spots. Evenings late in the week get busy, so a weekday lunch may be your smoothest bet.
Address: 218 W Market St, Wilmington, DE 19804
Bernie’s the Original Italian Water Ice
Pizza and water ice in one stop sounds like a summer daydream. In Wilmington, it’s just a regular afternoon.
Bernie’s the Original Italian Water Ice is known first for its homemade water ice. The pizza, though, has built a fan base of its own, especially the double slice.
That double slice is the star of the show. It’s also wildly friendly to your budget, which makes this one of the cheapest stops on the whole list.
Timing matters here more than almost anywhere else. The shop opens daily from 2 to 7 PM, so late lunch or an early dinner is the move.
Don’t plan on a long sit-down meal. This is a takeout spot with no table service and no restroom, so grab your food and go.
Expect a line on weekend afternoons and Sundays. Monday evenings tend to be calmer if you hate waiting.
Bringing your dog on a walk? Dogs are welcome outside, which makes a pizza and water ice stroll pretty tempting.
Street parking is free but can take some hunting. Honestly, a slice and a cup of fresh water ice feel worth a lap around the block.
Address: 1701 W 8th St, Wilmington, DE 19805
Margherita’s Pizza
Compact space, generous slices, and a Main Street address in a college town. Sounds like a winning formula for hungry students and everyone else.
Margherita’s Pizza has earned its reputation as a Newark stalwart. Slices sit ready at the counter, so you can eat almost the second you decide you’re hungry.
The pizza leans New York-style, with a thin, crispy crust and a chewy edge. Flavorful sauce and cheese tie the whole thing together nicely.
Generous slices are a big part of the value here. You get a real meal without paying for a full pie.
Not in a pizza mood? Sandwiches and pasta are also on the menu, plus a full vegetarian lineup.
The room stays casual and fairly quiet, which is nice after a long class or workday. Families will find a kids’ menu and high chairs too.
Hours run from late morning into the evening Monday through Saturday, with Sundays off. Friday and Saturday evenings bring the biggest rush, so go earlier if you can.
Address: 265 S Main St, Newark, DE 19711
Tony’s Cafe
Picking one slice from a packed display case is a delightful kind of stress. Tony’s Cafe hands you that problem on purpose.
This Newark spot keeps a case stuffed with specialty gourmet slices. Classics like pepperoni and Sicilian sit right alongside the fancier options.
Crab pizza and chicken bacon ranch are part of the lineup. That’s a fun way to try something new without buying a whole pie you might not love.
Prices on those specialty slices stay reasonable, even while plenty of places keep raising theirs. That makes it easy to grab two different flavors and call it research.
Garlic rolls and pasta fill out the menu for bigger appetites. The full vegetarian menu helps if your group has mixed tastes.
The space is snug and homey, with a small-town feel. You can dine in, take out, or get delivery, and reservations are accepted.
Doors open at 10 AM Monday through Saturday, while Sunday starts at noon. Friday evening is the busy stretch, so Sunday afternoons offer more breathing room.
Address: 366 Possum Park Rd, Newark, DE 19711
Mario’s Pizza – Pasta & Wings
Grandma pizza might not sound flashy, but it sure knows how to win people over. At this Newark strip mall pizzeria, it’s the slice that gets the most buzz.
Mario’s Pizza – Pasta & Wings sells pizza by the slice, so sampling a few is easy. The NYC-style pies have thin slices with a chewy crust and a tasty sauce.
Slices come huge and loaded with toppings. One or two can fill you up, which is exactly what an affordable lunch should do.
Feeling adventurous? Sweet and sour chicken pizza is on the menu, and it’s a fun change from the usual pepperoni.
The old-school, neighborhood feel keeps things relaxed. Vegans and vegetarians both get full menus, which isn’t common at a classic slice shop.
The shop welcomes everyone and has a gender-neutral restroom. Families will spot high chairs for younger diners.
Hours run from 10 AM Monday through Saturday, later on Fridays and Saturdays, with Sundays closed. Tuesday and Friday evenings tend to get busy, so mornings are calmer.
Address: 1011 S College Ave #2305, Newark, DE 19713
Little Anthony’s Pizza
A slice and a drink deal that barely dents your pocket? Little Anthony’s makes cheap eats feel like a small victory.
This New Castle parlor serves New York-style pizza in a neighborhood setting. The prices get noticed often, from slice-and-drink combos to extra large pies.
The thin-crust pepperoni slice is a standout. It comes packed with pepperoni and that classic, slightly greasy charm pizza lovers know well.
Cheesesteaks share the spotlight, so you can switch things up on a second visit. A kids’ menu keeps younger eaters happy too.
The dining area stays clean and calm, which makes a sit-down slice pleasant. Friendly staff help keep it relaxed.
Note that there’s no delivery listed, so plan on dine-in or takeout. A private dining room is available if you’re gathering a group.
Mondays are closed, so don’t show up hungry that day. Tuesday through Sunday works, with later hours on Friday and Saturday.
Friday afternoons and evenings bring the biggest crowds. Parking is usually plentiful, with a free lot right there.
Address: 287 Christiana Rd # 10, New Castle, DE 19720
3 Countries Pizzeria
Pizza and Mexican dishes under one roof? That’s a menu that settles family arguments before they start.
3 Countries Pizzeria is a family-owned shop in New Castle. It serves Italian-inspired pizza alongside Mexican plates, which makes it a fun outlier on this list.
Stop in for a slice, and expect it fresh, hot, and crispy. The firm crust holds up well, even when you load on toppings.
Garlic knots deserve their own shout-out. They come with a flavorful marinara and cost very little, so they’re an easy add-on.
Crispy fries also make the list of favorite sides. Pair them with a slice and you’ve got a cheap, satisfying meal.
The mom-and-pop feel shows in the friendly, knowledgeable staff. Delivery is available, and the drivers have a solid reputation for speed.
Saturday hours run late, all the way to midnight, which is handy for late cravings. Weekday hours end earlier, so check the clock before heading over.
Address: 202 E 6th St, New Castle, DE 19720
Fratelli’s Italian Specialties
Wednesday deserves a little celebration, and Fratelli’s gives you a delicious excuse. This Middletown shop runs a Wednesday pizza deal that keeps people coming back.
Fratelli’s Italian Specialties is family-run, and the vibe matches. The homemade sauce is a weekly staple, and it gives the pizza real personality.
Slices here are huge. A couple of them can easily cover lunch for two, which stretches your money nicely.
The crust and cheese get plenty of praise, along with that sauce. It’s the kind of pizza that makes a plain cheese slice feel like enough.
Signature cheesesteaks are another reason to visit. Want something different?
Try the rice ball, a vegetarian bite worth adding to your order.
This is a counter and takeout operation, with no table service. Delivery is available if you’d rather eat at home.
Hours run from 11 AM Monday through Saturday, with Sundays closed. Friday and Saturday afternoons get busiest, so weekday mornings are your calm window.
Address: 2394 Dupont Pkwy, Middletown, DE 19709
Roma Pizza
Some pizza tastes like a time machine, and this Dover shop serves slices with serious 80s energy. Think classic, a little greasy, and very satisfying.
Roma Pizza on Walker Road serves NY-style pizza and cheesesteaks. Specialty pizzas are sold by the slice, so lunch can be adventurous and cheap.
The veggie pizza earns high marks. It’s a smart pick if you want toppings without the meat.
The sauce has a special taste that sets it apart. Combined with a solid crust, it makes a slice that keeps things fresh and hot.
Late-night cravings are covered here. The shop stays open until 10 PM most nights and 11 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Delivery is fairly priced, which helps when you’re stuck at home. A full vegetarian menu and a kids’ menu give everyone something to order.
Friday evenings bring the biggest crowds in Delaware’s capital city. Free parking makes a quick stop simple, any day of the week.
Address: 1047 Walker Rd, Dover, DE 19904
Caruso’s Pizza & Pasta Italian Eatery
Two big slices and a drink for a small price is the kind of math everyone enjoys. Caruso’s in Georgetown has that combo nailed.
Caruso’s Pizza & Pasta Italian Eatery serves New York-style pizza in the heart of town. The cheese slices alone have fans calling them some of the best in the state.
Expect a chewy crust, tasty sauce, and real mozzarella. That stringy cheese pull is part of the fun.
Hungry for more than plain cheese? The stuffed meat lovers pizza is loaded, and the tomato pie is a classic worth trying.
Huge cheesesteaks also come out of this kitchen, topped with lettuce and tomatoes. Pasta and comfort dishes give you even more choices.
The space stays clean and quiet, which makes a solo lunch easy. Coffee is on the menu if you need a midday pick-me-up.
Hours run every day, starting at 10 AM most mornings and 11 AM on Sundays. Wednesday and Saturday afternoons get busiest, so plan accordingly.
Address: 101 E Market St, Georgetown, DE 19947
Gio’s Pizza Co.
Beach towns can be tough on your wallet. Gio’s Pizza Co. offers a giant slice that makes an affordable lunch option during your vacation.
This Rehoboth Beach shop serves New York-style pizza. Its thin-crust slices are a convenient choice when you’re craving a quick meal near the beach.
Homemade bread and meatballs are also part of the menu. They make solid sidekicks when a slice alone won’t cut it.
Feeling curious? The New Haven pizza is a menu highlight, and it may be worth trying if you’re looking for something different.
The staff have a reputation for being kind and helpful. That matters when you’re sandy, hungry, and unsure what to order.
Hours can vary, so check before you go. The shop opens at 4 PM on Mondays and Wednesdays, and it is open on Tuesdays as well.
Curbside pickup and delivery make life easier after a long beach day. Check current parking availability before visiting, as parking near the Delaware shore can vary by season and time of day.
Friday and Saturday evenings may be busy. Grab your slice early, and save the sunset for dessert.
Address: 37169 Rehoboth Ave Ext, Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971
