The hardest part of a pizza buffet is deciding when to stop. One more slice of bubbling cheese, a different combination of toppings, or a final bite of something sweet can make a quick lunch last a little longer than planned.
Across Virginia, pizza buffets offer a relaxed way to enjoy a meal without committing to just one kind of pizza. You can sample familiar favorites, discover a new topping combination, and share the table with family or friends while everyone chooses something they love.
From Richmond to smaller towns tucked among Virginia’s scenic landscapes, these stops give hungry travelers another reason to take a break along the way.
Buffet schedules and menu options can vary, so checking ahead helps avoid disappointment, particularly at the Pizza Hut locations. Ready to find your next favorite pizza stop?
These 10 Virginia pizza buffets are worth exploring when one slice simply isn’t enough.
Budget-Friendly Bites and Game Breaks at Cicis in Richmond
The best part of a buffet might be the moment nobody has to agree on a topping. At Cicis Pizza on Richmond’s Busy Street, different tastes can share one table without sharing one pie.
The location at 11549 Busy St offers pizza, pasta, salads, and desserts, with a game room adding another reason for families to settle in. Start with a familiar slice, then look over the other pizzas before choosing your next round.
Keep the first plate small so you can enjoy food while it is warm rather than stacking up slices that cool at the table. A little salad or pasta gives everyone a change of pace, and leaving room for dessert is usually a sound plan.
For parents, the practical move is setting a separate game budget before lunch begins. Check current admission prices, drink costs, and operating hours before leaving home, since those details can change.
Between the food choices and the chance to play, this Richmond stop can make a regular meal feel like a modest family outing without requiring an elaborate plan or a special occasion.
A Truce for Picky Eaters at Cicis in Henrico
One person wants plain cheese, another wants something with a little more bite, and lunch suddenly becomes a debate. A buffet offers a simple way around that familiar family problem.
Along West Broad Street, Cicis Pizza at 7516 W Broad St in Henrico brings several pizza choices together with pasta, salad, and dessert. The appeal is less about choosing the perfect order and more about letting each person build a meal that suits them.
Take a quick look along the counter before picking anything up. You may spot a topping combination worth trying beside your usual favorite, and smaller portions make that experiment easier.
Since the selection can rotate, treat specific specialty pizzas as possibilities rather than promises.
This is a useful stop when a shopping day or busy afternoon leaves everyone hungry at once. Ask about children’s pricing, whether beverages cost extra, and the current buffet schedule before paying.
Once seated, there is no need to turn lunch into a race; another small plate can wait until you have finished the first and decided what you actually want next.
Follow Your Appetite to Cicis in Lynchburg
A first slice can be a safe choice; the second is where curiosity gets a turn. That small freedom gives a pizza buffet its charm, especially when your group arrives with very different appetites.
In Lynchburg, Cicis Pizza at 3700 Candlers Mountain Rd offers an unlimited spread of classic and specialty pizzas, plus pasta, salads, and desserts. It makes a straightforward meal stop when you would rather sample a few things than commit to one large pizza.
Try pairing a familiar topping with something you have not ordered before, taking only what you expect to finish. Check the counter again later instead of assuming the opening selection is the whole story.
A fresh tray may offer a different choice, though the day’s lineup will vary.
For a smoother visit, confirm buffet hours and the full meal price, including drinks, before setting out. Anyone with food allergies should speak with staff about ingredients and shared serving areas.
The pleasure here is uncomplicated: a table together, several possible directions for dinner, and enough flexibility to let everyone find their own favorite along the way.
Trade Road Miles for Pizza at Cicis in Harrisonburg
After a stretch of highway, even a simple meal can feel like a welcome change of scenery. Getting out of the car, sitting together, and choosing lunch without a long debate can reset the whole afternoon.
Cicis Pizza at 2035 E Market St in Harrisonburg fits that kind of break. Its casual buffet offers unlimited pizza and dessert choices, giving travelers and families a chance to settle down before returning to their plans.
Rather than filling a plate immediately, walk the line and see what looks good. Begin with a couple of slices, then decide whether another pizza or something sweet deserves the next visit.
That approach keeps lunch relaxed and helps avoid wasting food when road trip hunger turns out to be smaller than expected.
Check the restaurant’s hours against your arrival time, especially if traffic could push you past the usual lunch period. Ask about current buffet pricing and available sides rather than relying on an older menu photo.
A stop here works best as an easy pause in the day, with enough choice to make another slice seem perfectly reasonable.
Let Everyone Choose at Cicis in Colonial Heights
Little victories count on a family outing, including a meal where everyone finds something they want. Pizza buffets make room for that happy outcome without requiring a separate order for every person at the table.
On Temple Avenue, Cicis Pizza at 1072 Temple Ave, Suite 140, gives Colonial Heights diners a family-oriented buffet option. Pizza anchors the meal, while other buffet choices offer a chance to switch things up between slices.
Let children look over the selection before helping them choose manageable portions. Picking one familiar food and one small taste of something different can keep the meal fun without turning it into a challenge.
Adults can do the same, especially when several pies make the decision harder than expected.
Before visiting, confirm current hours, prices, and which foods are included in the buffet. Larger groups should also ask about seating rather than assuming nearby tables will be available.
The attraction is the freedom to eat together while making different choices, a small convenience that can leave more room for conversation and less time spent negotiating what belongs on everyone’s shared pizza.
Make a Small-Plate Tour at Cicis in Roanoke
There is a pleasant kind of indecision that comes with several pizzas in front of you. Instead of solving it with one large order, you can try a little, pause, and see which flavor earns another visit.
At Cicis Pizza, 1413 Towne Square Blvd NW in Roanoke, that sampling approach suits the value-focused buffet. Pizza varieties, sides, and desserts let diners put together a meal without making every choice at the register.
Think of the first plate as a short tasting round rather than the entire dinner. Choose a couple of slices that differ from each other, then add a side if you want a break from cheese and crust.
Save dessert for when you know how much appetite remains.
A buffet can help with meal planning, but check the complete cost before assuming it fits your budget. Drinks, children’s rates, and any separate purchases deserve a quick look.
Confirm operating hours as well, since online listings can lag behind changes. For a casual Roanoke meal, the appeal lies in that easy rhythm of choosing, tasting, and returning only for what sounds good.
Ask About Your Favorite at Cicis in Winchester
An empty spot where your favorite pizza should be does not always mean you have missed your chance. Sometimes the smartest move at a buffet is simply asking what the kitchen can make.
Cicis Pizza at 2059 S Pleasant Valley Rd, Suite 115, in Winchester offers pizza alongside pasta, salads, sides, and desserts. Cicis also encourages guests to ask about a pizza that is not currently on the buffet, subject to ingredients and local availability.
Make that request early in the meal, then enjoy something else while staff explain what is possible. A request is not a promise of instant service or every imaginable topping, so a little patience helps.
It can still turn an ordinary buffet visit into a meal that feels more personal.
Keep your first helping modest if you are waiting for a particular pie. Check current buffet hours and pricing before arriving, and ask staff directly about dietary needs rather than guessing from appearance.
With several courses to choose from, this Winchester stop rewards a slower approach: browse, ask a friendly question, and leave some room for whatever comes next.
Find an Old-School Meal at Pizza Inn in Christiansburg
Cheese stretching from a fresh slice needs very little explanation. It brings the meal back to simple pleasures: warm crust, a favorite topping, and the chance to sit down without making dinner yourself.
Pizza Inn at 190 N Franklin St in Christiansburg offers a traditional buffet with choices beyond basic cheese and pepperoni. Salad and dessert options help turn a few slices into a longer, more varied meal.
Look over the specialty pies before settling on your usual order. A small serving lets you test a new combination without giving up space for a familiar favorite.
The exact selection can change, so ask what is available rather than counting on a particular pizza seen in an older review.
This is a sensible place to consider when your group wants a straightforward sit-down meal with some room for discovery. Confirm buffet service times, current prices, and drink charges before going, especially if you are traveling from another town.
Once there, keep a little appetite for the dessert choices; comparing a savory slice with a sweet finish is part of what makes this buffet format enjoyable.
Save a Little Space at Pizza Inn Buffet in Abingdon
The final decision may be the hardest one: another savory slice or a taste of dessert pizza? Leaving a little space makes that choice much more enjoyable than discovering the sweets after you are already full.
At Pizza Inn Buffet, 794 W Main St in Abingdon, several pizza styles share the meal with salad and dessert pizzas. The range gives diners a reason to look beyond the first tray and build lunch in small stages.
A salad can provide a fresh contrast between richer slices, while dessert pizza changes the ending without requiring a separate restaurant stop. Ask which varieties are being served that day, since specialty toppings and sweet options are not guaranteed to follow a fixed lineup.
If your Abingdon plans include a performance at Barter Theatre, allow enough time to eat without watching the clock through every bite. Check the buffet schedule directly before arranging your day around it.
The experience works best when you can browse at your own pace, enjoy a few different flavors, and make that last small plate a deliberate treat rather than an afterthought.
Take the Regional Route to Pizza Plus in St. Paul
A smaller town can change the pace of a food stop. Instead of scanning only for the biggest national name, you have a chance to try a regional chain that belongs more closely to the surrounding area.
Pizza Plus at 16415 Wise St in St. Paul offers that change of direction, with a pizza buffet and salad bar. Its regional identity sets it apart from the larger chains that fill much of this list.
Keep the meal simple: a few slices, a salad with the ingredients you enjoy, and time to decide whether another helping sounds good. Ask about the day’s pizza selection rather than expecting every item from the broader menu to appear on the buffet.
Availability and serving times can vary.
St. Paul sits along the Clinch River, giving travelers another local point of interest beyond lunch. If you plan to explore town or nearby outdoor areas, check conditions and access separately from your restaurant plans.
Call Pizza Plus before making a special trip to confirm buffet hours and pricing. The reward is a modest, satisfying pause with a different regional accent.
