One Richmond pizza shop keeps its ovens going until 2:30 AM, seven nights a week. That alone made me sit up a little straighter.
Then I kept finding more. A family of pizza shops across Virginia names each spot after a made-up Benny, and their slices are famously huge.
Another place sits near the ocean, where a slice can travel straight to the sand.
I love that cheap, honest pizza still exists. Prices on almost everything keep climbing, yet a hot slice can still be an affordable lunch.
To me, that feels like a small win worth celebrating.
This list covers college towns, beach blocks, and busy downtown streets. Each stop sells pizza by the slice, so you can eat well without emptying your wallet.
1. Benny Marzano’s
Ever ordered one slice and needed a strategy to finish it? That’s the normal experience at this Blacksburg counter.
Benny Marzano’s serves giant, thin-crust, New York-style slices and whole pies. A single slice comes out gigantic, so plan your appetite accordingly.
The location fits right into this college town. You’ll find it on Draper Road, just steps from the bustle of downtown.
Late hours are a big part of the appeal. The shop stays open until midnight most nights and until 2 AM on Fridays and Saturdays.
That makes it a reliable stop after a game, a study session, or a long evening out. Friday and Saturday nights tend to be the busiest stretch.
Ordering happens at the counter, with no table service and no reservations. Grab your slice, find a seat, and dig in.
Prefer fresh air? Outdoor seating is available, and dogs are welcome outside.
Families can relax too, since high chairs are on hand. Delivery and takeout work well if you’d rather eat at home.
Parking can be a little tricky nearby, so give yourself a few extra minutes. Trust me, that oversized slice is worth the short hunt.
Address: 110 B Draper Rd NW, Blacksburg, VA 24060
2. Benny Marconi’s
Old school rock and roll on the speakers and slices the size of a small surfboard. Downtown Roanoke has a fun lunch plan waiting.
Benny Marconi’s is a lively pizza restaurant known for huge, New York-style slices. It sits on Campbell Avenue in the heart of downtown.
The menu goes beyond plain cheese, too. A full vegetarian menu means meat-free eaters get plenty of choices.
Thirsty? Look for sodas made with real sugar, a fun throwback to pair with your slice.
Service is fast and handled at the counter. You won’t need a reservation, which makes it easy to pop in whenever hunger hits.
Night owls, take note. The shop stays open until 2 AM on Fridays and Saturdays, and Saturday night is the busiest time.
Visiting with kids? High chairs are available, and the spot works well for families and groups.
Outdoor seating gives you a chance to people-watch downtown. Dogs can join you outside.
Street parking and nearby garages are options, though spaces can fill up. A short walk just helps you build an appetite for that massive slice.
Address: 120 East Campbell Ave., Roanoke, VA 24011
3. Christian’s Pizza
Avocado on pizza? In Charlottesville, that’s simply part of the lineup.
Christian’s Pizza serves New York-style slices alongside a wide range of specialty pies. Toppings like avocado, tomato, and spinach help this spot stand out from basic pepperoni joints.
Picking just one slice can feel like a real challenge. The good news is you can mix and match without committing to a whole pie.
The crust gets plenty of attention here. It’s crispy, and the toppings are generous.
Timing matters at this location. Monday through Wednesday and Sunday, doors close at 9 PM.
Thursday through Saturday, though, the shop stays open until midnight. That’s late-night slice territory, and Friday evenings get especially busy.
Service is quick and handled at the counter. There’s no table service, so step up, point at what looks good, and you’re set.
Vegetarians will feel right at home with the full meat-free menu. Kids are welcome, and groups fit in easily.
Parking is a bonus, with a free lot plus free street spaces. In a busy college city like this, that’s a small treat before your bigger one.
Address: 601 5th St SW, Charlottesville, VA 22902
4. Benny Vitali’s
Small room, big slices. That’s the simple math at this Caroline Street favorite in historic downtown Fredericksburg.
Benny Vitali’s is a compact counter-serve shop with sizable pizza slices and whole pies. If you’re extra hungry, a giant pie is always an option.
Expect a crispy crust and a well-seasoned sauce. The toppings hold their own, too.
Seating is limited inside, so think about timing. Friday and Saturday evenings tend to get crowded, and a short wait is common.
Want a calmer visit? Tuesday and Wednesday mornings are usually the quietest windows.
Hours run until 11 PM most nights and midnight on weekends. That makes it handy after an evening stroll through downtown.
Outdoor seating offers extra room when the weather cooperates. Dogs are welcome outside, so your four-legged friend can tag along.
Craving something sweet afterward? Dessert is on the menu as well.
Parking downtown can be tricky, with a mix of free and paid street spots. Arrive a little early, grab your slice, and enjoy one of the easiest affordable meals in town.
Address: 722 Caroline St, Fredericksburg, VA 22401
5. Handover By The Slice
Pizza and arcade games under one roof? Old Town Alexandria clearly understands how fun should work.
Handover By The Slice is a casual spot on King Street built around late-night pizza by the slice. The arcade games add a playful twist you won’t find at most pizza counters.
The slices lean New York style, with a crispy crust and a balanced cheese-to-sauce ratio. Toppings taste fresh and classic.
Hours stretch later as the week goes on. Thursday runs until midnight, Friday until 1 AM, and Saturday until 2 AM.
You can order at the counter for speed. Service is fast, which helps when hunger is loud.
The menu also includes small plates and desserts. A full vegetarian menu means plenty of options for meat-free diners.
Kids are welcome, and high chairs are available. That makes it a solid pick for families exploring Old Town.
Outdoor seating lets you enjoy the King Street energy. Delivery and takeout are options too.
Parking is paid street parking and can be hard to find. Walking over from another part of Old Town might be your smartest move.
Address: 728 King St, Alexandria, VA 22314
6. Jo-Jo’s Pizza
Framed photos of New York City buildings line the walls here. Fitting, since the pizza borrows its style from the same place.
Jo-Jo’s Pizza is a window-filled, counter-serve pizzeria on East Main Street in downtown Richmond. Local sports banners add some hometown pride to the room.
The menu covers New York-style pies and slices. Salads and subs round things out, including eggplant parm and steak and cheese options.
Slices come big, with a crispy crust and a nice doughy flavor. It’s an easy lunch when you want something fast and filling.
Pay close attention to the schedule. Jo-Jo’s runs Monday through Friday from 9 AM to 3 PM and closes on weekends.
That makes it a weekday lunch champion for downtown workers. Weekday afternoons are often the busiest time to stop in.
Friday mornings tend to be quieter. Early arrivals might enjoy a calmer counter.
Ordering is simple, with quick service and no table service. Dine in, take it to go, or get it delivered.
Parking nearby is paid street parking. Plan on a few coins and a quick lunch break you’ll actually look forward to.
Address: 1201 E Main St, Richmond, VA 23219
7. The Pizza Place
Open until 2:30 AM, every single day of the week. Richmond night owls, this one has your name on it.
The Pizza Place on East Main Street turns out NYC-style pies and generous slices. It’s a casual joint built for quick, satisfying bites at almost any hour.
The menu brings a few fun surprises. Jamaican beef patties, calzones, and strombolis share space with the pizza.
Specialty pies include a Lasagna Pizza, which sounds like two comfort foods teaming up. A classic NY Pizza is on the menu too.
Here’s a helpful detail for many diners. The shop is pork-free and uses beef pepperoni.
Service is fast and handled at the counter. You can dine in, take your slice to go, or order delivery.
Friday night tends to be the busiest stretch. Saturday morning is usually the calmest.
College students make up a good share of the crowd. That makes sense for a spot that feeds people long after other kitchens close.
Free street parking nearby is a nice perk. Swing by late, grab a slice, and call it a successful night.
Address: 1731 E Main St, Richmond, VA 23223
8. Benny Damato’s Pizza
A slice that folds without flopping is a beautiful thing. Downtown Norfolk serves that kind of engineering on Granby Street.
Benny Damato’s Pizza is known for massive, thin-crust New York-style slices. The crust is crispy yet chewy, and the sauce and cheese balance well.
Toppings get creative here. One popular combination brings chicken, bacon, and ranch together on a single giant slice.
Want something to sip? IBC root beer is on the menu, a fun classic to pair with pizza.
This is one of several Benny-named shops around Virginia. Each one carries the same big-slice spirit with its own personality.
Hours run until 10 PM most nights and 1 AM on Fridays and Saturdays. Tuesday evenings and Friday nights tend to be busy.
Families will find high chairs and a full vegetarian menu. Free wi-fi is available if you need to check messages between bites.
Dogs are welcome, including on the outdoor seating. Catering is an option for parties.
Parking downtown is often tough to find. Consider a nearby garage and save your energy for that huge slice.
Address: 131 Granby St b, Norfolk, VA 23510
9. Benny’s On The Ocean
Two slices can fill a large pizza box here. That’s not a typo, and it’s a great reason to bring friends.
Benny’s On The Ocean sits on Atlantic Avenue near the Virginia Beach oceanfront. It serves giant New York-style slices that taste like summer vacation.
The crust is buttery and flaky with a crispy bottom. Slices come out hot and ready to travel straight to the sand.
The menu stays simple, which keeps ordering easy. Service is fast and friendly, perfect after a long beach morning.
A full vegetarian menu gives meat-free eaters solid choices. Dessert is available too.
Weekend afternoons and Sunday afternoons tend to be busy. Weeknights after the beach crowd thins out are usually calmer.
Hours run until 10 PM most nights and midnight on Fridays and Saturdays. Late beach walks can end with pizza.
Outdoor seating lets you keep the ocean breeze. Dogs are welcome outside, so your pup can enjoy the view.
Parking near the oceanfront is mostly paid and fills up quickly. Walking from your hotel may be the easiest way to claim your oversized slice.
Address: 1608 Atlantic Ave, Virginia Beach, VA 23451
10. Sal’s NY Slice Pizzeria
Plain cheese pizza is the ultimate test. Pass it, and you’ve earned trust.
Sal’s NY Slice Pizzeria in Virginia Beach handles that test with confidence. The cheese slice features a thin crust, tangy sauce, and nicely salty cheese.
Toppings come generously, with fresh mushrooms among the favorites. Non-pork topping options are available, which helps many diners.
Best of all, you can buy pizza by the slice. A filling lunch can easily stay under ten dollars.
The menu also covers classic Italian staples beyond pizza. Dessert is there for anyone saving room.
Families get plenty of thoughtful touches. A kids’ menu, high chairs, and changing tables make visits with little ones easier.
Unlike most slice shops, Sal’s accepts reservations. That’s handy for groups planning a pizza night.
The atmosphere stays casual and fairly quiet. Evenings tend to be busiest, while Sunday nights are calmer.
Parking is a breeze with a free lot and plenty of space. After so many hunts for street spots across Virginia, that might be the sweetest bonus on this list.
Address: 4676 Princess Anne Rd #170, Virginia Beach, VA 23462
