One pie shop on this list bakes its sweet potato pie in a crust that won a State Fair blue ribbon. Another bakery only sells its sweet potato pies during the autumn months.
I love that kind of stubbornness. It tells me somebody takes this humble orange pie very seriously.
North Carolina grows a lot of sweet potatoes, so the bar here is high. The bakers on this list include a pop-up running on a recipe passed through three generations.
There’s also a shop that turns the flavor into rolled ice cream.
I can’t think of a better excuse for a road trip. Which slice would you hunt down first?
Slice Pie Company
A blue ribbon from the North Carolina State Fair is a pretty great thing to put on a pie crust. Slice Pie Company in Raleigh earned that recognition with its signature apple pie and its award-winning biscuit-style crust.
The shop began with a father and daughter’s shared passion for baking pies. Each recipe draws on family traditions, so the lineup has some real roots behind it.
That award-winning crust is often compared to a flaky biscuit. Picture that holding up a creamy sweet potato filling, and you’ll see the appeal.
Sweet potato sits on the menu next to options like apple, coconut cream, key lime, and lemon with homemade raspberry glaze. You could easily leave with more than one pie, and nobody would judge you.
The family-owned business focuses on handcrafted Southern pies made with recipes passed down through generations. It also offers nationwide shipping, catering, and custom pies for special occasions.
Plan your pickup, though. Slice Pie Company has a permanent pie case inside Clyde Cooper’s Barbecue at 1326 E Millbrook Road in Raleigh.
Rotating slices are available for walk-in pickup, while whole pies can be preordered online.
Availability can vary by day, so check the company’s website before heading over. You can also order ahead to make sure your favorite flavor is waiting.
Go for a quick visit, grab a slice, and take a whole pie home if you can resist eating it first. Your kitchen table will thank you.
Address: 1326 E Millbrook Rd, Raleigh, NC 27609
Dewey’s Bakery
Patience is part of the recipe at Dewey’s Bakery. Its sweet potato pies show up during the autumn months, so you have to wait for the leaves to turn.
That seasonal rule makes the pie feel like an event in Winston-Salem. When fall arrives, so does a reason to swing by Stratford Road.
Dewey’s is a traditional bakery known for custom cakes and a wide spread of sweet treats. Sweet potato fans can look for both full pies and smaller sweet potato tarts.
Planning a holiday table? Large pies have long been a popular pick for families stocking up for big gatherings.
Out of season, you won’t leave empty-handed. The case also holds goodies like chess tarts and napoleons, plus coffee to sip on the way out.
The hours are friendly to busy schedules. Dewey’s opens at 8 AM Monday through Saturday and stays open until 9 PM.
Sunday hours run from 11 AM to 6 PM. Sunday morning tends to be one of the calmer times to pop in.
There’s no dine-in here, so think of it as a grab-and-go mission. A free parking lot makes the trip easy.
Address: 262 S Stratford Rd, Winston-Salem, NC 27103
Sweet D’s Cuisine
Croissants might be the headliner at Sweet D’s Cuisine, but a tiny pie steals plenty of attention. The mini sweet potato pies are the move for fans of the classic.
Small pies have big perks. You get your own crust, your own filling, and zero arguments about who cut the bigger slice.
This family-owned Wilmington bakery specializes in artisanal croissants and a variety of sweet treats. The menu also includes apple fritters, cinnamon rolls, macaroons, and coated croissants.
Early birds, rejoice. Sweet D’s opens at 6 AM Monday through Saturday, and breakfast and coffee are part of the deal.
That means a mini pie can count as breakfast dessert. We won’t tell anyone.
The team also handles catering and even wedding cakes. Staff here are known for being friendly and attentive.
Want a calmer visit? Monday and Wednesday afternoons tend to be quieter, while Friday and Saturday mornings get busy.
The bakery closes at 5 PM and stays closed on Sunday. Dine-in, takeout, and delivery are all options, with free parking nearby.
Address: 2321 S 17th St, Wilmington, NC 28401
Premier Cakes
Sweet potato gets two starring roles at Premier Cakes. You can grab it as a classic pie or as a moist layered cake.
The pie filling is known for being smooth and creamy. It balances earthy sweet potato flavor with spices like cinnamon and nutmeg.
Then there’s the Sweet Potato Cake, one of the shop’s menu highlights. It’s a smart choice when you want that fall flavor with frosting on top.
This Raleigh bakery makes its cakes and pies from scratch without preservatives. That’s the kind of detail that makes a dessert taste like somebody cared.
Can’t pick just one flavor? The slice lineup runs from red velvet and German chocolate to hummingbird, tres leches, and a 4 layer Jamaican carrot cake.
Here’s a timing tip. The doors open at noon each day, so this is an afternoon treat rather than a morning one.
Weekday hours run until 7 PM. Saturday closes at 6 PM, and Sunday wraps up at 4 PM.
There’s no dine-in, so carry your treasure home. Free parking keeps the stop quick.
Address: 6617 Falls of Neuse Rd #105, Raleigh, NC 27615
Sweet Momma Pies LLC
Sweet potato pie is the specialty at Sweet Momma Pies LLC. It’s the kind of classic Southern dessert that brings family gatherings and holiday tables to mind.
This Raleigh-based small business focuses on homemade sweet potato pies rather than a long list of different baked goods.
There’s something appealing about a business built around one classic dessert. Instead of a massive menu, the focus stays on a familiar Southern favorite.
Sweet potato pie has a long history in Southern kitchens, where family recipes and traditional baking methods have helped keep the dessert popular across generations.
Getting your hands on a pie takes a little planning. Before making the trip, contact Sweet Momma Pies to confirm current ordering arrangements and pickup availability.
That makes it worth considering for holidays, birthdays, or a Sunday supper. Order ahead if possible, and you can bring a classic dessert to the table without touching a mixing bowl.
Since the business does not appear to operate like a conventional walk-in bakery, check its current pickup arrangements before visiting.
Address: Raleigh, NC (confirm the public pickup location before publishing).
Sweet Porpos Rolled Ice Cream & Bakeshop
Sweet potato pie gets a frosty makeover in Winterville. Sweet Porpos turns the flavor into made-to-order Thai rolled ice cream.
Yes, you read that right. Your favorite holiday pie can arrive as cold, curled rolls in a cup.
Sweet potato pie appears as a flavor option, and you can order it in a 4 oz size. That’s handy if you want a taste before going bigger.
The shop also bakes its own goods. Look for items like banana pudding, strawberry cheesecake, and a honey bun cake with real sweet potato flavor.
This small eastern North Carolina stop has a casual, quiet feel. It works for solo treats, family outings, and groups of friends.
Kids fit right in here. Picking flavors is half the fun.
The shop closes on Monday. Tuesday through Thursday hours run from 10 AM to 8 PM.
Friday and Saturday stretch to 9 PM, while Sunday runs from noon to 5 PM. Weekday mornings tend to be calm, so that’s your shortcut to skipping a crowd.
Address: 701 W Fire Tower Rd Unit B, Winterville, NC 28590
Baked Pie Company
A good pie can make an ordinary afternoon feel a little more special, and Baked Pie Company in Arden, North Carolina, gives dessert lovers plenty of reasons to stop in. This locally owned bakery has been welcoming customers since 2016, with homemade pies made from fresh ingredients and plenty of tempting flavors to discover.
Sweet potato pie is a Southern classic, loved for its smooth, comforting filling and warm, familiar flavor. If you’re hoping to find it here, check the bakery’s daily selection before visiting.
The pie flavors rotate, so the choices can change from one day to the next.
One fun way to sample the selection is to order a Pie Flight. You can choose three smaller slices and enjoy them with a scoop of ice cream, making it easier to try more than one flavor without committing to a whole pie.
Whether you’re picking up dessert to share or settling in for a sweet afternoon treat, Baked Pie Company offers a welcoming place to enjoy a slice of something homemade. Check the current menu or call ahead to ask whether sweet potato pie is available.
Address: 4 Long Shoals Rd, Suite A, Arden, NC 28704, USA
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
Some pies are made for the holidays, and the sweet potato pie at Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop brings a little Southern comfort to the table.
This locally owned shop in Huntersville is all about handmade pies, with recipes inspired by traditional Southern baking. The selection includes familiar favorites and seasonal treats, so there is always something tempting to discover.
The sweet potato pie has its own special touch. A smooth sweet potato filling gets topped with ginger whip and candied pecans, adding a little spice and crunch to every slice.
It is a cozy combination that feels right at home on a holiday dessert table.
I like that this pie doesn’t stop at the classic filling. The ginger whip brings a fresh, lightly spiced finish, while the candied pecans add sweetness and texture.
It’s the kind of dessert that can turn a simple family gathering into something a little more memorable.
Planning to bring one home? The shop offers full-size pies, making this a convenient option for sharing with family and friends.
Sweet potato pie is listed as a holiday offering, though availability may depend on the season, so check the current menu before making the trip.
You can also explore the shop’s other handmade flavors, including pecan, apple, chocolate cream, and Southern custard. Whether you’re planning a holiday meal or simply craving a taste of Southern baking, this pie shop is worth a stop.
Address: 16836 D Birkdale Commons Pkwy, Huntersville, NC 28078, USA
Burney’s Sweets & More
Sweet potato pie is one of those desserts that feels right at home on a Southern table, and Burney’s Sweets & More in Raleigh gives you a reason to make room for a slice.
This locally owned, family-operated bakery is known for its wide selection of baked treats. Glazed croissants, cakes, pastries, and donuts share the menu with a variety of pies, including this traditional favorite.
The sweet potato pie comes as a full 9-inch pie, sized to serve around six to eight people. That makes it a lovely option for a family dinner, holiday gathering, or any occasion when you want to bring something sweet to share.
I like that you can choose from so many different pie flavors here, but sweet potato has a special place among Southern desserts. Its familiar, comforting character makes it an easy choice for anyone who enjoys classic homemade-style baking.
There is just one thing to remember before you go. The online ordering menu says the sweet potato pie requires 48 hours’ notice, so this is not necessarily a grab-and-go treat.
Plan ahead, place your order, and give the bakery time to prepare it.
Whether you’re setting the table for a holiday or bringing dessert to a get-together, Burney’s makes it easier to arrive with a whole pie ready to share.
Address: 4500 Falls of Neuse Rd, Suite 100, Raleigh, NC 27609, USA
