This Small-Town Iowa Steakhouse Serves the Kind of Prime Rib Supper You Dress Up For

The prime rib here only shows up on Friday and Saturday nights. Somehow, that makes the whole weekend feel like a countdown.

It comes out thick, juicy, and rosy pink in the center. The steaks are dry-aged and cut in-house.

Dessert includes something called Black Dirt Cake, which I find impossible to ignore.

The steakhouse sits on a quiet country road surrounded by open Iowa fields. People drive out on purpose, and weekend tables fill fast.

A fireplace, antiques, and a supper club feel set the mood once you arrive.

You don’t actually have to dress up. I still think a meal this classic deserves a clean shirt and a little extra effort.

Some suppers simply feel like an occasion, and this one clearly earns that spot.

The Prime Rib Is the Reason Your Weekend Plans Just Changed

The Prime Rib Is the Reason Your Weekend Plans Just Changed
© That Place Steakhouse

Friday and Saturday nights belong to one plate at That Place Steakhouse. The prime rib is the headline act, and everything else kind of plays backup.

It arrives thick and juicy, with a rosy pink center that makes the whole table go quiet. That’s the kind of slice you plan a week around, not a last-minute craving.

Timing matters here more than you’d think. Since prime rib is a weekend thing, a Tuesday visit means you’ll be picking something else from the menu.

That’s not a bad problem to have, but it’s worth knowing before you make the drive. Mark your calendar for Friday or Saturday if this cut is your goal.

A baked potato makes a classic partner on the plate. It’s often loaded with butter and sour cream, which feels exactly right next to a slab of beef.

Add a crisp lettuce salad and you’ve got a supper that feels straight out of a different era. Honestly, that’s the whole charm.

One more practical tip from me. Wear something with a little stretch, because generous portions mean you may be heading home with a doggy bag.

Steak Lovers Get Dry-Aged Cuts Trimmed Right in the Kitchen

Steak Lovers Get Dry-Aged Cuts Trimmed Right in the Kitchen
© That Place Steakhouse

Not a prime rib person on a Tuesday? No worries, because the steak lineup has serious backup power.

The kitchen cuts tender, dry-aged steaks in-house. You’ll find ribeye, sirloin, and filet, which covers pretty much every steak mood a person can have.

Dry aging is a slow process that helps beef develop deeper flavor. It takes patience, and patience is exactly what you want from someone handling your dinner.

Cutting steaks in-house also means the kitchen controls every piece. That’s a small detail with a big effect on what lands on your plate.

The ribeye suits anyone who likes a richer bite. A filet feels a bit more refined, while sirloin hits that sweet spot for a classic steak night.

My advice is to pick based on your appetite, not your ego. Portions here run generous, and leftovers are basically part of the plan.

Pair your steak with the classic sides and you’ll get the full throwback experience. A baked potato and crisp salad never really go out of style, especially out in the Iowa countryside.

That old-school combo is part of why this place still feels so special after all these years.

Say Hello to the Broasted Iowa Chop Before It Steals the Show

Say Hello to the Broasted Iowa Chop Before It Steals the Show
© That Place Steakhouse

Here’s a twist on a steakhouse menu that makes total sense in this state. The broasted Iowa chop stands as one of the most talked-about plates in the house.

Iowa and pork go together like fields and fences. Seeing a thick chop given the broasted treatment feels like a proud local salute.

Broasting combines pressure and frying for a golden outside. It’s the same cooking style that made broasted chicken a Midwest favorite for decades.

Speaking of which, broasted chicken is on the menu too. So if your group can’t agree, you’ve got two crispy options to argue over.

I love that this steakhouse doesn’t force everyone into beef. Some nights call for a big chop, and the kitchen clearly respects that.

It’s also a smart pick if someone in your party wants something hearty but different. Nobody feels left out when the alternatives carry this much personality.

Cottage fries show up as a side option here as well. Pairing them with a broasted chop sounds like the kind of dinner you’d tell your friends about the next day.

Just don’t be surprised when that box comes home with you.

Seafood Fans Have More Than a Few Reasons to Show Up

Seafood Fans Have More Than a Few Reasons to Show Up
© That Place Steakhouse

Massive walleye on a steakhouse menu in the middle of farm country? Yep, and it’s not hiding in a corner either.

That Place Steakhouse serves big walleye and fried catfish for anyone craving fish. Both feel right at home in the Midwest, where a good fish fry is close to a tradition.

Mini shrimp also make an appearance on the menu. They’re a fun option for lighter eaters or anyone who wants a little something extra alongside dinner.

Then there’s the seafood salad, which often shows up on weekends. It’s a popular pick, so grab it when you see it.

Mixed groups will appreciate this variety most. One person orders prime rib, another orders walleye, and suddenly the table looks like a feast.

That kind of flexibility makes planning a group supper much easier. Nobody needs to compromise on what they actually want to eat.

My tip is to ask your server what’s available that night. Weekend specials can shift, and a friendly heads-up might steer you toward something great.

A seafood night out here still feels like a proper occasion, even miles from any coastline.

Black Dirt Cake Sounds Odd Until You Hear the Rest

Black Dirt Cake Sounds Odd Until You Hear the Rest
© That Place Steakhouse

Ordering something called Black Dirt Cake takes a certain bravery. Lucky for you, it’s a dessert, not a gardening project.

The name alone earns a spot on my must-try list. It sits on the dessert menu at That Place Steakhouse alongside other sweet temptations.

Pecan pie is another option for anyone who loves a nutty, classic finish. The kitchen also serves what’s been called prize-winning pie, which is a pretty bold title to live up to.

I respect a steakhouse that takes dessert this seriously. After a heavy supper, a good slice of pie feels less like a choice and more like a tradition.

Here’s the practical part. Portions are generous all night, so you may want to plan ahead.

Sharing dessert with the table works great. You could also pack it up and enjoy it later at home, which honestly stretches the fun into the next day.

Ask your server which pies are available that evening. Selections can change, and a quick question might lead you to a new favorite.

Either way, skipping dessert here seems like a mistake I wouldn’t want to make.

A Fireplace and Antiques Set the Supper Club Mood

A Fireplace and Antiques Set the Supper Club Mood
© That Place Steakhouse

Cozy is the first word that comes to mind with this dining room. A fireplace anchors the space, and antiques show up throughout the restaurant.

The décor leans rustic-chic, which fits the countryside setting perfectly. It feels like a throwback supper club that never lost its sense of fun.

That nostalgic charm is a big part of the appeal. Plenty of restaurants try to recreate this look, but here it feels genuinely earned.

Now, about dressing up. You don’t actually need to, because the atmosphere stays relaxed and unpretentious.

Still, the mood practically invites a nice sweater or a pressed shirt. A prime rib supper by a fireplace just feels like an event worth honoring.

Expect some energy too. The dining room can get lively and loud, especially when the weekend crowd fills every table.

That buzz is part of the experience, not a drawback. It sounds like a hometown gathering where everybody came hungry and happy.

If you want a quieter evening, a weeknight visit might suit you better. Either way, the warm setting makes a great backdrop for birthdays, anniversaries, or simply celebrating a Friday.

New Owners Kept the Old Recipes Close to Home

New Owners Kept the Old Recipes Close to Home
© That Place Steakhouse

Change can make longtime fans nervous, especially at a beloved steakhouse. Thankfully, this story has a happy twist.

Brittany Sanderson, a Conrad native, and her husband Mike Davis took over That Place Steakhouse in early 2025. They bought it from Jeff DeNeui and Sandy Gibbs, who ran it for nearly two decades.

Here’s the part I love most. Jeff stayed on staff to handle morning prep work and share the famous recipes.

That means the flavors people drive out for didn’t vanish with the sale. It’s like inheriting a family cookbook along with the person who wrote it.

The entire staff also stayed onboard during the switch. For a place built on hospitality, keeping familiar faces matters a lot.

The new owners have a clear goal too. They want to protect the nostalgic charm that made this steakhouse a destination in the first place.

A newer addition has joined the menu as well. The open-faced Hot Prime Rib sandwich comes with mashed potatoes, and it sounds like comfort food royalty.

Fresh energy plus old favorites feels like a pretty smart recipe for the next chapter.

Call Ahead or You Might Be Watching From the Parking Lot

Call Ahead or You Might Be Watching From the Parking Lot
© That Place Steakhouse

Weekend nights here get busy, and cars can line the blacktop outside. That’s a pretty clear sign you should plan ahead.

Reservations are recommended, especially on Friday and Saturday. Those are prime rib nights, so the demand makes perfect sense.

Hours matter too. The restaurant typically opens in the late afternoon Tuesday through Saturday, and it’s closed Sunday and Monday.

Closing times run on the earlier side, so don’t count on a late supper. Checking current hours before you leave is a smart move.

Bigger groups should definitely book early. The restaurant works well for groups and families, but a large table needs a heads-up.

There’s a private parking lot on site, which helps once you arrive. Just know there’s no outdoor seating, so all the action happens inside.

Takeout is available as well. That’s handy if you want the prime rib at home in your pajamas, though I’d argue the full experience deserves a real table.

A quick phone call earlier in the day can save a lot of disappointment. Nobody wants to drive all that way just to smell supper from the car.

Country Roads Make the Drive Part of the Fun

Country Roads Make the Drive Part of the Fun
© That Place Steakhouse

Open fields stretch out on every side of this steakhouse. It sits along a quiet country road just outside Conrad, Iowa.

You’ll find it at 33030 G Ave, Conrad, IA 50621. Plug that into your map and enjoy the scenic stretch on the way.

That Place Steakhouse counts as a true destination dinner. People make the trip on purpose, which says plenty about what’s waiting at the end of the road.

I find that part charming. A long drive builds anticipation, and anticipation makes prime rib taste like a reward.

The hospitality matches the setting nicely. Staff have a reputation for greeting folks by name and making first-timers feel welcome too.

That’s classic Midwestern warmth, and it turns a meal into a memory. You come for the beef but leave feeling like part of the neighborhood.

Try timing your drive around sunset if you can. Golden light over Iowa farmland makes a lovely opening act before supper.

Then head inside, find your table, and let the evening slow down a little. Honestly, few road trips end with a better reward than a rosy slice of prime rib.

Sharing is caring!