One of my favorite finds in Pennsylvania is a Philly-style cheesesteak shop living inside a country general store, right beside a covered bridge. It sits hours from Philadelphia.
That alone made me want to hit the road.
Then the list kept getting stranger in the best way. One dining room fills an 1832 sawmill with its original wood beams and stonework.
Another serves dinner inside a tavern dating to the 1760s, on an old road travelers have used for centuries.
I love that these meals come with a catch. You have to wind through river gorges, farm country, and mountain towns to reach them.
Honestly, that sounds less like a catch and more like a bonus. The road builds your appetite, and the plate rewards your patience.
So gas up, grab a friend, and let the map wander a little.
1. Hotel Manor, Slate Run, PA

Fewer than 100 people live in Slate Run, so a full-service restaurant here feels like a happy surprise. You’ll find it inside a rural inn deep in the Pine Creek Gorge.
The drive alone is half the fun. Roads follow the creek through thick forest, with steep green hills rising on both sides.
Once you arrive, head straight for the riverside deck. It sits along Pine Creek, so you can eat while the water rolls past and the woods close in around you.
Hotel Manor is more than a meal stop, too. The inn has seven decorated rooms with private baths, plus breakfast and Wi-Fi for guests.
That makes it a smart base if you want more time in this wild corner of the state. Spend a day exploring the gorge, then come back for dinner by the water.
Plan ahead before you go. Cell service and quick detours are not things to count on out here, so build in extra time for the winding trip.
Address: 392 Slate Run Rd, Slate Run, PA 17769
2. Forksville’s Big Mike’s Steaks & Hoagies, Forksville, PA

A South Philly-style cheesesteak next to a covered bridge in a town of about 110 people? Yes, and it’s real.
Big Mike’s sits right beside the Forksville Covered Bridge in Sullivan County. You step through a quirky general store entryway before you reach the food.
The menu leans hard into Philly comfort. Look for the Dean Martin Cheesesteak, a cheesesteak with onions and mushrooms, hoagies, burgers, and club sandwiches.
Fries deserve their own spotlight here. Try the garlic fries, the Dirty Fries, or the Famous Dirty Jersey Fries if you want something messier.
Vegetarians get options too, thanks to a full vegetarian menu. Dogs are welcome both inside and out, and there’s a picnic area with riverside outdoor seating.
Weekends can bring live music, which makes Saturday the busiest stretch. The shop is closed Monday and Tuesday, and it opens at 11 a.m. other days.
Worlds End State Park sits nearby, so pair lunch with a hike. Ricketts Glen isn’t far either, if you want waterfalls for dessert.
Address: 22 Bridge St, Forksville, PA 18616
3. Jean Bonnet Tavern, Bedford, PA

Travelers were stopping at this stone building around 1762, long before cars existed. Today you can grab lunch in the same spot along the historic Lincoln Highway.
The Jean Bonnet Tavern joined the National Register of Historic Places in 1979. Inside, stone walls, wood details, hardwood floors, and a stone fireplace set the mood.
Food here goes well beyond basic tavern fare. Start with the Tavern Onion Soup or the butternut squash bisque on a chilly day.
Craving something heartier? The bison burger, filet mignon sandwich, bacon-wrapped scallops, and broiled crab cake sandwich all show up among the favorites.
Fried green beans make a fun snack for the table. There’s also a small shop on site, so browse a bit before you head back to the road.
The tavern serves lunch and dinner Monday through Saturday and closes Sundays. Friday and Saturday evenings get busy, so reservations are a smart move.
Some folks love its haunted tavern reputation. Whether you believe the stories or not, it makes dinner conversation easy.
Address: 6048 Lincoln Hwy, Bedford, PA 15522
4. The Settlers Inn, Hawley, PA

Farm-to-table dining inside a 1940s inn makes Hawley an easy pick for a Pocono road trip. The building dates to 1944 and keeps plenty of period details.
Hawley itself is small, with around 1,200 residents. Its main street shops and historic mills give the town a charming, old-fashioned feel.
Food at The Settlers Inn follows the farm-to-table approach. That means the kitchen leans on fresh ingredients rather than a frozen-food routine.
Burger night is a regular event here. It’s a fun, laid-back way to enjoy the dining room without dressing up.
The location may be the best bonus of all. Waterfalls, the silk mill, downtown Hawley, and a lake trail are all close by.
That makes the inn a handy home base for a weekend. Rooms come with period touches, so you can eat, sleep, and explore without moving the car much.
Fall foliage season is a great time to make the trip. The Pocono hills put on a show along the way.
Address: 4 Main Ave, Hawley, PA 18428
5. The Log Cabin Restaurant, Leola, PA

White tablecloths inside a real log cabin in the woods sounds like a fairy tale. In Leola, it’s just dinner.
The Log Cabin Restaurant sits amid the rolling hills of Lancaster County. Getting there means a pretty drive past farms and patches of forest.
Inside, the historic, lodgelike space feels polished and romantic. A fireplace adds charm on cold nights, and live music sometimes fills the room.
The menu focuses on sophisticated American fare. Filet mignon is a standout, and there’s also a full vegetarian menu for meat-free diners.
Save room for dessert, because the sweets get plenty of love. Coffee makes a nice finish before the drive home.
This is a special-occasion kind of place. Think anniversaries, birthdays, or a night when you want to feel fancy.
Reservations are required, so don’t just show up hoping for a table. The restaurant serves dinner only, opening at 4 p.m.
Monday through Saturday.
Saturday evening is the busiest time. Book early if your heart is set on a weekend.
Address: 11 Lehoy Forest Dr, Leola, PA 17540
6. Table 1837 – Glen Rock Mill Inn, Glen Rock, PA

Back in 1832, this building was a sawmill. Now it serves crab imperial, which feels like a pretty great career change.
Table 1837 sits inside the Glen Rock Mill Inn in a quiet nook of this York County borough. Original wood beams and stonework still show off the building’s past.
The menu leans gourmet without feeling stuffy. Favorites include crab imperial, filet mignon, and halibut, and portions run generous.
Plant-based eaters get real choices here. The kitchen offers full vegan and vegetarian menus, which isn’t common in small towns.
A fireplace and occasional live music add to the old mill charm. Outdoor seating is available, and dogs are welcome outside.
Hours take a little planning. The restaurant closes Monday and Wednesday, while Sunday opens at 11 a.m. for an earlier meal.
Weekend evenings fill up, so reserve a table if you can. Tuesday evenings and Sundays tend to be calmer.
Address: 50 Water St, Glen Rock, PA 17327
7. The French Manor Inn and Spa, Newfoundland, PA

A 1930s stone manor on Huckleberry Mountain serving French cuisine might be the fanciest reason to drive into the Poconos. It’s earned AAA Four Diamond honors for both its inn and restaurant over the years.
Newfoundland is a tiny community with fewer than 1,000 residents. Protected forests surround the area, so the drive up feels peaceful and green.
The dining room serves elevated French food. Expect a special-night meal rather than a quick bite before more errands.
Many guests turn a visit into a full getaway. The property has elegant rooms, a spa, and a saltwater pool for extra pampering.
Some couples even return year after year for a two-night stay. That says a lot about how relaxing this mountaintop escape can be.
Hours start at 8:30 a.m. daily, so breakfast lovers aren’t left out. Evening service ends a bit earlier on Sundays.
Go slow on those mountain roads. The views along the way are part of the treat.
Address: 50 Huntingdon Dr, Newfoundland, PA 18445
8. The Tavern on the Square, New Wilmington, PA

Amish Popcorn on a menu tells you right away where you are. New Wilmington sits among the rolling farm hills of western Pennsylvania.
The Tavern on the Square is a longtime, family-owned spot in a historic building. A renovation gave it a more polished look while keeping the old-fashioned dining room charm.
The menu mixes country comfort with a few surprises. You’ll see a Tavern Burger, a Reuben, crab cakes, and Korean sticky ribs.
Curious eaters should try the Scotch egg. Then finish with carrot cake, one of the dessert favorites.
Vegans and vegetarians both have full menus to choose from. Families get high chairs and a kids’ menu too.
Here’s a fun bonus: rooftop seating. On a nice day, it’s a great perch above the square.
The tavern closes Monday and Tuesday. Saturday afternoons and evenings get busiest, so reservations help for dinner.
Country byways dotted with family farms make the drive a treat. Take your time and enjoy the view.
Address: 108 N Market St, New Wilmington, PA 16142
9. Wellsboro Diner, Wellsboro, PA

Some people ride 332 miles in one loop just for breakfast here. That’s dedication, and honestly, the Wellsboro Diner makes it believable.
The diner sits on Main Street in Wellsboro, a town famous for its gas-lit street lamps. Route 6 runs through town, and the Pine Creek Gorge is close by.
Inside, a dining car-style interior brings back old-school charm. Breakfast and sandwiches make up the heart of the menu.
Start your morning with a Western omelette and home fries. Add a side of bacon if you’re feeling bold.
Sweet tooth? Grab a diner-made cinnamon roll or a slice of the Famous Diner Pie.
Lunch fans can go classic with a BLT or a grilled chicken sandwich. Portions are large, so arrive hungry or plan to share.
The diner opens at 7 a.m. and closes at 2 p.m. daily. It doesn’t take reservations, and Friday and Saturday mornings get busy.
Address: 19 Main St, Wellsboro, PA 16901
10. Bulls Head Public House, Lititz, PA

Sticky toffee pudding in Lancaster County farm country? You don’t need a passport for this British treat.
Bulls Head Public House sits inside the historic Lititz Springs Inn on East Main Street. Wood paneling and chandeliers give it the feel of a refined English pub.
The menu blends American, British, and global flavors. Fish and chips, bangers and mash, and chicken and leek pie lead the British lineup.
Snackers can grab sausage rolls or a Scotch egg. If you want spice, chicken tikka masala is on the menu too.
Lititz is a charming borough with a historic Main Street that’s great for strolling. Walk off dinner by browsing the shops nearby.
Parking can be tricky downtown, so give yourself a few extra minutes. The pub doesn’t take reservations either.
Hours run late on Fridays and Saturdays, and Saturday opens early at 8 a.m. Sunday nights and Mondays are usually the quietest times to visit.
Address: 14 E Main St, Lititz, PA 17543
