The Catskills aren’t just a feast for the eyes—they’re a feast for your taste buds too. Between roaring waterfalls and pine-scented hiking trails, there’s a world of small-town diners, farm-to-table cafés, and roadside grills that will make you want to lace up your boots just to earn that next bite. One moment you’re standing on a mountaintop, taking in views that look painted by hand. The next, you’re sitting at a rustic table with a burger so juicy it feels like a reward from nature itself—or maybe a slice of pie baked with fruit picked just miles away. Forget the idea that the Catskills are only about outdoor adventures. The real adventure might just be on your plate. Here are nine food stops that prove the Catskills are as much about flavor as they are about fresh mountain air.
Brushland Eating House
Tucked away in Bovina Center, Brushland Eating House enchants guests with its rustic farmhouse setting. This culinary gem offers a seasonal, prix fixe menu that changes weekly, highlighting the freshest local ingredients. With a cozy ambiance that feels like dining in a friend’s kitchen, Brushland creates an intimate experience for food enthusiasts. Each dish is crafted with care, paying homage to the rich agricultural heritage of the Catskills. Whether you’re savoring a hearty main course or a delicate dessert, the commitment to quality shines through every bite. A true must-visit destination for those seeking a taste of local charm.
Peekamoose Restaurant & Tap Room
In the heart of the Catskills, Peekamoose Restaurant & Tap Room stands as a beacon of contemporary American cuisine. Nestled in Big Indian, this restaurant emphasizes locally sourced ingredients, bringing the flavors of the region to life. The ambiance reflects the surrounding natural beauty, with rustic decor that complements the delicious dishes. Guests can enjoy a memorable dining experience, where each meal tells a story of community and sustainability. From the welcoming staff to the thoughtfully prepared dishes, Peekamoose captivates diners seeking both comfort and innovation.
The Roscoe Diner
An iconic stop for travelers, the Roscoe Diner has been a beloved fixture in the Catskills since 1962. Known for its hearty breakfasts, this diner serves up thick-cut French toast that has become a staple for both locals and visitors. The nostalgic atmosphere, complete with classic diner booths and friendly service, transports guests back in time. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, the Roscoe Diner offers a comforting taste of Americana. It’s a place where history and hearty flavors come together to create a dining experience that’s truly timeless.
Stissing House
In the quaint town of Pine Plains, Stissing House offers a unique dining experience within a historic building dating back to the 1780s. The restaurant combines rustic charm with contemporary design, creating an atmosphere that is both inviting and sophisticated. Guests can enjoy a modern take on classic tavern fare, where each dish is crafted with creativity and precision. The blend of history and culinary innovation makes Stissing House a standout destination for those seeking a memorable meal. Whether dining by the hearth or in the elegant dining room, the experience is both timeless and refreshing.
Matilda – Henson Hotel
Situated within the boutique Henson Hotel, Matilda offers a menu inspired by local ingredients and sustainability. The restaurant’s design complements its culinary offerings, creating a harmonious dining environment. Guests can indulge in dishes that reflect the rich flavors of the region, crafted with care and creativity. The ambiance is both chic and welcoming, providing a perfect backdrop for a delightful meal. Whether enjoying a leisurely dinner or a special occasion, Matilda promises a dining experience that resonates with both elegance and warmth. It’s a hidden gem in Hensonville, offering a taste of the Catskills’ culinary charm.
Casa Latina Pupusas y Mas
Casa Latina Pupusas y Mas in Hudson brings the vibrant flavors of Salvadoran cuisine to the Catskills. Known for its delicious pupusas and traditional dishes, this restaurant offers a cultural dining experience that delights the senses. The colorful setting adds to the charm, creating an atmosphere that feels both lively and welcoming. Each dish is crafted with authenticity and passion, reflecting the rich culinary heritage of El Salvador. Guests can enjoy a taste of Central America right in the heart of the Catskills, making Casa Latina a must-visit destination for those seeking something unique and flavorful.
The Henson Hotel
Beyond its main restaurant, The Henson Hotel in Hensonville offers additional dining options that cater to diverse palates. Day June Lunchonette and Paracasa general store provide a variety of culinary experiences, all set within the scenic beauty of the Catskills. Guests can enjoy the creativity and innovation that define the hotel’s dining offerings, from casual bites to gourmet meals. The ambiance is both inviting and sophisticated, making it a perfect spot for relaxation and indulgence. Whether you’re staying at the hotel or just visiting, the culinary delights are sure to impress.
Alons Halal Grill
As the first Uzbek restaurant in the Hudson Valley, Alons Halal Grill in Highland introduces diners to the rich flavors of Central Asia. Known for its traditional dishes like pilov and shawarma, this restaurant offers a unique culinary perspective in the region. The welcoming atmosphere and authentic flavors make Alons a standout destination for those seeking something different. Each dish is prepared with care, reflecting the culinary traditions of Uzbekistan. Whether you’re a seasoned foodie or new to Uzbek cuisine, Alons Halal Grill promises a dining experience that is both exciting and memorable.
Phoenicia Diner
Phoenicia Diner is a beloved Catskills institution, serving up comfort food with a modern twist. Located in Phoenicia, this diner offers a diverse menu that caters to all tastes. The welcoming atmosphere and retro decor create a nostalgic dining experience, where guests can enjoy both classic and innovative dishes. From hearty breakfasts to satisfying dinners, Phoenicia Diner delights with its commitment to quality and flavor. It’s a place where tradition meets modernity, offering a taste of the Catskills’ vibrant culinary scene. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, a visit to Phoenicia Diner is a must.