St. Louis runs on gooey butter cake. Forget ordinary desserts—this city’s sweet heart is rich, buttery, and irresistibly gooey. One bite, and you’re hooked, smudged fingers and all. From dense, buttery bases to soft, creamy tops, gooey butter cake isn’t just a treat—it’s a local obsession. Bakeries here guard their recipes like treasure, each slice carrying decades of flavor, tradition, and a little bit of St. Louis magic.
Get ready to taste the gooey glory that makes St. Louis unique. Your sweet tooth will be begging for more before you even finish the first slice.
Gooey Louie
Nestled in Creve Coeur, Gooey Louie is the go-to spot for St. Louis natives craving the authentic taste of gooey butter cake. Known for their rich flavors and irresistible gooey texture, their cakes have won the hearts of locals for over 15 years.
Gooey Louie has earned the accolade of “Best GBC in St. Louis,” testament to their dedication to quality. With multiple locations, each visit promises consistency and indulgence. Their commitment to tradition while offering modern twists ensures that every bite is a delightful surprise.
Park Avenue Coffee
With an impressive lineup of over 70 flavors, Park Avenue Coffee redefines gooey butter cake creativity. Located in Lafayette Square, this coffee haven is a hotspot for dessert enthusiasts. Their “Mom’s Traditional” cake remains a classic, but adventurous flavors like “Funky Monkey” offer something new. Park Avenue’s commitment to quality and innovation makes it a beloved staple in the community.
The welcoming environment invites you to savor a slice with a warm cup of coffee, making it a perfect spot for both locals and visitors.
Missouri Baking Company
In the heart of St. Louis’ historic Hill neighborhood, Missouri Baking Company stands as a testament to tradition. Famous for its Italian pastries, their gooey butter cakes are equally legendary. Each cake is a harmonious blend of rich, buttery goodness, perfected through decades of dedication.
The bakery’s historical roots add a layer of nostalgia, transporting patrons back to a time of genuine craftsmanship. Whether you’re a local or a curious traveler, a visit here is a delightful journey into St. Louis’ sweet past.
Russell’s Café & Bakery
Russell’s Café & Bakery offers a unique twist on the classic gooey butter cake by incorporating a salted shortbread crust. This creative addition adds a satisfying crunch that contrasts beautifully with the gooey top.
Nestled in South St. Louis, Russell’s combines comfort food with innovation, making it a must-visit for dessert lovers. The bakery’s warm ambiance, complete with rustic decor, invites you to relax and relish each bite. This unique take on a St. Louis classic has earned them a loyal following.
Companion Bakery & Café
Companion Bakery & Café, known for its artisan approach, offers a gooey butter cake that’s both classic and indulgent. Their deep-dish version caters to those who crave a more substantial dessert experience.
Located in the vibrant Clayton area, Companion is a hub for bakery enthusiasts. The combination of a thicker crust and gooey center creates a decadent, satisfying treat. Whether you’re stopping by for a morning coffee or evening dessert, Companion Bakery ensures that each visit is a delicious affair.
Straub’s Markets
Straub’s Markets, a cornerstone of St. Louis grocery tradition, offers gooey butter cakes made from scratch. Their cakes embody the rich, dense essence of this beloved dessert, using simple, high-quality ingredients. Straub’s multiple locations across the city make it accessible for all St. Louis residents seeking a taste of nostalgia.
The market’s dedication to maintaining the authenticity of gooey butter cake ensures that each slice is a reminder of St. Louis’ sweet legacy.