Wisconsin, the Dairy State, is not just known for its cheese. It’s the birthplace of the butter burger, a delicious creation focused on rich, savory flavors.
This blog celebrates eight iconic restaurants where butter burgers thrive, each with their unique twist on this Wisconsin classic.
Solly’s Grille
Established in 1936 by Kenneth “Solly” Salmon, Solly’s Grille is often cited as the original or most authentic butter burger spot.
Known for its sirloin beef cooked on a flattop and steamed in butter, the burgers are unapologetically rich with a heavy butter topping.
A James Beard honored classic, it’s a beloved destination for those seeking a true taste of Wisconsin’s heritage.
Kroll’s West & Kroll’s East
In the Green Bay area since 1936, Kroll’s is a cultural landmark for Packers fans, combining tradition with taste.
The charcoal-grilled burgers, topped with real butter and everything on, including pickles and onions, offer a hearty, flavorful experience.
Located near Lambeau Field, it’s more than just a meal; it’s a part of the game-day ritual.
Culver’s
Founded in Sauk City in 1984, Culver’s helped popularize the name “ButterBurger” beyond small diners. With fresh never-frozen beef, the buttered and toasted bun offers a unique twist, without smothering the patty itself in butter.
Known for its wide visibility, Culver’s has turned the butter burger into a beloved fast-food staple across the state.
Kopp’s Frozen Custard
Located in the Milwaukee area, Kopp’s is renowned for its “jumbo” hamburgers, frozen custard, and rich butter burgers. Their casual style combines simplicity and indulgence, offering a full Wisconsin comfort meal.
The combination of savory burgers and creamy custard makes it a must-visit for those craving a local taste sensation.
Mihm’s Charcoal Grill
Since 1958, Mihm’s in Menasha has delighted locals with its buttery burgers cooked over charcoal. Praised for its generous butter usage, the diner’s old-school charm and authentic flavors make it a nostalgic favorite.
It’s a place where tradition meets taste, offering a genuine slice of Wisconsin’s culinary history.
Oscars Pub & Grill
Located “on Pierce” in Milwaukee, Oscars Pub & Grill is known for its big, juicy burgers and strong local reputation.
Customers can ask for their burgers to be loaded with butter, embracing the indulgent spirit. It’s a modern joint that keeps the butter burger tradition alive, offering an abundant, flavorful experience.
Gilles Frozen Custard
Since 1938, Gilles Frozen Custard has been a Milwaukee-area classic, offering delicious butter burgers alongside creamy custard.
Known for its retro drive-in vibe and loyal following, Gilles keeps the tradition alive with juicy burgers finished with a generous smear of butter. It’s a nostalgic destination where flavor and history meet.
Crave Cafe
Located in Madison, Crave Cafe is celebrated for its rich and juicy butter burgers served on toasted buns with real butter.
The cozy, casual vibe offers an elevated comfort food experience, making it a local gem. With a menu full of crave-worthy options, Crave Cafe lives up to its name, especially for burger lovers.