Get ready to feast like you’ve stepped straight into a storybook. Pennsylvania’s Amish country isn’t just about horse-drawn buggies and serene farmland—it’s a haven for hearty, soul-satisfying meals. Here, buffets aren’t just meals—they’re experiences. Mountains of fried chicken, golden biscuits, creamy mashed potatoes, and piles of seasonal vegetables beckon from every table. Each plate is a celebration of homestyle cooking, slow-cooked with care and generosity. From sweet pies to tangy coleslaw, these seven Amish buffets prove that in Pennsylvania, comfort food is serious business.
Roll up your sleeves and get ready—your appetite will thank you.
Shady Maple Smorgasbord
Shady Maple Smorgasbord is a colossal culinary experience, often hailed as the largest Amish buffet in the U.S. Spanning over 110,000 square feet, it offers an extensive array of homestyle dishes. The buffet, nearly 200 feet long, presents breakfast, lunch, and dinner options, including brisket, ham, fried chicken, and Pennsylvania Dutch pies like shoofly and whoopie pies.
Weekends are particularly bustling, drawing crowds eager to indulge in these hearty meals. Besides dining, visitors can explore the gift shop and market, making it a comprehensive destination for local culture and cuisine.
Miller’s Smorgasbord
Miller’s Smorgasbord, Lancaster County’s oldest smorgasbord, offers a warm, inviting atmosphere and a time-honored menu. Since 1929, it has delighted locals and visitors with Pennsylvania Dutch classics made from scratch.
The Traditional Smorgasbord includes hearty soups, salads, breads, and entrées like chicken & waffles and pot pie. For lighter appetites, there’s a Soup, Salad & Bread option. Seasonal vegetables sourced from local Amish farms ensure fresh, authentic flavors. Miller’s is cherished by locals for its homey feel and enduring culinary traditions.
Bird-in-Hand Family Restaurant & Smorgasbord
Bird-in-Hand Family Restaurant & Smorgasbord offers a warm, family-friendly dining experience with a focus on Pennsylvania Dutch comfort food. Guests enjoy a smorgasbord of soups, salads, hot entrées, and desserts made from farm-fresh ingredients.
The local Amish and Mennonite farms supply seasonal produce, ensuring each dish is as authentic as it is delicious. Known for its hospitable atmosphere, the restaurant feels inviting and genuine, making it a favorite for family gatherings and anyone seeking the essence of Dutch culinary tradition.
Yoder’s Restaurant & Buffet
Yoder’s Restaurant & Buffet provides an authentic Amish dining experience, featuring breakfast, lunch, and dinner buffets with true Pennsylvania Dutch fare. Breakfast delights include omelets, pancakes, and baked oatmeal, while lunch and dinner offer broasted chicken, potato filling, and a variety of desserts like pies and soft ice cream.
Adjacent to the restaurant is a country market offering local products, enhancing the visitor experience. With ample space for motorcoach parking, Yoder’s is ideal for large groups seeking flavorful, homestyle cooking.
Dienner’s Country Restaurant
Dienner’s Country Restaurant is a hidden gem in the Amish buffet landscape, offering a quieter, more intimate experience. Open from breakfast through dinner, it serves authentic Pennsylvania Dutch dishes with a homestyle touch.
The buffet features buttered noodles, roast meats, chicken pot pie, and delightful desserts. Patrons appreciate the consistently full buffet bins and homemade feel of the food. Its casual, welcoming atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for those seeking a less crowded dining experience with genuine local flavors.
Hershey Farm Resort
Hershey Farm Resort’s Grand Smorgasbord offers a delightful all-you-can-eat experience with Pennsylvania Dutch staples. Patrons enjoy ham balls, chicken pot pie, soft pretzels, and homemade desserts. The buffet is complemented by made-to-order grill items. Beyond dining, the resort features an inn, gift shops, and farm animals, providing an engaging outing.
Despite past setbacks from a fire, the restaurant has successfully rebuilt and continues to thrive as a popular destination for both tourists and locals seeking quality Amish cuisine and relaxation.
Amish Yoder Family Drive-Thru All-You-Can-Eat Buffet
The Amish Yoder Family Drive-Thru Buffet introduces a novel concept to traditional Amish dining. Patrons collect buckets filled with classics like fried chicken, mashed potatoes, and shoofly pie from a walk-up window.
This quick-serve style caters to those seeking authentic Amish flavors in a convenient format, perfect for individuals or families on the go. Open from morning until sold out, it provides a unique blend of tradition and modern convenience, allowing diners to enjoy hearty meals without the formality of a sit-down experience.