Explore the delightful world of Indiana’s sugar cream pie, a Hoosier classic cherished for its creamy, custard-like texture and sweet simplicity.
This dessert, often referred to as “Hoosier Pie,” remains a staple in bakeries across Indiana, celebrated for its nostalgic flavor that resonates with locals and visitors alike.
Join us as we uncover seven must-visit bakeries where this iconic pie continues to shine.
Wick’s Pies – Winchester
Wick’s Pies in Winchester sets the gold standard for sugar cream pies in Indiana. Known for its classic, no-frills recipe, the pies are mass-produced but maintain the nostalgic flavor many Hoosiers grew up with.
With a legacy dating back to 1944, Wick’s has perfected the art of sugar cream pie. Each bite offers a rich, creamy texture and a perfectly balanced sweetness.
The bakery atmosphere adds to the charm, making it a must-visit destination for pie enthusiasts. Enjoy a slice surrounded by the warmth of a true Indiana establishment.
Concannon’s Bakery Café – Muncie
Concannon’s Bakery Café, a beloved family-owned bakery in Muncie, offers made-from-scratch sugar cream pies that are rich, creamy, and full of hometown flavor.
Known for its commitment to quality, Concannon’s has become a staple on the Hoosier Pie Trail. The bakery’s inviting atmosphere and friendly service make it a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike.
Each pie is crafted with care, ensuring every slice is a delightful experience. Whether you’re grabbing a pie to-go or enjoying a slice on-site, Concannon’s is a must-visit.
My Sugar Pie – Zionsville
My Sugar Pie in Zionsville offers a delightful experience with its specialty sugar cream pie, among a large rotating menu of seasonal and classic options.
Known for its charming ambiance, this pie shop is the perfect place to grab a whole pie or just a slice. The sugar cream pie, a customer favorite, is crafted with love and precision, ensuring a rich and velvety texture.
The shop’s dedication to quality ingredients and creative flavors makes it a standout destination for pie lovers. Enjoy the cozy atmosphere while savoring Indiana’s iconic pie.
Pots & Pans Pie Co.- Indianapolis
Pots & Pans Pie Co. in Indianapolis is a local favorite known for its homemade, small-batch pies that capture the heart of Indiana’s baking traditions.
Their signature sugar cream pie, rich and creamy with a perfectly flaky crust, is a must-try for anyone craving an authentic taste of Hoosier heritage.
With a cozy atmosphere and a commitment to quality ingredients, Pots & Pans Pie Co. offers a sweet slice of comfort right in the city.
Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery – Shipshewana
Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery in Shipshewana is a staple in Amish Country, offering hearty meals and a wide range of homemade pies. The sugar cream pie, rich and velvety, pairs perfectly with their country-style fare.
Known for its rustic charm and welcoming atmosphere, Blue Gate provides a memorable dining experience. The bakery uses traditional recipes and quality ingredients to create pies that resonate with the local culture.
Enjoy the blend of rich flavors and the serene Amish setting, making it a must-visit for anyone exploring Indiana’s pie heritage.
Das Dutchman Essenhaus – Middlebury, IN
Das Dutchman Essenhaus in Middlebury, an Amish-style restaurant and bakery, is a renowned stop on the Hoosier Pie Trail. Offering a variety of pies, including the traditional sugar cream pie, it’s a popular destination for pie enthusiasts.
The bakery’s inviting atmosphere and classic decor evoke a sense of nostalgia and warmth. Every pie is crafted using time-honored recipes, ensuring a rich, flavorful experience.
Whether dining in or taking a pie to-go, Das Dutchman Essenhaus promises a taste of Indiana’s culinary heritage that can’t be missed.
Bread Basket Cafe & Bakery – Danville, IN
Located in Danville, the Bread Basket Cafe & Bakery is celebrated for its diverse range of pies, with the sugar cream pie holding a special spotlight.
Known for its quaint charm and welcoming environment, this bakery invites pie lovers to enjoy a taste of Indiana’s pie heritage. Each pie is baked with care, reflecting the bakery’s dedication to quality and tradition.
The sugar cream pie, in particular, stands out for its creamy texture and delightful sweetness. Enjoy a slice amidst the cozy setting, making it a notable stop on the Hoosier Pie Trail.