Skip to Content

10 New York Steakhouses That Cost a Fortune but Always Deliver

10 New York Steakhouses That Cost a Fortune but Always Deliver

Sharing is caring!

New York City, a melting pot of culinary delights, hosts some of the most opulent steakhouses in the world.

These establishments are known not just for their exquisite cuts of beef but also for their exceptional ambiance and service.

From historic institutions to modern marvels, here are ten steakhouses that promise a lavish experience worth every penny.

Peter Luger Steak House (Brooklyn)

Peter Luger Steak House (Brooklyn)
Image Credit:© Peter Luger Steak House

Since 1887, Peter Luger Steak House has been a shrine for steak lovers. Known for its cash-only policy, it serves beef that’s dry-aged on-site, offering quality that justifies the price. The gruff service is part of its old-school charm, enhancing the experience of enjoying the legendary porterhouse.

The unpretentious decor adds to the allure, with rustic wooden tables and timeless appeal. Located in Brooklyn, this iconic establishment is a true New York institution.

With its reputation, Peter Luger remains a pilgrimage site for those seeking unparalleled steak.

Keens Steakhouse (Midtown Manhattan)

Keens Steakhouse (Midtown Manhattan)
Image Credit:© Eclectic Kim

Dating back to 1885, Keens Steakhouse offers an ambiance as rich as its steaks. The historic establishment is famed for its mutton chop and an extensive collection of clay pipes.

Stepping inside feels like traveling back in time, with vintage decor setting the stage for a memorable meal. The perfectly cooked prime cuts melt in your mouth, making each bite a delight.

Nestled in the heart of Midtown Manhattan, Keens’ storied history and culinary excellence make it a must-visit for steak aficionados.

COTE Korean Steakhouse (Flatiron District)

COTE Korean Steakhouse (Flatiron District)
Image Credit:© Secret Singapore

COTE Korean Steakhouse stands out by blending Korean BBQ with American steakhouse sophistication. Awarded a Michelin star, it offers a unique dining experience with USDA Prime and Wagyu cuts grilled at your table.

The Butcher’s Feast is an indulgent affair, providing a taste of luxury with every bite. Located in the Flatiron District, COTE’s sleek modernity and innovative approach make it a culinary gem worth exploring.

Porter House Bar and Grill (Columbus Circle)

Porter House Bar and Grill (Columbus Circle)
Image Credit:© New York Post

In the Time Warner Center, Porter House Bar and Grill offers both culinary excellence and stunning views of Central Park. Renowned chef Michael Lomonaco crafts a menu of prime steaks and a deep wine list that perfectly complements the meal.

The ambiance is upscale and elegant, making it a favorite for those seeking a sophisticated dining experience.

The combination of exquisite food and breathtaking scenery ensures a memorable visit, justifying its premium price.

Gallaghers Steakhouse (Theater District)

Gallaghers Steakhouse (Theater District)
Image Credit:© Forbes

Once a speakeasy, Gallaghers Steakhouse brings Broadway glamour to the steakhouse scene. Known for its glass-fronted meat lockers, the restaurant dry-ages USDA Prime beef to perfection, offering a grill-over-hickory-coals experience.

The lively, old New York atmosphere is enhanced by its location in the Theater District, making it a perfect pre-show dining spot. Its storied past and gastronomic excellence make Gallaghers a lavish choice for meat lovers.

4 Charles Prime Rib (West Village)

4 Charles Prime Rib (West Village)
Image Credit:© Eater NY

Hidden in the West Village, 4 Charles Prime Rib offers an exclusive and intimate dining experience. Known for its prime rib and burger, this cozy spot feels like a members-only club with its velvet booths and candlelit ambiance.

The premium price tag is matched by the indulgence of each dish. Reservations are hard to come by, adding to its allure among those in the know. For a special night out, 4 Charles delivers in spades.

Wolfgang’s Steakhouse (Multiple Locations)

Wolfgang’s Steakhouse (Multiple Locations)
Image Credit:© The Venue Report

Founded by a former Peter Luger headwaiter, Wolfgang’s Steakhouse brings a touch of upscale polish to the iconic dry-aged beef tradition. The porterhouse is consistently stellar, served in a refined setting across its multiple locations.

Wolfgang’s combines the legacy of its origins with a modern dining experience, offering reliability and luxury.

It’s a destination for those seeking high-quality steak in a more elegant environment, with prices reflecting the premium offerings.

Club A Steakhouse (Midtown East)

Club A Steakhouse (Midtown East)
Image Credit:© ILoveNY.com

At Club A Steakhouse, owner Bruno Selimaj’s personal touch is evident as he often greets guests. This family-run establishment combines warmth with five-star sophistication, offering a romantic vibe, top cuts, and attentive service.

The elegant decor and welcoming atmosphere invite diners to relax and enjoy their meal. Located in Midtown East, Club A’s commitment to quality and hospitality creates a dining experience that stands out in the bustling city.

STK Steakhouse (Meatpacking District)

STK Steakhouse (Meatpacking District)
Image Credit:© NYC New Years Eve Events

STK Steakhouse is where fine dining meets a high-energy lounge vibe. Located in the trendy Meatpacking District, it features DJs and dim lights, creating a flashy yet sophisticated atmosphere.

While the ambiance is designed for the Instagram era, the steaks, especially the dry-aged tomahawk, deliver on taste and quality.

STK is perfect for those looking to combine culinary excellence with a lively night out.

Benjamin Steakhouse (Midtown Manhattan)

Benjamin Steakhouse (Midtown Manhattan)
Image Credit:© Benjamin Steakhouse

Benjamin Steakhouse is a favorite among Wall Street power players, offering a white-tablecloth experience with massive cuts of dry-aged beef. Its polished atmosphere attracts both suits and celebrities, ensuring a stylish dining scene.

The Midtown Manhattan location enhances its appeal as a business and pleasure destination. Known for its reliable service and premium offerings, Benjamin Steakhouse remains a top choice for those seeking luxury and quality in every bite.