Indiana’s pizza scene is hiding secrets, and they’re cheesy, saucy, and unforgettable. You won’t find these gems plastered on every foodie blog or lined up in tourist guides. These are the spots locals whisper about, the pizzerias where the dough is perfect, the cheese stretches for miles, and the toppings make you question every chain pizza you’ve ever eaten.
Skip the obvious chains. Grab a friend, hit the back roads, and let your taste buds wander. These eight local favorites promise pizza with character, charm, and flavors you’ll be talking about long after the last slice disappears.
Mug-n-Bun Pizza – Speedway
Mug-n-Bun Pizza in Speedway is a nostalgic treasure. Established in 1960, it’s the oldest operating drive-in in Marion County. Known for its classic American diner fare, the attached pizzeria offers a trip down memory lane with its cozy retro vibe.
Here, patrons savor traditional pies in a setting reminiscent of simpler times. The combination of history and comfort food makes it a beloved local haunt, ideal for those craving a slice of nostalgia.
From its iconic neon signs to the aroma of baking pies, Mug-n-Bun Pizza is a must-visit for anyone near Speedway.
Giorgio’s Pizza – Indianapolis
Nestled in downtown Indianapolis, Giorgio’s Pizza has been serving delicious Italian fare since 1990. Its cozy, inviting atmosphere transports you straight to Naples, offering an authentic Italian escape.
The pizzeria’s main attraction is its pizza, but the homemade lasagna is a hidden gem with a dedicated following. Giorgio’s is where locals gather for a taste of Italy, right in the heart of Indiana.
A warm ambiance and flavorful dishes keep patrons coming back, cementing its spot as a local favorite for over three decades.
Azzip Pizza – Evansville
Azzip Pizza in Evansville is not your typical pizza joint. Since 2014, it has revolutionized the scene with a fast-casual model, boasting over 16 million possible combinations.
Patrons customize their pies with a variety of toppings, all baked to perfection in a conveyor belt oven. This innovative approach appeals to locals seeking a quick yet satisfying meal.
With endless possibilities and a commitment to fresh ingredients, Azzip Pizza is where creativity meets flavor, offering a unique dining experience.
Arni’s Restaurant – Lafayette
In Lafayette, Arni’s Restaurant has been a community staple since 1965. Originally a small pizza parlor, it has grown into a beloved chain with locations across Indiana.
Known for its welcoming service and diverse menu, Arni’s focuses on delivering delicious pizza in a family-friendly environment. The establishment’s classic recipes and inviting atmosphere make it a go-to spot for locals.
Whether you’re enjoying a casual meal with family or a gathering with friends, Arni’s offers the perfect setting for any occasion.
LaRosa’s Pizzeria – Evansville
LaRosa’s Pizzeria, established in 1954, has earned its place as a beloved institution in Evansville. Known for its thin-crust pizzas, the sweet tomato sauce and provolone cheese create a distinctive flavor.
The family-friendly atmosphere invites diners of all ages to enjoy a meal together, fostering a sense of community. With consistent quality and a welcoming ambiance, LaRosa’s is a staple for pizza lovers.
Whether it’s a casual dinner or a special occasion, LaRosa’s offers an inviting space for all to share a slice.
Bazbeaux Pizza – Indianapolis
Bazbeaux Pizza in Indianapolis’ Broad Ripple neighborhood has been serving gourmet pizzas since 1986. Known for its creative toppings, this pizzeria crafts each pie with high-quality ingredients.
The lively atmosphere and dedicated customer base make it a top choice for pizza enthusiasts. Bazbeaux is where tradition meets innovation in every slice.
Whether you’re a new visitor or a loyal fan, Bazbeaux promises a flavorful journey in every bite.
King Dough – Bloomington
King Dough in Bloomington is a local treasure known for its rustic, wood-fired pizzas. This spot offers a cozy ambiance, featuring a large wood-fired oven that brings pizzas to life with a perfect char.
Their menu includes creative options like the Blue Piggy, topped with blue cheese and prosciutto. The inviting atmosphere makes it a favorite among locals who come to enjoy its artistic flair and friendly service.
Located close to Indiana University, it’s a great spot for students and families alike. King Dough continues to impress with its commitment to fresh ingredients and inventive flavors.
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza – Greenwood
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza in Greenwood offers an exciting pizza experience with its artisan creations and vibrant atmosphere. Known for pushing boundaries, their pizzas come with innovative toppings such as artichoke hearts and goat cheese.
The lively setting is perfect for gatherings, and their commitment to locally sourced ingredients ensures fresh and flavorful pies. The Slaughterhouse-Five, a meat lover’s delight, is a hit among patrons.
Jockamo stands out for its dedication to quality and creativity, making it a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts seeking something special in Indiana.