St. Augustine isn’t just history and cobblestone streets—it’s a flavor-packed playground for your taste buds. Step into this coastal city, and you’ll find restaurants that do more than feed you—they seduce, surprise, and turn first-timers into loyal fans. Each plate is a story, each bite a little thrill of culinary magic.
These 10 restaurants don’t just serve food—they create moments. Locals know the secrets, but visitors are about to discover why the city keeps them coming back. Prepare your appetite, your curiosity, and maybe even your camera, because St. Augustine’s flavors are as photogenic as they are delicious.
Saint
Saint is a culinary gem offering a sophisticated twist on Italian classics. Nestled along the bayfront, this restaurant provides not only exquisite dishes but also breathtaking views. Handmade pastas and wood-fired pizzas are among the highlights.
The ambiance is romantic, perfect for special occasions. With attentive service and a menu that caters to both traditional and modern tastes, Saint captures the essence of Italian dining. Whether you’re celebrating a milestone or enjoying a quiet evening, this venue will leave a lasting impression.
Columbia Restaurant
Columbia Restaurant, established in 1905, is a living piece of history. As Florida’s oldest restaurant, it offers a unique Spanish-Cuban dining experience. The “1905 Salad” and “Paella a la Valenciana” are must-tries.
Its ornate interior transports diners to another era, while live flamenco shows add a festive touch. The combination of rich flavors and cultural heritage makes Columbia a standout in St. Augustine. Whether you’re a history buff or a culinary adventurer, this restaurant promises a memorable experience.
Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille
Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille is where Southern charm meets Creole flair. Known for its lively atmosphere, the restaurant serves up favorites like “Blackened Chicken Pasta” and “Cajun Shrimp.”
Live music adds to the vibrant energy, making it a perfect spot for an evening out. Whether you’re indulging in their hearty dishes or enjoying a cocktail at the bar, Harry’s offers a delightful taste of the South in the heart of St. Augustine.
St. Augustine Fish Camp
St. Augustine Fish Camp is a haven for seafood lovers. Located on the water, this casual restaurant offers fresh coastal dishes like “Shrimp & Grits” and “Fish Tacos.”
The laid-back vibe and picturesque views create a perfect setting for a relaxing meal. Whether dining with family or friends, the welcoming atmosphere and delicious seafood make every visit special. It’s a local favorite that captures the essence of St. Augustine’s coastal charm.
Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila
Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila is a colorful celebration of Mexican cuisine. With dishes like “Tacos al Pastor” and “Elote,” it offers a modern twist on traditional flavors.
The lively atmosphere, complemented by an extensive tequila selection, makes it a popular choice for both locals and tourists. Whether you’re a fan of spicy salsas or smooth margaritas, Casa Reina promises an exciting culinary adventure in St. Augustine.
Llama Restaurant
Llama Restaurant brings the rich flavors of Peru to St. Augustine. Known for its cozy and intimate setting, it serves authentic dishes like “Lomo Saltado” and “Ceviche.”
The warm ambiance and attentive service add to the dining experience, making it a favorite among food enthusiasts. Whether you’re discovering Peruvian cuisine for the first time or revisiting beloved flavors, Llama offers a delightful culinary journey.
The Floridian
The Floridian combines Southern comfort with a modern twist. Emphasizing fresh and local ingredients, it serves dishes like “Shrimp & Grits” and “Fried Green Tomatoes.”
Its laid-back atmosphere makes it a standout choice for those seeking genuine Southern hospitality. With a commitment to sustainability, The Floridian offers a menu that delights both the palate and the conscience, creating a unique dining experience in St. Augustine.
Cap’s on the Water
Cap’s on the Water is a serene escape offering coastal delights with a touch of elegance. Located on the waterfront, it features dishes like “Blackened Grouper” and “Crab Cakes.”
The stunning sunset views enhance the dining experience, making it perfect for a romantic evening or a special celebration. With a blend of Southern and Mediterranean influences, Cap’s creates a memorable culinary experience in a truly picturesque setting.
Beachcomber Restaurant
Beachcomber Restaurant is a quintessential beachside dining spot. With a focus on fresh seafood and American classics, it offers dishes like “Fish Tacos” and “Crab Cakes.”
Its beachfront location and relaxed vibe make it a favorite among both locals and visitors. Whether you’re enjoying a casual lunch or watching the waves, Beachcomber provides a taste of coastal living in St. Augustine.
Swillerbees Craft Doughnuts
Swillerbees Craft Doughnuts is a sweet haven for doughnut lovers. Known for its creative flavors like “Maple Bacon” and “Lemon Lavender,” this shop uses high-quality ingredients to craft gourmet treats.
The whimsical approach to doughnuts has garnered a loyal following, with each visit offering new and exciting flavors. Whether you’re a local or a tourist, Swillerbees promises a delightful and indulgent experience in the heart of St. Augustine.