In Wisconsin, cheese isn’t just a food—it’s a way of life. From the rolling hills of the Driftless Area to the shores of Lake Michigan, these 12 cheese shops have become cherished destinations for locals and visitors alike. Each shop offers a unique taste of the state’s rich dairy heritage, serving up everything from squeaky curds to aged goudas.
Whether you’re a lifelong cheese enthusiast or a curious newcomer, these establishments promise an authentic Wisconsin experience, where every bite tells a story of tradition, craftsmanship, and community.
Baumgartner’s Cheese Store & Tavern – Monroe
In the heart of Monroe, Baumgartner’s Cheese Store & Tavern combines history with flavor. This iconic spot serves legendary Limburger and is the oldest cheese shop in Wisconsin. Enjoy a hearty sandwich paired with a cold beer while soaking in the charming, rustic atmosphere.
The tavern’s walls adorned with eclectic decor make it a perfect backdrop for cheese tasting. Locals and visitors alike revel in its lively ambiance. Don’t miss their friendly staff, always ready with a story or suggestion.
A must-stop for those seeking a true taste of Monroe’s cheese culture.
Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery – Ellsworth
Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery is synonymous with cheese curds perfection. Known as the “Cheese Curd Capital,” this creamery delivers fresh, squeaky curds that are nothing short of legendary. Visitors can watch the cheese-making process through large windows.
While the curds steal the show, Ellsworth also offers a variety of other cheese delights. The creamery’s well-stocked shop invites you to explore flavors and textures.
The friendly staff are eager to share insights and offer samples, ensuring each visit is both educational and delicious. A true haven for cheese lovers.
Carr Valley Cheese Company – Multiple locations
Carr Valley Cheese Company is a family-owned business with a legacy spanning over 100 years. Their artisanal cheeses, crafted from cow, goat, and sheep milk, offer a symphony of flavors.
Each of their locations showcases a wide range of award-winning cheeses, making it a cheese lover’s paradise. The friendly and knowledgeable staff enhance the experience with recommendations tailored to your taste.
Whether it’s their creamy blue cheese or aged cheddar, every bite tells a story of dedication and craftsmanship, honoring Wisconsin’s cheese-making tradition.
Fromagination – Madison
Fromagination in Madison is more than a cheese shop; it’s a culinary adventure. This boutique offers an exquisite selection of artisan cheeses and gourmet foods. Known for its elegant displays, it captivates all who enter.
The passionate staff are not just sellers but storytellers, eager to share the origins and nuances of each cheese. Pairings with wine, meats, and chocolates are thoughtfully curated.
Located near the Capitol, it’s a convenient stop for those exploring the city. Fromagination crafts an unforgettable cheese experience in Wisconsin’s capital.
Vern’s Cheese – Chilton
Nestled in Chilton, Vern’s Cheese is a treasure trove for cheese enthusiasts. With a vast selection of local and imported cheeses, this family-run shop embodies warmth and hospitality.
The quaint setting invites you to explore flavors from around the globe. Staff members are eager to share their favorite picks and offer generous samples.
Vern’s also features a deli for fresh sandwiches, making it a delightful stop for both shopping and snacking. Whether you’re a cheese aficionado or just curious, Vern’s promises a memorable visit.
Mars Cheese Castle – Kenosha
Mars Cheese Castle isn’t just a store; it’s a landmark. Located in Kenosha, this castle-themed shop offers a vast array of cheeses alongside Wisconsin-themed souvenirs.
The whimsical architecture draws visitors from afar, while inside, the selection satisfies even the most discerning palate. From classics to unique finds, each cheese tells a part of Wisconsin’s story.
Friendly staff and a bustling atmosphere make Mars Cheese Castle a family favorite. Whether you’re shopping or just exploring, this iconic stop is sure to enchant.
Widmer’s Cheese Cellars – Theresa
At Widmer’s Cheese Cellars in Theresa, tradition is key. This family-run operation has been crafting cheeses for generations, with a focus on quality and flavor.
Their famed brick cheese is a local favorite, reflecting the dedication and skill of the Widmer family. The cellar tours offer a fascinating glimpse into time-honored cheese-making processes.
Widmer’s welcoming atmosphere and commitment to excellence make it a cherished destination. Old-world charm meets modern taste in every bite, ensuring a delightful experience for all visitors.
Sartori Cheese – Plymouth
Sartori Cheese in Plymouth is celebrated for its innovative approach to cheese-making. Known for award-winning varieties, their cheeses are a staple in gourmet circles.
Each product reflects a blend of tradition and creativity, creating flavors that are both classic and unique. Visitors can enjoy tastings that highlight the depth of Sartori’s offerings.
The atmosphere is professional yet welcoming, illustrating their passion for perfection. Sartori’s commitment to quality and innovation makes them a standout in Wisconsin’s rich cheese landscape.
Gile Cheese Store – Gile
Gile Cheese Store, a rustic gem, captures the essence of small-town charm. Located in Gile, this shop offers a delightful array of local specialty cheeses.
The friendly atmosphere invites you to linger, with staff eager to share stories and samples. Each cheese reflects the region’s heritage, making it a true taste of Wisconsin.
Beyond cheese, Gile offers locally-sourced goods that complement their dairy delights. Visitors appreciate the authenticity and warmth that this quaint shop provides, turning a simple visit into a cherished memory.
Kuehnert Dairy Farm – Wausau
Kuehnert Dairy Farm in Wausau offers more than just cheese; it’s an experience. This working farm provides tours that educate and entertain, showing cheese-making from pasture to plate.
Their farm-fresh products are a testament to their dedication to quality. Visitors can sample cheeses that reflect the rich flavors of the countryside.
The farm’s friendly environment and family-oriented approach make it a wonderful destination for all ages. Kuehnert Dairy Farm combines agriculture and artisan cheese, delivering a taste of rural Wisconsin.
Clock Shadow Creamery – Milwaukee
Clock Shadow Creamery, an urban gem in Milwaukee, showcases cheese-making in a modern setting. This eco-friendly creamery is known for its innovative approach and sustainable practices.
Visitors can enjoy tours that highlight the art and science of cheese-making. The creamery’s location in the city makes it an accessible adventure for urban dwellers.
Their fresh curds and specialty cheeses offer a taste of innovation. Clock Shadow Creamery stands out for its commitment to the environment and quality, making it a must-visit in Milwaukee.
Wisconsin Cheese Mart – Milwaukee
Wisconsin Cheese Mart in Milwaukee is a haven for cheese connoisseurs. Offering a vast selection, this bustling shop invites you to explore diverse flavors and textures.
Tasting events and knowledgeable staff enhance the shopping experience, providing insights into cheese pairings and selections. The shop’s lively atmosphere and downtown location make it a convenient stop.
Whether seeking a familiar favorite or discovering something new, Wisconsin Cheese Mart delivers. It’s a vibrant celebration of Wisconsin’s cheese-making legacy, offering a delightful journey for all who enter.