Pennsylvania takes its pizza seriously—and when the ovens fire up, the slices vanish fast. These aren’t just any pizzerias. They’re local legends where lines form before lunch, and by dinner, the last pie is gone. Each crust is golden, each topping layered with care, and every bite tells a story of flavor perfected over decades. From Philadelphia’s classic corner spots to Pittsburgh’s hidden gems, these pizzerias have mastered the art of making people crave just one more slice.
If you’ve ever wondered where to find a pie that lives up to the hype, these thirteen Pennsylvania pizza spots are calling. Come hungry, arrive early, and savor every mouthwatering moment before it disappears.
Pizzeria Beddia – Philadelphia, PA
Once dubbed “the best pizza in America” by Bon Appétit, Pizzeria Beddia is revered for its meticulously crafted pies. With just five artisan pizzas on the menu, including the famed “Corn Pie,” it’s a place where quality reigns supreme. Long lines and rapid sellouts are a testament to their commitment to fresh, top-tier ingredients.
The minimalist approach extends to the decor, creating a sleek yet welcoming atmosphere. Dining here is an experience, with each slice embodying the passion poured into its creation. The loyal following they’ve amassed speaks volumes about the magic emanating from their ovens.
Paulie Gee’s Soul City Slice – Philadelphia, PA
Paulie Gee’s Soul City Slice brings Brooklyn vibes to Philadelphia with its thin-crust round pies and thick Sicilian squares. Inspired by the original Paulie Gee’s in Brooklyn, this slice shop is known for its quality ingredients and creative specials.
The lively atmosphere and late-night hours attract a diverse crowd, from night owls to foodies. Pair a slice with a craft beer for the full experience. Their rotating menu ensures there’s always something new to try, making it a beloved spot for pizza enthusiasts.
Beto’s Pizza – Pittsburgh, PA
Since 1953, Beto’s Pizza has been a Pittsburgh institution, known for its unconventional method of serving pizza. Hot crust and sauce topped with cold shredded mozzarella create a delightfully contrasting texture and flavor.
A signature of Beto’s is the generous portion size, which has kept customers returning for decades. The combination of tradition and a dedicated community following ensures that slices disappear quickly, often before the day ends. Beto’s is more than just a pizza place; it’s a slice of local history.
Lorenzo’s Pizza – Philadelphia, PA
Known for its massive slices, Lorenzo’s Pizza offers a quintessential Philadelphia pizza experience. Their enormous portions and simple yet flavorful toppings make it a staple for both locals and tourists.
Situated on the bustling South Street, it’s a favorite late-night stop, with lines often wrapping around the block. The no-frills approach to pizza resonates with those who crave authenticity and hearty servings. Patrons appreciate the balance of size and taste, ensuring they leave satisfied.
Benny Leone’s – State College, PA
In the heart of State College, Benny Leone’s serves 14-inch slices from their signature 28-inch pies. College students and locals flock here for the generous portions and quality flavor.
The friendly atmosphere and commitment to fresh ingredients make it a standout among local pizzerias. Quick sellouts are common as the demand during peak hours often outweighs supply. Benny Leone’s is not just about the size; it’s about creating memorable pizza experiences that keep people coming back.
Vinnie’s Pizza – Troy, PA
In the quaint town of Troy, Vinnie’s Pizza is celebrated for its perfectly balanced dough and homemade sausage. The cozy atmosphere and straightforward menu have captured the hearts of locals.
Vinnie’s dedication to quality ingredients and traditional methods ensures that every bite is a delight. Regulars know to arrive early, as slices are often gone before closing. It’s a place where simplicity meets excellence, and the community’s loyalty speaks volumes.
Scicchitano’s Pizzeria – Berwick, PA
Since 1958, Scicchitano’s Pizzeria has been a staple in Berwick, serving delicious, no-frills pies. The dedication to using high-quality ingredients and time-tested techniques has cemented its reputation.
The friendly, down-to-earth atmosphere invites patrons to enjoy pizza that feels like home. Quick sellouts are common, especially during peak dining times. Scicchitano’s is more than just a pizzeria; it’s a cherished part of the community, where tradition and taste go hand in hand.
Slice on Broadway – Pittsburgh, PA
Slice on Broadway is a Pittsburgh favorite, celebrated for its dedication to quality and community. Each pizza is crafted from scratch, with a focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
The inviting atmosphere and friendly service create a welcoming space for patrons. Slices disappear quickly, especially during peak hours, as locals flock for their pizza fix. Slice on Broadway is a reminder of how passion and quality can come together to create something truly special.
Angelo’s Pizza – Scranton, PA
Angelo’s Pizza in Scranton is a true staple, offering a wide variety of flavorful pies. Their emphasis on quality and customer satisfaction has earned them a devoted local following.
The warm ambiance and attentive service make every visit a pleasure. Slices often sell out before closing, a testament to the quality and taste that define Angelo’s. It’s a place where tradition meets innovation, creating pizzas that keep patrons coming back for more.
Rockaway Pizzeria – Pittsburgh, PA
Rockaway Pizzeria in Pittsburgh is known for its flavorful pies and welcoming service. With a menu offering diverse options, there’s something for every pizza lover.
The commitment to top-tier ingredients and creative combinations makes it a standout. Slices sell quickly, especially during busy hours, as the place buzzes with conversation and laughter. Rockaway Pizzeria is more than a dining spot; it’s a gathering place for community and culinary joy.
Pizzeria Vetri – Philadelphia, PA
Pizzeria Vetri is the go-to spot in Philadelphia for authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas. Known for using high-quality ingredients, their pizzas offer a delightful taste of Italy.
The modern, relaxed setting invites diners to savor each slice. Slices are a hot commodity, often selling out during peak dining times. It’s a culinary journey where tradition meets modernity, creating pizzas that leave a lasting impression. Pizzeria Vetri exemplifies the art of pizza-making at its finest.