New Jersey knows sandwiches like no other state. Forget the chains—locals crave subs that are stacked high, overflowing with fresh meats, crisp veggies, and bread baked just right. Every shop tells a story, and every bite hits with bold, unmistakable flavor. These are not just sandwiches—they’re a hometown ritual.
Pull up a chair or grab your sub to go. With every chew, you’ll understand why New Jersey locals keep skipping the chains. These shops serve flavor, pride, and tradition, all rolled into one unforgettable sandwich.
White House Subs
Since 1946, White House Subs in Atlantic City has been a local favorite, known for its oversized Italian heroes. The White House Special, a magnificent combination of salami, ham, provolone, and capicola, all packed in nearly two feet of crisp Atlantic City rolls, is a must-try.
The walls are adorned with photos of celebrities who’ve tasted these delights, adding a rich sense of history and fame. Situated near the boardwalk, this lively counter-service spot embodies classic comfort and nostalgia.
Open daily, it offers a taste of tradition with each generous bite. Whether you’re a tourist or a local, it’s a satisfying experience.
Bagliani’s Market
Bagliani’s Market, a family-run gem since 1959, melds Italian tradition with South Jersey charm. Known for its house-made sausages and fresh mozzarella, this market offers oversized Italian-style subs with rich imported meats.
The Deluxe Italian sub, featuring layers of salami, prosciutto, and marinated eggplant, is an artisanal delight that keeps locals coming back. The combination of a sandwich line for quick orders and artisanal pantry goods creates a unique shopping experience.
With a legacy steeped in tradition, Bagliani’s is a must-visit for lovers of authentic Italian flavors.
Joe Leone’s Italian Specialties
Since 1997, Joe Leone’s Italian Specialties in Point Pleasant Beach has been a haven for beach-bound sandwich lovers. Known for handmade breads and a rotating sandwich menu, this spot is celebrated for its fresh mozzarella.
The Italian Combo, packed with cured meats and fresh mozzarella on focaccia, is a symphony of flavors perfect for a seaside picnic. Combining a bakery, market, and sandwich counter, Joe Leone’s provides an energetic and bustling atmosphere.
Grab an Italian treat and enjoy the vibrant seasonal vibe at this shore-side favorite.
Cangiano’s Marketplace
Cangiano’s Marketplace in Jersey City combines an Italian market with a creative deli, offering a variety of numbered sandwiches with unique flavor profiles. The No. 17 sandwich, featuring prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, and spicy fig jam, is a bold and delicious choice.
With a community market vibe, this spot offers chef-level sandwiches and a butcher counter for those who want to take gourmet ingredients home.
The inventive combinations and high-quality ingredients make Cangiano’s a go-to destination for foodies seeking something special.
Denaro’s Submarine Sandwiches
Since 1962, Denaro’s Submarine Sandwiches in Dumont has been delighting locals with its legendary breaded chicken cutlets and oversized Italian heroes. The Crispy Chicken with Cheese is a standout, showcasing perfectly fried cutlets and soft, fresh bread.
This family-owned deli exudes hometown charm, offering reliable catering and hearty sandwiches that can satisfy any appetite. The welcoming atmosphere and generous portions make it a beloved spot for families and friends alike.
Get there early to ensure you snag one of their much-coveted loaves of bread.
Sugar Hill Sub & Deli
Sugar Hill Sub & Deli in Mays Landing is renowned for its hefty cheesesteaks and creative “Gut Buster” subs. The classic cheesesteak and the adventurous Gut Buster, filled with steak, mushrooms, peppers, mozzarella, and pepperoni, cater to big appetites.
This South Jersey favorite is known for its generous portions and friendly counter service. Open late, it’s perfect for those seeking a hearty meal after a day on the shore.
Bring friends to share the experience and enjoy the bold flavors that define Sugar Hill.
Iorio Deli & Coffee Stop (La Casa di Martino)
Iorio Deli & Coffee Stop in Roselle Park is celebrated for its award-winning Italian subs and homemade sauces. The “Big Al” Italian sub, packed with prosciutto, capicola, ham, and provolone, has garnered regional accolades.
This family-run deli offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere and was voted Best Sandwich Joint in New Jersey. Visitors can enjoy hearty meals and friendly service from morning to lunch.
Owner Gilda’s unique recipes and dedication to quality make this deli a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Italian flavors.