Some of the best pizza in America isn’t found in the big cities—it’s hiding along Pennsylvania’s backroads. Each stop has its own story—a century-old oven here, a secret sauce there—and the smell alone could make you hit the brakes.
From Old Forge trays dripping with cheese to hand-tossed pies baked in mom-and-pop kitchens, these ten spots prove you don’t need a skyline view to find world-class pizza. Just a hungry heart, an open road, and a little grease on your fingers.
Arcaro & Genell
Arcaro & Genell stands as a cornerstone of Old Forge’s pizza legacy. Family-operated, this landmark crafts rectangular trays laden with a cheese blend and slightly sweet tomato sauce. Each tray tells a story of local tradition and culinary pride.
The classic red tray with its crisp cheese layer is a must-try. The ambiance is warm, echoing years of pizza passion. Visiting during the Lackawanna County Pizza Trail provides a taste comparison opportunity. The place is a tribute to Old Forge’s unique pizza culture, making it a cherished stop for both locals and visitors.
Mary Lou’s Pizza
In the heart of Old Forge lies Mary Lou’s Pizza, a quaint takeout spot exuding charm and authenticity. Known for its white pizza tray, the shop attracts a loyal following. The handmade dough and family recipes speak of tradition.
Limited hours heighten the anticipation, with locals lining up early to snag a pie. The white pizza, oozing with blended cheeses, is a favorite. Despite its small size, Mary Lou’s impact on the community is immense, offering a genuine taste of Old Forge’s beloved pizza style.
Small Town Pizza
Small Town Pizza in Martinsburg embodies the essence of community dining. Known for its hand-tossed pies and reliable delivery, it offers a homely atmosphere. The house cheese pie or a local specialty with fresh toppings are recommended.
Reopened under new ownership, its commitment to quality and hometown charm remains. The friendly service and consistent value make it a beloved local staple. Whether for a quick lunch or a family dinner, Small Town Pizza serves as a reminder of simple pleasures in small-town life.
Penn Pizza Cucina Italiana
Penn Pizza Cucina Italiana in Bloomsburg captures the essence of a bustling college town. Offering slices and Sicilian pies, its expansive menu includes pasta and seafood. The Works Sicilian or ricotta-topped white pie are standout choices.
Generous portions and an easygoing vibe make it a favorite among students and families. Online ordering adds convenience, especially for busy schedules. The pizzeria’s commitment to hearty flavors and a welcoming atmosphere ensures it remains a central part of Bloomsburg’s dining scene.
Pizza Town I & Italian Restaurant
Pizza Town I & Italian Restaurant in Jonestown offers a cozy retreat for pizza lovers. Family-owned, it’s praised for consistent quality and generous portions. The specialty white-pizza and classic pepperoni pie shine alongside hearty breadsticks.
Warm service and authentic flavors make it a reliable stop on Pennsylvania’s backroads. Families appreciate both the value and the genuine Italian comfort food. It’s a place where small-town charm meets solid culinary craftsmanship, inviting travelers to savor more than just a meal.
Pizza Town Pizzeria & Trattoria
In Punxsutawney, Pizza Town Pizzeria & Trattoria stands as a local institution. Known for its fresh dough and family recipes, it has been a community staple for over 30 years. The large signature hand-tossed pie is a crowd favorite.
Lunch specials offer great value, while dinner entrées provide hearty satisfaction. The atmosphere is welcoming, embodying small-town hospitality. For those exploring Pennsylvania, it’s a place to enjoy genuine flavors and warm interactions, leaving diners with a taste of hometown pride.
Riviera Pizza & Pasta
Nestled in the heart of a quaint Pennsylvania town, Riviera Pizza & Pasta offers a blend of tradition and creativity. The warmth of the atmosphere is matched only by their classic pepperoni pie.
The crust is expertly crafted, striking a balance between crispness and chew. Their sauce, rich with a hint of garlic, complements fresh mozzarella perfectly.
Friendly service enhances the experience, making each visit a delightful escape. Locals and travelers alike rave about their specialty pies, often returning for more. It’s a slice of nostalgia wrapped in modern flavors.
Pizza Bella
Pizza Bella exudes charm with its vintage neon sign and family-run feel. The place is known for its welcoming vibe and delightful menu.
Their veggie pizza is a flavorful masterpiece, with fresh spinach, mushrooms, and bell peppers, all resting on a perfectly baked crust.
Warm hospitality is a hallmark here, making each patron feel like family. The combination of cozy ambiance and delectable food creates a memorable dining experience. Pizza Bella is more than just a meal; it’s a slice of small-town heart.
Pizza L’Oven
In the small town of Exeter, Pizza L’Oven is a culinary delight known for its thick, cheesy pies. The bustling atmosphere mirrors the passion of its patrons, who return time and again for the savory offerings.
The family-owned establishment boasts a unique blend of traditional recipes and modern flavors. Their pepperoni pizza, generously topped and perfectly seasoned, is a local legend.
With a history dating back to the 1960s, Pizza L’Oven has become a cornerstone of the community. Each bite offers a taste of nostalgia, wrapped in a warm, gooey embrace.
Pizza Joe’s
Pizza Joe’s in New Castle stands out with its lively decor and community-focused vibe. This local favorite serves pizzas with a twist, featuring unique toppings and creative combinations.
The BBQ chicken pizza, a crowd-pleaser, bursts with flavor and is topped with fresh ingredients. Pizza Joe’s offers a nostalgic slice of small-town life with every bite.
Their commitment to innovation is paired with a respect for classic recipes, ensuring every pizza feels like a new adventure while honoring tradition.