Indiana knows how to do sandwiches, and pork tenderloin reigns supreme. These aren’t dainty lunch bites—they’re colossal, hand-breaded, fried-to-golden perfection, spilling over the edges of the plate. Every café has its own twist: a secret seasoning, a house-made bun, or a tangy slaw that makes each bite unforgettable.
From small-town diners to beloved neighborhood cafés, Indiana’s pork tenderloin sandwiches are more than meals—they’re a rite of passage.
Nick’s Kitchen — Huntington, IN
Nick’s Kitchen in Huntington proudly claims to be the birthplace of Indiana’s breaded pork tenderloin. Their rendition features a hand-tenderized, buttermilk-soaked cutlet enveloped in a cracker crumb coating. This century-old diner offers a nostalgic experience, pairing tenderloins with sugar cream pie for dessert.
Located at 506 N Jefferson St, Huntington, it draws visitors eager to taste true Midwestern history. Open weekdays from early morning to mid-afternoon, it’s a must-visit for those seeking authenticity and charm. Regulars and newcomers alike revel in the iconic sandwich that started it all.
Aristocrat Pub & Restaurant — Indianapolis, IN
In the vibrant Broad Ripple area, Aristocrat Pub & Restaurant serves a Hoosier Tenderloin that’s a local favorite. With its distinctive seasoning and thin cutlet, this sandwich epitomizes pub perfection.
The Aristocrat is cherished for its friendly atmosphere and robust beer selection. Situated at 5212 N College Ave, it caters to lunch and dinner crowds, though it’s closed on Mondays. Those who frequent this spot appreciate not just the food but the camaraderie and spirited environment, making every visit memorable. The Hoosier Tenderloin is a staple that locals and visitors both relish.
Four Day Ray Brewing — Fishers, IN
Four Day Ray Brewing offers an Indiana Tenderloin that’s as impressive as its craft beer selection. Hand-breaded and served on a brioche bun, this sandwich is a star on their menu. Known for sourcing ingredients from local farms, the result is a fresh and flavorful dining experience. Located in Fishers, the hours vary, so checking ahead is wise.
Patrons enjoy the perfect pairing of food and brew, with the tenderloin being a highlight. This venue embraces a harmonious blend of cuisine and craft, drawing foodies and beer lovers alike.
The Willard — Franklin, IN
Located in Franklin, The Willard is celebrated for its hand-breaded and grilled tenderloins. Known for its well-seasoned breading, this sandwich has received contest accolades and is a staple on best-tenderloin lists.
Nestled at 99 N Main St, The Willard offers a welcoming atmosphere with delicious meals. Open for lunch and dinner, it’s a gathering place for locals who cherish its culinary traditions. Its tenderloin, paired with excellent onion rings, is a must-try. The restaurant’s reputation for quality and flavor keeps patrons returning for more.
Steer-In Restaurant — Indianapolis, IN
Steer-In Restaurant, a longstanding Indianapolis favorite, serves up Hoosier Tenderloins that diners adore. This east-side classic has been operating since 1960, providing an old-school diner experience. Located at 5130 E 10th St, it offers breakfast and lunch, with hours available online. Known for its consistent quality and welcoming atmosphere, Steer-In is a beloved neighborhood spot.
The generous portions and well-prepared dishes draw regulars who appreciate the charm and nostalgia. The Hoosier Tenderloin remains a signature item that keeps guests coming back.
The Grill-A — Markleville, IN
In Markleville, The Grill-A is famed for its enormous breaded pork tenderloin, a dish that local regulars claim is nearly unfinishable. This eatery offers a cozy, small-town feel with fast, friendly service. Situated at 4 W Main St, it provides dinner and weekend hours, so checking online is recommended.
The Grill-A draws in guests with its massive portions and genuine community atmosphere. The sandwich serves as both a culinary challenge and a taste of Hoosier hospitality. It’s a delightful stop for those craving a hearty meal.
Weenee World — New Castle, IN
Weenee World in New Castle is an amusement-style eatery known for its giant tenderloins and fun, family-oriented setting. With a carnival-like vibe, it’s a favorite for those seeking a playful dining experience. Located at 601 N Memorial Dr, it serves lunch and dinner year-round. The oversized tenderloin sandwiches are a highlight, drawing both locals and visitors.
This spot offers a blend of nostalgia and novelty, with dessert treats following the main course. It’s a place where the food is as entertaining as the environment, providing a memorable visit.