Pennsylvania pizza isn’t just food—it’s a full-on flavor adventure. From the moment the ovens fire up in the morning to the last slice served late at night, these pizza places keep the heat high and the lines long. The smell of bubbling cheese, fresh dough, and zesty sauce hits the senses and doesn’t let go.
Whether you’re after a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a late-night indulgence, these nine Pennsylvania pizzerias prove one thing: pizza here is more than a meal—it’s a reason to show up, stay a while, and savor every glorious bite.
Iron Born Pizza
Pittsburgh’s Iron Born Pizza is famed for its Detroit-style pies, offering thick, square crusts with caramelized cheese edges. Located in the Strip District and Millvale, it serves bubbly crusts with inventive toppings from lunch through dinner.
The dough’s 72-hour fermentation adds to its unique texture and flavor. Frequented by pizza aficionados, its friendly service and neighborhood vibe create a welcoming atmosphere. A favorite among locals, Iron Born keeps its patrons coming back with its distinctive style and quality ingredients.
Aiello’s Pizza
Since 1978, Aiello’s Pizza has been a Squirrel Hill staple, serving foldable New York-style slices with a sweet tomato sauce. Located on Murray Ave, it offers hoagies, strombolis, and craft beer. Known for its community feel, Aiello’s draws locals with its sizeable slices and budget-friendly prices.
Open from morning till late, it’s a reliable spot for a pizza fix any time. The combination of classic flavors and vibrant atmosphere makes it a go-to destination for casual dining in Pittsburgh.
Fiori’s Pizzaria
Fiori’s Pizzaria, a beloved Pittsburgh institution, is famous for its hand-tossed pies and late-night hours. Located on Capital Ave, it serves classic red pies that feel like a comforting family recipe. With modest prices and a relaxed ambiance, it’s a popular spot for locals seeking a late-night snack or a casual meal.
Its friendly legacy staff and retro vibe add to its charm, making it a regular haunt for those in search of authentic, timeless pizza.
Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room
In Pittsburgh’s Cultural District, Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room offers wood-fired pizzas alongside 30 craft beer taps. Located on 7th Street, it serves bold pizzas like the “Black & Gold” with sausage and caramelized onions.
The lively atmosphere, with theater-goers mingling, adds to its appeal. Open from early afternoon to late night, it’s a vibrant spot for pizza and drinks. The smoky, airy crusts crafted in their brick oven draw a diverse crowd, making it a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts.
Piccolo Forno
Piccolo Forno in Lawrenceville is a rustic Italian eatery known for its wood-burning pizza oven. Located on Butler Street, it crafts artisan pizzas with seasonal toppings like prosciutto and fresh basil. The warm, inviting atmosphere makes it ideal for cozy dinners.
Alongside pizza, it offers handmade pasta, providing a complete Italian dining experience. Its commitment to quality ingredients and traditional techniques create a memorable culinary journey for diners seeking authentic Italian flavors.
Pizzata Pizzeria
Philadelphia’s Pizzata Pizzeria blends Italian-American classics with local Philly flavor. Situated on South 22nd Street, it’s known for its round pies and specialty calzones. Open daily for lunch and dinner, it serves hearty, chewy crusts that cater to both locals and visitors.
With friendly service and a reputation for catering, it’s a staple for casual dining. Its cozy atmosphere and reliable quality make it a favored spot for those seeking a hearty, flavorful meal.
Mezzaluna Wood Fired Pizza
In Kennett Square, Mezzaluna Wood Fired Pizza crafts Neapolitan-style pizzas with high-quality, seasonal ingredients. Recognized in pizza competitions, it highlights farm-driven flavors such as wild mushrooms and heirloom tomatoes.
Open for both lunch and dinner, it offers a community-focused atmosphere. The crisp, blistered crusts and creative toppings reflect the local provenance, drawing pizza lovers from across the region. It’s a destination for those who appreciate artisanal quality and authentic taste.
New Columbus Pizza Co.
New Columbus Pizza Co. in Pittston is celebrated for its award-winning dough and authentic craftsmanship. Though a small local spot, it’s recognized among the world’s best, attracting serious pizza fans. The carefully fermented crust and locally sourced toppings offer globally competitive quality.
Open from morning to evening, it draws a devoted clientele seeking excellence in every slice. Its reputation as a hidden gem adds a sense of discovery for new visitors and long-time fans alike.
Slice on Broadway
Slice on Broadway offers a relaxed bar-pizzeria experience with wood-fired New York-style pies. Known for its late-night hours, it attracts dinner crowds and those seeking a nightcap. The menu features classics alongside specialty pies with creative toppings. Its combination of neighborhood bar charm and solid pizza makes it a popular spot in Pittsburgh.
With rotating beers and a welcoming ambiance, it’s a place where patrons enjoy good food and company in equal measure.