Discover nine hidden gems in Alabama where the pizza is unexpectedly delicious.
These places offer unique twists on classic pies, combining local charm with culinary creativity.
Whether you’re a fan of deep-dish, wood-fired, or inventive toppings, these pizzerias promise a memorable experience.
Valentina’s Pizzeria & Wine Bar – Madison
Valentina’s Pizzeria & Wine Bar in Madison is more than just a pizzeria; it’s an experience. Known for its inventive toppings and lively atmosphere, this spot attracts pizza lovers from afar.
Their classic and creative pies are a hit, offering something for every palate. The award-winning menu features unique combinations like fig and prosciutto or the spicy jalapeño and honey.
With friendly staff and a colorful ambiance, dining at Valentina’s feels like a special occasion. Pair your pizza with a selection from their wine bar for a perfect evening.
Tortugas Homemade Pizza – Birmingham & Hoover
If you’re craving authentic Chicago-style deep-dish pizza with a Southern flair, Tortugas Homemade Pizza is the place to be. Located in both Birmingham and Hoover, they serve hearty pies with generous toppings.
The crust is thick and buttery, packed with cheese and savory fillings. Regular patrons rave about their unique combinations, such as pepperoni and jalapeño.
Tortugas offers a cozy atmosphere, perfect for families or casual nights out. The deep flavors and rich textures ensure you leave satisfied, having discovered a slice of Chicago in Alabama.
Pizza Ed – Hartselle & Guntersville
Pizza Ed, located in Hartselle and Guntersville, masterfully combines New York-style thin crust with Chicago’s famous deep-dish. This dual focus makes it a versatile choice for pizza enthusiasts.
The pizzas are crafted with precision, ensuring each bite delivers on flavor. Their attention to detail is evident, from the fresh ingredients to the perfectly baked crust.
Locals appreciate the balance of tradition and creativity, making each visit a delightful surprise. The friendly atmosphere and diverse menu ensure there’s something for everyone at Pizza Ed.
Bettola – Birmingham
Nestled in Birmingham, Bettola offers a genuine taste of Italy with its wood-fired pizzas. The cozy spot is famous for its authentic flavors, using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients.
Each pizza is a work of art, with a thin, crispy crust and toppings that range from classic margherita to inventive creations. The wood-fired technique adds a unique smoky flavor that sets Bettola apart.
Whether you’re a pizza purist or adventurous eater, Bettola provides a satisfying culinary journey. The warm, rustic setting is perfect for intimate dinners or lively gatherings.
DePalma’s – Tuscaloosa
DePalma’s in Tuscaloosa is a local favorite, renowned for its inviting atmosphere and diverse pizza offerings. The menu blends traditional and innovative, satisfying both classic cravings and adventurous tastes.
Regulars are drawn to their signature pizzas, like the spicy pepperoni or the veggie-loaded option. Each pie is crafted with care, ensuring quality and flavor.
The warm, welcoming environment makes DePalma’s a community hub. Whether dining solo or with friends, the experience is enhanced by the friendly staff and consistent excellence of their pizzas.
Slice Pizza & Brew – Birmingham
Slice Pizza & Brew in Birmingham is the go-to spot for innovative, New York-style slices. Known for its creativity, the menu boasts a range of toppings from classic to unexpected.
Their craft beers perfectly complement the eclectic pizzas, enhancing the dining experience. The environment is lively, making it a popular hangout for locals and visitors alike.
The casual, fun atmosphere invites conversation and enjoyment. Whether you’re trying a unique slice or sticking to a favorite, Slice offers a memorable pizza outing.
Uncle G’s – Birmingham
Uncle G’s is a neighborhood gem in Birmingham, beloved for its cozy ambiance and delicious pizzas. The friendly service and welcoming environment make it a favorite among locals.
Their pizzas are crafted with care, using high-quality ingredients that shine in every bite. Whether opting for a simple cheese or a loaded supreme, satisfaction is guaranteed.
Frequent visitors praise the consistent quality and warm atmosphere. Uncle G’s is more than just a pizzeria; it’s a community gathering spot where everyone feels at home.
Troup’s – Birmingham
Troup’s in Birmingham is celebrated for its historic charm and unique offerings, most notably their breakfast pizza. This standout dish combines breakfast favorites with a pizza twist.
The eatery exudes a vintage vibe, inviting diners to enjoy both the food and the ambiance. Regulars appreciate the creativity and quality that goes into each dish.
Troup’s provides a distinctive dining experience that blends history with culinary innovation. It’s a must-visit for anyone seeking something new and delicious in Birmingham.
Mozza – Huntsville
Mozza in Huntsville offers a modern take on classic pizza recipes, delivering flavorful and memorable pies. The sleek, contemporary setting attracts a trendy, diverse crowd.
Their menu is a showcase of creativity, with pizzas that feature unexpected yet delightful combinations. The commitment to quality and fresh ingredients is evident in every bite.
Mozza stands out for its bold approach to traditional dishes, making it a favorite among those seeking both style and substance. The combination of modern flair and classic roots creates a standout dining experience.