Whoopie pies were never meant to sit on a gas station shelf. In Pennsylvania’s Amish Country, these pillowy chocolate cakes stuffed with creamy filling are still made the way they were generations ago—by hand, in small batches, using simple ingredients and serious care. No shortcuts. No plastic wrap. Just pure, nostalgic joy. You won’t find flashy signs or long Instagram lines outside these bakeries. Most are tucked inside barns, roadside stands, or family-run shops where time moves slower and the ovens never stop. If your sweet tooth is craving the real thing—the kind of whoopie pie that melts in your mouth and sticks to your memory—this list is your map. Grab a napkin and let’s go.
Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop
Nestled in the heart of Bird-in-Hand, PA, this beloved bake shop has been a Lancaster County staple since the 1970s. Known for its irresistible handmade whoopie pies, the bakery offers a charming array of classic and seasonal flavors. Visitors rave about the chocolate-peanut butter version—a true fan favorite.
Everything here is crafted using traditional Amish methods, ensuring authenticity in every bite. The bakery’s welcoming atmosphere and dedication to quality make it a must-visit destination for both locals and tourists seeking a taste of genuine Amish baking.
Emma’s Gourmet Popcorn
While Emma’s Gourmet Popcorn in New Holland, PA, may surprise visitors with its name, it’s the fluffy whoopie pies that steal the show. This bakery is a hidden gem, celebrated for its rotating fillings that keep locals and visitors coming back.
From maple cream to lemon and strawberry, the flavors are as delightful as they are unexpected. Each pie is a testament to creativity, nestled in a charming setting that invites exploration and indulgence.
The Bake Shop at Kitchen Kettle Village
Located in the heart of Intercourse, PA, The Bake Shop at Kitchen Kettle Village is a lively spot that offers consistently perfect whoopie pies. Each pie is hand-filled daily and wrapped with care, showcasing a dedication to quality and tradition.
While the bakery offers a wide range of treats, the traditional chocolate-vanilla combo remains a staple that keeps locals returning for more. The vibrant atmosphere of Kitchen Kettle Village adds to the experience, making it a delightful destination for anyone exploring Amish Country.
Dutch Haven
Dutch Haven in Ronks, PA, is a place where nostalgia and sweetness come together. While famous for its shoofly pie, this bakery also excels in crafting soft, generously sized whoopie pies. Each is handmade daily, featuring an extra-thick filling that nods to Amish dessert traditions.
The iconic windmill and charming atmosphere make it a memorable stop for visitors. It’s a delightful journey into the heart of Amish baking, where every bite carries a touch of history and tradition.
Shady Maple Farm Market
At Shady Maple Farm Market in East Earl, PA, the bakery counter is a paradise for whoopie pie lovers. With dozens of flavors to choose from, including red velvet and oatmeal raisin, there’s something to satisfy every palate.
Everything is made fresh in-house using traditional Pennsylvania Dutch recipes, ensuring authenticity and flavor in every bite. The market’s lively atmosphere and wide selection make it a must-visit destination for those exploring local culinary delights.
Achenbach’s Pastry Inc.
In Leola, PA, Achenbach’s Pastry Inc. has been delighting customers since 1954. While best known for its Long Johns, the bakery’s whoopie pies are just as worthy of praise. These hefty, hand-piped treats come in fun variations like pumpkin or chocolate chip, catering to a wide range of tastes.
Each pie reflects a dedication to quality and creativity, making every visit a delightful culinary adventure. It’s a place where tradition meets innovation, creating a perfect harmony of flavors.
Zook’s Homemade Chicken Pies
Known primarily for savory delights, Zook’s Homemade Chicken Pies in Ronks, PA, also has a tiny adjacent bakery that shouldn’t be overlooked. Here, the whoopie pies are rich, ultra-fresh, and devoid of unnecessary frills.
The emphasis is on simplicity and tradition, with recipes passed down through generations. Each bite offers a taste of honest-to-goodness baking, providing a comforting link to the past and a satisfying treat for the present.
Lapp Valley Farm Creamery
Lapp Valley Farm Creamery in New Holland, PA, is renowned for its small-batch ice cream, but it’s the frozen whoopie pies that offer a unique twist. Here, ice cream is sandwiched between fresh-baked cookies, creating a delightful hybrid dessert.
The picturesque setting and innovative treats make it a standout destination for those seeking something special. It’s Amish Country’s coolest dessert, offering a refreshing take on a beloved classic.
The Sweet Shoppe at Stoltzfus Meats
Located within a family-run butcher and market in Intercourse, PA, The Sweet Shoppe at Stoltzfus Meats delivers a straightforward, old-fashioned take on whoopie pies. The rich, sugary filling and melt-in-your-mouth cakes make it a true hidden gem.
The simplicity and dedication to traditional recipes shine through, offering a delightful indulgence that feels like a sweet embrace from the past. It’s a charming destination for anyone exploring the flavors of Amish Country.