Who says you need to live on the coast to enjoy a perfect lobster roll? Ohio’s hidden seafood spots are flipping that notion on its head. From Cleveland to Columbus, these cozy eateries are serving buttery, tender lobster piled high on toasted buns, dripping with flavor that rivals any New England seaside shack.
Whether you crave a classic Maine-style roll, a garlic-butter twist, or something unexpected, these ten Ohio gems prove that great seafood doesn’t need an ocean view. Get ready to taste lobster perfection, right in the heart of the Buckeye State.
Cousins Maine Lobster – Cleveland
In Cleveland, Cousins Maine Lobster serves up a taste of New England with their renowned lobster rolls. Known for their food truck charm, they offer both Maine and Connecticut-style rolls. Fresh lobster meat is lovingly packed into a toasted bun, bringing the coast to the Midwest.
The experience is both casual and satisfying, with a focus on quality ingredients. Their reputation for authenticity makes them a go-to for seafood lovers seeking genuine flavors.
Visit them at various locations throughout Cleveland, and enjoy a bite that transports you to the Atlantic shores.
COLO Market & Oyster Bar – Columbus
COLO Market & Oyster Bar in Columbus is a haven for seafood enthusiasts. Their lobster rolls are a standout, offering a choice between Maine-style with chilled lobster, or Connecticut-style with warm, buttery lobster.
The ambiance is sophisticated, yet welcoming, making it perfect for both casual and special occasions. Freshness is paramount, and every bite reflects their dedication to quality.
In addition to lobster rolls, they boast an impressive oyster selection, adding to the allure for seafood aficionados. A visit to COLO promises a flavorful escape from the ordinary.
The Lobster Pot – Willoughby Hills
The Lobster Pot in Willoughby Hills offers a charming, rustic setting where seafood takes center stage. Their lobster rolls are crafted with care, combining succulent lobster with just the right amount of dressing.
Dining here feels like a coastal retreat, with a menu that complements the star attraction, including clam chowder and other seafood staples. The commitment to quality shines through in every dish.
The welcoming atmosphere and delicious offerings make The Lobster Pot a delightful escape for those seeking a seafood indulgence in Ohio.
The Governor – Milford
The Governor in Milford takes pride in their innovative approach to the classic lobster roll. Featuring brown-butter-lemon mayo, celery hearts, and shredded lettuce, their version is a harmonious blend of textures and flavors.
The ambiance is warm and inviting, perfect for leisurely dining with friends or family. Patrons appreciate the creative spin on traditional seafood offerings.
With a focus on fresh ingredients and inventive recipes, The Governor continues to captivate locals and visitors alike, establishing itself as a must-visit destination for seafood lovers.
Pickle Bill’s Lobster House – Grand River
Pickle Bill’s Lobster House in Grand River offers a lively dining experience with river views and seafood aplenty. Their lobster rolls are a highlight, served alongside all-you-can-eat crab legs and prime rib.
This bustling locale is perfect for those who enjoy hearty portions and a vibrant atmosphere. The menu caters to diverse tastes, ensuring everyone finds something to savor.
Famous for their generous servings and friendly service, Pickle Bill’s remains a staple for both seafood lovers and those seeking a memorable dining outing.
Jolly Roger Seafood House – Cleveland
Jolly Roger Seafood House in Cleveland is where locals find comfort in quality seafood. Known for their lobster rolls, they emphasize freshness and consistency in every dish.
The setting is cozy and unpretentious, making it an ideal spot for casual dining. Friendly service complements the delightful menu, ensuring a pleasant experience for all visitors.
Their commitment to using the finest ingredients shines through, making Jolly Roger a beloved choice for seafood enthusiasts seeking a reliable and enjoyable meal.
Pier W – Lakewood
Pier W in Lakewood offers a sophisticated dining experience with stunning views of Lake Erie. Their lobster rolls are a testament to culinary excellence, marrying fresh lobster with delicate seasoning.
The elegant ambiance and breathtaking scenery create a perfect backdrop for a memorable meal. Whether celebrating a special occasion or enjoying a leisurely lunch, Pier W delivers in style.
A landmark in Lakewood, this restaurant combines fine dining with a relaxed vibe, making it a standout choice for those who appreciate the finer things in life.
RH Rooftop Restaurant – Columbus
RH Rooftop Restaurant in Columbus brings culinary artistry to new heights with their exquisite lobster rolls. Set in a stylish environment, the combination of chic décor and exceptional cuisine creates a unique dining experience.
Their lobster rolls are crafted with precision, offering a balance of flavors that delight the palate. The attention to detail extends beyond the food, with ambiance playing a crucial role in the overall experience.
Perfect for those who appreciate elegance and innovation, RH Rooftop Restaurant is a must-visit for discerning diners seeking something extraordinary.
Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls – Columbus
Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls in Columbus offers a casual yet vibrant atmosphere where lobster takes center stage. Known for their traditional Maine-style rolls, they deliver authenticity and flavor in every bite.
The laid-back setting is perfect for a quick lunch or relaxed dinner, catering to seafood lovers who crave simplicity and taste. Fresh ingredients and meticulous preparation ensure a satisfying meal.
Mason’s commitment to quality and tradition has earned them a loyal following, making it a favorite stop for anyone seeking a genuine lobster roll experience.
COLO Burger & Oyster Bar – Columbus
COLO Burger & Oyster Bar in Columbus blends innovation with tradition, offering creative takes on seafood dishes, including their signature lobster rolls. The setting is modern and relaxed, perfect for unwinding with friends.
Their menu showcases fresh ingredients, with inventive combinations that surprise and delight. The lobster rolls stand out as a delicious testament to their culinary creativity.
Whether you’re in the mood for oysters, burgers, or a unique lobster roll, COLO Burger & Oyster Bar promises a memorable dining experience with flair.