Skip to Content

9 donut shops around Ohio where self-control doesn’t last long

9 donut shops around Ohio where self-control doesn’t last long

Sharing is caring!

Ohio is a haven for donut enthusiasts, boasting a plethora of shops where tempting treats await. Each establishment offers its own unique flair, guaranteeing a delightful experience.

Whether you’re a local or just passing through, these Ohio donut shops promise to challenge your willpower.

Buckeye Donuts

Buckeye Donuts
© Buckeye Donuts

At the heart of Columbus, Buckeye Donuts has been serving the community since 1969. Known for its 24/7 service, this place is a haven for late-night snackers and early risers alike.

Each donut is crafted with care, reflecting years of tradition and love.The standout here is their signature Buckeye donut, a delightful twist on the classic buckeye candy. Imagine biting into a fluffy donut, perfectly complemented by creamy peanut butter and rich chocolate icing.

Besides the classics, they offer an array of flavors that cater to every palate.Whether you’re enjoying a morning coffee or looking for a midnight treat, Buckeye Donuts offers more than just food; it’s an experience. The ambiance, filled with vibrant conversations and warm lights, invites you to stay a while.

Truly, stepping into Buckeye is like walking into a comforting embrace of nostalgia and flavor.

Holtman’s Donuts

Holtman's Donuts
© Holtman’s Donut Shop

Holtman’s Donuts, a Cincinnati staple, has been winning hearts since 1960. With its rustic charm and friendly service, it feels like stepping back into a simpler time.

The aroma of freshly baked goods greets you as you enter, promising a delightful experience.Known for their innovative flavors, Holtman’s boasts a donut selection that ranges from classic glazed to quirky bacon maple. Each bite reveals a perfect balance of texture and flavor, crafted to perfection.

Their donuts are not just food items but tiny works of art.The shop’s commitment to quality is evident, using fresh ingredients to ensure top-notch taste. Regulars swear by their apple fritters, generously filled with cinnamon and apple chunks.

If you’re in Cincinnati, a visit to Holtman’s is essential—not just for the donuts, but for the nostalgic ambiance that transports you to yesteryears.

Amy’s Donuts

Amy's Donuts
© Amy’s Donuts

Amy’s Donuts in Columbus is a colorful wonderland that delights both the eyes and the taste buds. Walking into Amy’s is like entering a candy shop; bright colors and an array of mouthwatering options greet you at every turn.Their selection is vast, with over 100 donut varieties to choose from at any given time.

Unique flavor combinations like Fruity Pebbles or Maple Bacon ensure there’s something for everyone. Each donut is meticulously prepared, providing a perfect balance of sweetness and indulgence.Beyond the delightful treats, the atmosphere at Amy’s is welcoming and vibrant.

Staff members are always ready with a smile, eager to help you find your new favorite flavor. For a truly unforgettable donut experience, Amy’s in Columbus is the place to be.

Stan the Donut Man

Stan the Donut Man
© Stan the Donut Man

In Dayton, Stan the Donut Man is a local legend. This family-owned gem has been delighting customers with its fantastic selection of donuts for generations.

With a charmingly unassuming exterior, the real magic happens inside.The warmth of this neighborhood staple is palpable, with a friendly team always ready to serve. Their donuts are classic, yet each has its own special twist that makes it irresistible.

The glazed donuts here are a must-try, with a texture so light and fluffy, it practically melts in your mouth.Stan the Donut Man is more than just a donut shop; it’s a community hub where friends and families gather over coffee and fresh pastries. This Dayton treasure continues to be a beloved favorite for good reason, offering a sweet slice of nostalgia with every visit.

Peace, Love and Little Donuts

Peace, Love and Little Donuts
© Peace, Love and Little Donuts of Worthington

Cleveland’s Peace, Love and Little Donuts embraces the spirit of the 1960s with its retro vibe and eclectic selection. As you walk in, the groovy atmosphere and psychedelic decor immediately set the tone for a fun visit.Specializing in miniature donuts, their creations are as exciting as they are tasty.

From s’mores to raspberry lemonade, each mini donut packs a punch of flavor. It’s the perfect spot for those who love variety, allowing you to enjoy multiple flavors without feeling overwhelmed.Staffed by a cheerful crew, the shop ensures every visit is as enjoyable as the donuts themselves.

Whether you’re grabbing a quick breakfast or indulging in an afternoon treat, Peace, Love and Little Donuts promises a delightful experience filled with nostalgia and sweetness.

Jolly Pirate Donuts

Jolly Pirate Donuts
© Jolly Pirate Donuts

In Reynoldsburg, Jolly Pirate Donuts is a beloved institution that has been serving delicious pastries since 1968. With its classic charm and pirate-themed decor, it offers a whimsical twist on your typical donut shop experience.Their donuts are a testament to time-honored recipes, with fluffy textures and rich flavors.

Classics like the glazed donut and apple fritter are fan favorites, but adventurous eaters will find plenty to explore among their seasonal specials.More than just a spot for sweet treats, Jolly Pirate provides a cozy atmosphere perfect for enjoying a leisurely coffee or catching up with friends. Its enduring appeal lies in the combination of quality donuts and a warm environment that welcomes everyone like family.

Der Dutchman Bakery

Der Dutchman Bakery
© Der Dutchman

Nestled in Plain City, Der Dutchman Bakery is part of an Amish establishment known for its hearty meals and exceptional baked goods. This place transports you to a world of rustic charm and simple pleasures.Donuts here are crafted with precision and love, capturing the essence of traditional Amish recipes.

The apple fritters are particularly noteworthy, offering a delightful crunch and bursts of cinnamon flavor with every bite. The bakery’s commitment to using fresh, local ingredients shines through in every pastry.The welcoming atmosphere of Der Dutchman invites you to slow down and savor each treat.

It’s more than just a bakery; it’s a peek into a lifestyle rooted in community and craftsmanship, making it a must-visit for anyone passing through Plain City.

Fox’s Donut Den

Fox's Donut Den
© Fox’s Donut Den

In Cuyahoga Falls, Fox’s Donut Den is a hidden gem that promises a delightful escape from the ordinary. This quaint shop offers a personal touch with every visit, making it a favorite among locals.Donuts here are crafted with quality and care, featuring both classic options and inventive flavors.

Their lemon-filled donuts are a standout, providing a refreshing burst of citrus in every bite. The cozy atmosphere invites you to linger over coffee and conversation.Fox’s is more than just a donut shop; it’s a place where the community gathers to enjoy good food and great company.

Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a regular, this charming establishment offers a warm welcome and delicious treats that keep you coming back for more.

Schneider’s Bakery

Schneider's Bakery
© Schneider’s Bakery

Schneider’s Bakery in Westerville is a piece of history dating back to 1957. This charming establishment has a nostalgic feel, offering a glimpse into the past with its classic bakery ambiance.Their donuts are a testament to tradition, featuring time-honored recipes passed down through generations.

The cream sticks and jelly-filled donuts are particularly popular, showcasing rich, indulgent flavors that satisfy any sweet tooth.More than just a bakery, Schneider’s is a cornerstone of the community, where memories are made over delicious pastries and warm greetings. For anyone visiting Westerville, a stop at Schneider’s Bakery is essential, providing a taste of history wrapped in delightful sweetness.