When people think of the Florida Keys, they often picture sunsets over turquoise water, umbrella drinks in hand, and breezy seafood joints perched on stilts. And while the views are undeniably part of the charm, there’s a deeper culinary story happening here—one that locals know by heart. Beneath the tourist favorites and tiki bars lies a collection of restaurants where the food isn’t just good—it’s the reason people return again and again. These are the spots where the grouper is grilled to perfection, the key lime pie tastes like someone’s grandmother made it, and the conch fritters don’t come frozen from a bag.
The beauty of the Keys’ culinary scene is how diverse and unpretentious it can be. One night, you might be savoring a fresh hogfish sandwich under a tin roof while chickens wander past your table. The next, you’re diving into spicy Cuban-style shrimp cooked with a recipe that’s been in the family for generations. This isn’t just beachy food—it’s soulful, heritage-driven cooking that blends Caribbean, Latin, Southern, and local seafood influences in a way that’s uniquely Floridian. And more often than not, the most delicious bites come from places you might overlook unless a local points you there.
So if you’re headed to the Keys and want to eat like the locals do, this list is for you. From Key Largo to Key West, these 12 restaurants serve dishes so memorable that you’ll forget all about the ocean view—at least until dessert.
Hobo’s Café – Key Largo
Hobo’s Café in Key Largo is a beloved local hangout. Famous for its fresh-caught seafood, the café offers generous portions and a warm, unfussy vibe. Locals recommend the grilled mahi mahi sandwich, a dish that captures the essence of the Keys.
A slice of homemade Key lime pie rounds off the meal on a sweet note. Whether you’re a seafood lover or a dessert aficionado, Hobo’s Café caters to all. Its laid-back atmosphere invites diners to relax and enjoy a true taste of the Florida Keys.
The Fish House – Key Largo
The Fish House is a Key Largo institution. Known for its signature yellowtail snapper, this spot epitomizes old-school Florida charm. The “Matecumbe-style” preparation has become legendary, attracting seafood enthusiasts from near and far.
The rustic decor and friendly service make diners feel at home, while the mouth-watering dishes ensure a memorable culinary experience. For those who cherish tradition and flavor, The Fish House remains a must-visit destination. Its commitment to quality and taste has made it a favorite among locals.
Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen – Key Largo
At Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen, comfort food gets a tropical twist. Located in Key Largo, this charming eatery serves coconut shrimp and house-made chili in a quirky setting.
The eclectic decor, featuring license plates and tropical motifs, adds to the dining experience. Whether you’re craving a taste of the tropics or a hearty meal, Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen delivers flavor and fun in equal measure. It’s a place where food and atmosphere come together to create lasting memories for both locals and visitors.
Morada Bay Café – Islamorada
Morada Bay Café, located in Islamorada, offers a unique blend of Mediterranean and Caribbean flavors. While the view is stunning, it’s the dishes like seared scallops with tropical fruit salsa that capture the hearts of diners.
Locals appreciate the creative menu that takes them on a culinary journey. The relaxing ambiance, paired with flavorful dishes, makes it a cherished spot for those seeking both taste and tranquility. More than just a meal, a visit to Morada Bay Café is an experience to savor.
Chef Michael’s – Islamorada
Chef Michael’s in Islamorada balances upscale dining with casual comfort. Known for its locally speared lionfish, the restaurant provides a unique dining experience that’s both elegant and approachable.
Many locals choose Chef Michael’s for special occasions, drawn by the innovative menu and exquisite flavors. It’s a place where culinary artistry meets heartfelt hospitality, creating moments that linger in memory long after the meal is over. For a taste of the extraordinary, Chef Michael’s is the go-to choice.
The Green Turtle Inn – Islamorada
The Green Turtle Inn, a historic eatery in Islamorada, offers a menu rich with classic Keys cuisine. Established in the 1940s, this restaurant is steeped in vintage charm.
From turtle chowder to shrimp and grits, the Green Turtle Inn serves dishes that tell the story of the Keys. Its eclectic menu and welcoming atmosphere make it a favorite among locals and a living piece of history. For those who appreciate tradition and taste, it’s a must-visit spot in the Florida Keys.
The Square Grouper Bar & Grill – Cudjoe Key
The Square Grouper Bar & Grill in Cudjoe Key is a modern dining spot with a creative twist. Known for its locally sourced ingredients, the menu features vegan options alongside fresh seafood specials.
This tucked-away gem offers a contemporary take on Keys cuisine, appealing to a diverse range of palates. The lively atmosphere and innovative dishes make it a standout choice for those looking to explore new culinary horizons. Locals and visitors alike find joy in the unexpected delights of The Square Grouper.
The Galley Grill – Summerland Key
The Galley Grill, located in Summerland Key, is a hidden treasure for breakfast and lunch lovers. Known for its lobster omelet and crab cake sandwich, this low-key spot delivers pure flavor without the frills.
Locals appreciate the straightforward approach to dining, where the focus is on the food. With its casual ambiance and delightful menu, The Galley Grill offers a little slice of heaven in the heart of the Keys. It’s a place where simplicity meets satisfaction, making it a beloved local haunt.
Kiki’s Sandbar – Little Torch Key
Kiki’s Sandbar in Little Torch Key is the epitome of beachy bliss. Known for its killer fish tacos and frozen drinks, this joint often features live music that keeps the vibe lively and fun.
Locals flock here for happy hour deals and the chance to unwind with friends. The sand beneath your feet and the ocean breeze make dining at Kiki’s a quintessential Keys experience. It’s more than just a meal; it’s a celebration of good times and great company.
El Siboney – Key West
El Siboney, a cherished Cuban restaurant in Key West, offers authentic flavors that locals adore. Known for its roast pork, black beans, and sweet plantains, it’s a place where affordability meets authenticity.
The lively atmosphere and delicious dishes keep patrons coming back for more. El Siboney’s reputation for quality and taste makes it a staple in the community, where every meal feels like a fiesta. It’s a celebration of Cuban culture and cuisine, right in the heart of Key West.
Garbo’s Grill – Key West
Garbo’s Grill, once a humble food truck, has become a cult classic in Key West. Known for its Korean BBQ tacos and ahi tuna burgers, the charm of this spot lies in its funky, laid-back vibe.
Despite the long lines, locals return time and again, drawn by the unique flavors and casual atmosphere. Garbo’s Grill offers a taste of creativity and originality that resonates with all who visit. It’s an unassuming gem that has captured the hearts of many with its culinary surprises.
Fisherman’s Café – Key West
Fisherman’s Café in Key West is a grab-and-go spot that packs big flavors into every bite. Located near the marina, it’s a favorite for its Cuban coffee, breakfast sandwiches, and fish bites that embody the essence of the Keys.
The convenient location and delicious offerings make it a popular choice for locals on the move. Whether starting the day or grabbing a quick midday meal, Fisherman’s Café delivers satisfaction with every bite. It’s a slice of Key West life that’s both flavorful and fulfilling.