Not all key lime pie is created equal. Some slices are forgettable, some are flat-out fake—and then there are the few that hit you with the perfect punch of tart, creamy, graham-crackery magic. Florida has no shortage of spots claiming to serve “the best.” But most fall short—too sweet, too bland, too… whatever that green food coloring is. You want the real thing. The kind of pie that tastes like sunshine and sea breeze, with a zing that makes your eyes pop. Whether it’s stacked with sky-high meringue in Key West, tucked into a diner off the highway, or hiding behind the bakery counter at your local Publix, these nine pies deliver. No gimmicks. No sugar overload. Just pure, Florida-born flavor. Grab a fork. You’re going to want a bite of every single one.
Blue Heaven – Key West
In the heart of Key West, Blue Heaven offers a towering slice of key lime pie topped with a cloud of meringue. This open-air restaurant, nestled under banyan trees, is as famous for its pie as it is for the roosters wandering about. The pie’s tangy filling and homemade crust create a perfect balance, making it a must-try. The ambiance, a blend of classic Key West flavor and bohemian charm, adds to the unique experience. A visit here feels like stepping into a postcard of island life.
Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe – Key West
Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe is a staple in the Florida Keys, renowned for its unapologetically tart key lime pie. Whether you prefer it as a traditional slice, chocolate-dipped bar, or frozen treat, there’s a version for every palate. The shop’s zesty creations embody the essence of the Keys. Each bite is a burst of citrus that locals and tourists alike crave. This iconic spot ensures that you experience the true taste of Florida’s beloved pie. It’s a tart, zesty adventure in every form imaginable.
The Fish House – Key Largo
Known for its seafood, The Fish House in Key Largo also excels in crafting a key lime pie that complements its oceanic offerings. The creamy texture and not-too-sweet taste, combined with a thick graham cracker crust, make it a perfect dessert. After a meal of conch chowder or blackened mahi, this pie leaves a refreshing finish. The charm of the restaurant lies not only in its famed seafood but in the citrus bliss that their pie delivers. It’s a must-stop on the Overseas Highway.
Old Town Bakery – Key West
Old Town Bakery is a quaint spot in Key West where pie enthusiasts gather for breakfast or dessert. Their key lime pie, silky smooth and refreshingly tart, is perfectly balanced. Pairing it with a strong cup of Cuban coffee makes for a delightful start or end to any day. The bakery’s cozy atmosphere enhances the enjoyment of each bite. It’s a small, charming location where every pie is crafted with care and tradition. Ideal for those who appreciate a well-made pastry in a serene setting.
Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen – Key Largo
Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen, a funky roadside diner in Key Largo, has been serving its famous key lime pie for decades. The pie’s thick, rich custard texture and generous whipped cream topping make it a favorite among locals. This no-frills diner offers a full-flavor experience, where simplicity meets perfection. The pie is as vibrant as the diner itself, capturing the essence of classic Florida dessert. Each slice tells a story of tradition and taste, unchanged through years of culinary delight.
Red Bar – Grayton Beach
Red Bar in Grayton Beach proves that you don’t have to travel south for authentic key lime pie. This Panhandle favorite delivers a tangy, creamy creation that stands out on the Emerald Coast. The pie, with its precise lime zing, captivates both locals and visitors. The lively atmosphere of Red Bar, coupled with its remarkable dessert, makes for a memorable dining experience. It’s the perfect spot to enjoy a slice while taking in the beachside vibes. A true Emerald Coast treasure.
Publix Bakery – Statewide
Surprisingly delightful, Publix Bakery’s key lime pie earns its place on this list. This grocery store favorite nails the balance between sweet and tart, featuring a legit graham cracker crust. It’s a staple for many Floridians, perfect for a beach trip or casual gathering. While it may not boast the glamour of a standalone bakery, the taste is shockingly good. Each pie offers a touch of homemade nostalgia, proving that sometimes the best things are found in unexpected places.
Joe’s Stone Crab – Miami Beach
At Joe’s Stone Crab, old-school elegance meets the cool citrus of key lime pie. This Miami Beach icon finishes every meal with a refined slice that’s both sophisticated and delicious. Served on vintage china with a dollop of whipped cream, the pie has a velvety texture that melts in your mouth. It’s a taste of Miami’s past and present, a seamless blend of flavor and tradition. Joe’s offers more than just seafood; it provides a citrus delight that’s as classic as the restaurant itself.
Pineapple Willy’s – Panama City Beach
Pineapple Willy’s in Panama City Beach serves up more than beachfront views; their key lime pie is a testament to relaxation and flavor. Chilled to perfection with a buttery crust, it’s the ideal dessert to enjoy with the ocean breeze. While it may have a touristy air, the taste is undeniably delicious. The laid-back ambiance complements the pie’s refreshing tang, making it a favorite among beachgoers. This spot captures the essence of a beachside escape, one tangy bite at a time.