Ready for a treasure hunt that actually pays off? Indiana’s biggest secondhand shops deliver deep racks, overflowing furniture aisles, and prices that make a road trip feel like a smart strategy.
Whether you love curated vintage or dig‑through‑the‑bins chaos, these large, well‑stocked spots are worth the miles. Map a loop, clear your trunk, and chase the thrills only great thrift scores can bring.
Mission 27 Resale – Indianapolis
When you want a clean, spacious store where everything feels easy to scan, Mission 27 Resale delivers. You get color‑blocked racks, furniture staged like mini rooms, and home goods arranged so you can visualize them in your space.
Prices are fair, with frequent tag sales that make upgrading a room or closet surprisingly affordable.
The store leans into quality basics and standout vintage finds, so both everyday shoppers and decor hunters leave happy. Furniture turns fast, but you will usually spot solid wood pieces, accent chairs, and quirky lighting.
The book and housewares sections reward slow browsing, especially if you love classic kitchenware.
Expect helpful staff who know the floor and can point you toward sizes or departments quickly. Parking is easy, and the layout is accessible for strollers and carts.
If you are furnishing on a budget, the mix of dressers, coffee tables, and framed art can anchor a room in one trip.
Pro tip: Start with furniture, then loop back for clothing. Check seasonal displays for themed deals and watch for markdown days that stack savings.
You will leave with practical pieces and a few feel‑good surprises supporting a community mission.
Goodwill Outlet Store – Indianapolis (N Franklin Rd)
If you thrive on the thrill of the hunt, the Goodwill Outlet on N Franklin Rd is your arena. Items are sold by the pound, so you can experiment with styles and projects without stressing over tags.
Bring gloves, hydrate, and pace yourself because the bin rotations keep the energy high.
Clothing dominates, but books, linens, electronics, and oddities show up constantly. You will find denim by the armful, graphic tees, and the occasional vintage gem.
Be patient with pairs of shoes and lids for containers, and always check seams, zippers, and liners.
Timing matters here. Early mornings and rotation callouts are prime, and regulars line up when new bins roll out.
You can build a wardrobe, stock a resale booth, or load up on craft textiles for a fraction of regular thrift prices.
Bring reusable bags or bins for sorting in your trunk. Weigh items often so you are not surprised at checkout.
Keep an eye on electronics until you test at home. The chaos is half the fun, and the savings justify the dig.
With persistence, you will leave with brag‑worthy scores and stories.
Habitat for Humanity ReStore – Avon
DIYers and upcyclers should plan extra time at the Avon ReStore. It is a sprawling warehouse filled with building materials, furniture, appliances, and lighting, all priced to move.
You can outfit a rental, refresh a kitchen, or gather supplies for a flip without wrecking your budget.
Expect pallets of tile, doors stacked in rows, and a surprising selection of cabinets. Sinks, faucets, and vanity mirrors rotate in regularly.
Furniture is the sleeper hit: sturdy dressers, dining sets, and occasional mid‑century silhouettes that polish up beautifully.
Because inventory comes from donors and partner retailers, every visit feels different. Bring measurements, paint swatches, and photos of your space to make quick decisions.
Staff and volunteers are friendly, and they will help you locate hardware, hinges, or the right width of trim.
Load‑out is straightforward, and you can usually find dollies on site. Check lighting for compatible sockets and keep a screwdriver in your car for quick disassembly.
Shopping here supports affordable housing, which makes every project feel more meaningful. If your weekend plans include sawdust and savings, this ReStore makes the drive well worth it.
Sell It Here – Lafayette
Sell It Here feels like a small city of booths, and wandering it is half the joy. You will find vendor stalls curated to different tastes, from farmhouse decor to pop‑culture collectibles.
Prices range from bargain bin to display‑worthy, so plan to compare and negotiate when appropriate.
Clothing racks mix modern basics with retro jackets and specialty pieces. Furniture appears in waves: sideboards, coffee tables, and tall bookcases you will wish you measured for.
Keep an eye on the glass cases for better jewelry, cameras, and small electronics.
Because the vendor mix is large, selection stays fresh. Take photos of booth numbers for easy returns, and make a second pass after a break because highlights hide in plain sight.
It is a great place to hunt for gifts, props, and room anchors without paying boutique premiums.
Bring cash for quick deals, though most registers handle cards. Comfortable shoes and a tote bag make the hours fly by.
If you are building a vintage‑leaning look at home, you will appreciate the variety and scale. Expect to leave with at least one conversation piece and plans to come back.
Millie’s Thrift Store – Lafayette
Millie’s Thrift Store is the kind of neighborhood spot you wish was on your corner. It is tidy, friendly, and stacked with practical finds for daily life.
Expect gently used clothing, kitchen staples, toys, and small furniture at prices that let you experiment with style.
Shoppers love the clear organization and frequent turnover, so sizes are easy to browse and seasonal sections pop. If you are furnishing a first apartment or updating a nursery, the mix of shelves, lamps, and picture frames makes quick work of a to‑do list.
Check linens for quilts and fun patterns.
Because the space is compact, the team edits well and keeps the floor refreshed. You will see a few vintage surprises alongside current brands, especially in handbags and jackets.
Housewares run from stainless pans to ceramic bakeware, ideal for building a kitchen on a budget.
Bring a list, but allow time to wander. Try bundled deals when you are grabbing multiple pieces, and ask about any upcoming sale tags.
It is an easy stop on a Lafayette thrifting loop, and the warm atmosphere makes browsing relaxing. You will likely find something useful every visit.
Beyond the Thrift – Greenwood
Beyond the Thrift feels curated without being fussy, which makes browsing energizing. Racks hold current brands, true vintage, and seasonal capsules so outfits come together fast.
Accessories are a highlight, with belts, bags, and jewelry grouped by color for easy styling.
Expect fair pricing with standout deals during rotation sales. Denim and outerwear shine, and you will often spot dresses perfect for events or work.
The store layout encourages trying things on, and mirrors are flattering, which helps decisions stick.
Staff are engaged and happy to suggest pieces that match what you are holding. If you bring a photo of an inspiration look, they will help recreate it from the floor.
Shoes move quickly, so start there, then sweep tops, blazers, and handbags.
Parking is simple, and the shop is a pleasant detour from the highway. For a wardrobe refresh without department‑store prices, this is a smart destination.
You will leave with outfits that fit your life and budget, plus a few playful extras. It is worth the drive for the polish alone, and the selection changes fast enough to justify repeat trips.
Thrifty Threads – Indianapolis
Thrifty Threads is designed for efficient treasure hunting. Racks are clearly labeled, aisles are wide, and departments flow logically from clothing to home goods.
If you prefer a less chaotic experience, the tidy layout makes it easy to see everything.
Selection skews practical with standout gems: blazers, athletic wear, quality denim, and occasional vintage outerwear. Home aisles yield baskets, frames, lamps, and storage that make apartments feel finished.
Pricing is reasonable, and red‑tag days are worth timing.
You will appreciate the mission‑driven vibe and friendly staff who truly know sizes and sections. Ask about back‑stock or upcoming rollouts when you have a specific need.
Shoes and handbags are organized enough to compare quickly, which saves time and second guessing.
Bring measurements for furniture accents and an idea of your wardrobe gaps. Try on more than you think because unexpected brands fit well here.
The store is an easy anchor for an Indy thrifting route, and you will likely find both basics and one statement piece. It is the dependable stop you recommend to friends when they ask where to start.
Uptown Cheapskate NE Indianapolis – Keystone area
If you want trend‑forward secondhand, Uptown Cheapskate near Keystone hits the sweet spot. It is resale, not donation‑based thrift, so you get curated racks with current labels and gently used condition.
Prices beat retail by a mile while staying higher than dig‑style shops for the curation.
Expect strong denim, sneakers, athleisure, and event‑ready dresses. The accessories wall is fun, with crossbodies, statement earrings, and belts that finish an outfit fast.
Weekends get busy, so try weekday evenings for roomy fitting rooms and calmer browsing.
Because they buy daily, turnover is fast. Bring anything you are trading in, then roll that credit straight into upgrades.
Staff styling help is genuine and low pressure, and they will suggest alternates if your size is out.
Check clearance for last‑chance steals, and scan the sneaker wall early. If you are building a capsule wardrobe, you can grab quality basics and one or two trend pieces without overspending.
It is an ideal stop when you want something specific for a trip, interview, or night out. You will probably leave with a complete look.
Resell Indy – East Washington St
Resell Indy brings a warehouse vibe with consistently low prices and lots of choice. You will find racks of clothing, footwear, and accessories, plus aisles that shift with seasonal overstock.
The energy is brisk and fun, especially during weekend markdowns.
Expect brand‑name basics, graphic tees, and outerwear alongside home items like rugs, organizers, and small appliances. Deals come in waves, so walk the perimeter first to spot display highlights.
If you shop for family, the range of sizes makes it easy to cover everyone.
Because it operates discount style, inventory can feel like a treasure map. Staff move merchandise frequently, so ask what just came out.
Check carts near fitting rooms for returns and surprise scores, and always inspect zippers and seams.
Bring a list, but stay flexible so you can pounce on unexpected bargains. Budget time to dig and compare duplicates for best condition.
It is the kind of place where a cart fills fast and the total still shocks you in a good way. If you love plentiful options at friendly prices, this stop earns a permanent spot on your route.
Audrey’s Place Thrift Store – Indianapolis
Audrey’s Place is a destination for furniture hunters who also want solid thrift clothing and decor. The floor is big, and the variety keeps you browsing from sofas to side tables to framed art.
If your home needs personality fast, this is a productive first stop.
Expect sturdy dressers, dining sets, and accent chairs, with upholstery changing often. Lamps and art aisles deliver quick wins for renters looking to elevate without drilling.
Clothing racks are organized enough to pull complete outfits, with coats and denim as standouts.
The staff understands measurements, delivery options, and how pieces can be disassembled to fit in a compact car. Bring a tape measure, room photos, and fabric swatches to speed decisions.
Prices are fair for the scale and condition, and sale tags help stretch budgets.
Load‑in and parking are straightforward, which makes big buys less stressful. Plan a slow lap, then circle back for contenders.
You will likely leave with a signature piece and a few clever accessories. For anyone building a stylish home on a realistic budget, Audrey’s Place is worth the detour and the trunk space.
Hearts In Motion Resale Shoppe – Schererville
Hearts In Motion Resale Shoppe feels community‑driven and thoughtfully organized. You will find clothing for all ages, housewares, seasonal decor, and a reliable kids section that makes family budgeting easier.
Displays are cute without hiding price tags, which helps you shop quickly.
Selection rotates frequently, and condition is consistently good. Look for quality coats, handbags, and occasional vintage dresses that photograph beautifully.
The home aisle carries baskets, vases, and frames that pull together entryways and shelves for very little.
Staff are kind and mission‑focused, which keeps the experience warm and low pressure. Ask about special sale days or color tags to plan your visit strategically.
If you are outfitting a new place, you can snag linens, lamps, and kitchen basics in one run.
Because it serves Northwest Indiana, it is a smart stop if you split time between Chicago and the Hoosier State. Bring a reusable tote, and check the front counter for small jewelry finds.
You will walk out with practical upgrades and a couple of joyful extras, knowing your purchase supports programs doing good.
Jasper Junction Thrift Store and Flea Market – Rensselaer
Jasper Junction is a sprawling hybrid that rewards patience and curiosity. You will wander through vendor booths and thrift sections housing furniture, decor, records, and quirky collectibles.
It is the spot to uncover a statement piece that sparks conversation at home.
Expect vintage chairs needing a simple reupholster, farmhouse tables, and oddball art that photographs beautifully. Records and books rotate often, so bring a list of artists and titles.
Seasonal decor shows up early and moves quickly, so grab what you love.
Because the footprint is big, take notes or photos of booth numbers and prices to compare during a second lap. Friendly staff and vendors will work with you on questions and occasional deals.
Bring measurements, plus a blanket for hauling furniture safely.
Weekends can get lively, but weekday afternoons feel relaxed and roomy. Wear comfortable shoes and budget more time than you think.
If you thrive on variety and want both thrift and market energy, this destination delivers. You will leave with a trunk full of character and plans to tweak a room around your new find.