Tucked along West Broad Street, The Original Josie’s Pizza keeps things simple and shockingly satisfying. Regulars whisper about a humble cheese sandwich that somehow steals the show at a classic pie shop.
If you appreciate crisp edges, gooey centers, and prices that respect your wallet, this place belongs on your shortlist. Come hungry, because small choices on this menu carry big flavor.
The No-Frills Cheese Sandwich
Golden edges crackle as you pick it up, and the cheese pulls like a promise kept. The bread gets a light butter brush and a hot-plate kiss, landing that crisp bite without tasting greasy.
Order it when the place opens at 4 PM for the freshest sizzle. Pair it with a side of marinara for dipping and a fountain cola, then thank yourself later.
Thin-Crust Pepperoni By The Slice
That first snap from the thin crust sets the tone, all crisp and lightly blistered. Pepperoni curls into little cups that hold savory oil, giving each bite a salty kick.
Ask for a reheat to get the underside extra firm without drying the cheese. A sprinkle of red pepper flakes brings heat that balances the buttery edge perfectly.
House Marinara For Dipping
Tomato brightness leads, with garlic riding close behind and a hint of sweetness. It is not fancy, just balanced and clean, exactly what you want for dunking.
Use it with the cheese sandwich or leftover crusts to stretch your meal. If you like a kick, stir in crushed red pepper to make a quick personal sauce.
Timing Your Visit
Doors open at 4 PM, and evenings are the sweet spot for hot griddles and fast turns. Thursdays through Saturdays run until 11 PM, while Sunday and Monday closures can surprise new visitors.
Call ahead at (614) 224-9637 if you are timing a quick pickup. Arriving early means snagging a booth and beating the post-work rush.
Budget-Friendly Order Strategy
Keep it under twenty by pairing the cheese sandwich with a slice and a marinara cup. You get crunch, melt, and a dip for balance without overspending.
Split the sandwich if you plan on dessert elsewhere, or keep it solo for a filling snack. The value shines because nothing on the plate feels like filler.
Neighborhood Feel On West Broad
There is no pretense inside, just the hum of a neighborhood spot that knows its lane. Locals chat with staff by name while orders hit the counter steady and fast.
That laid-back rhythm makes solo visits comfortable and group hangs easy. You come for pizza, stay for the cheese sandwich, and leave already planning the next round.