Pie is the secret reason people keep driving across town. Walk into an Indiana buffet and the first thing that hits you is the warm sugar and butter scent. Steam rises from lattice crusts and counters sag under whole pies waiting to be sliced. You’ll see plates piled with roast and sides, but eyes always drift to the dessert case. These buffets make pies the old-fashioned way—hands-on filling, flaky dough, and no shortcuts. Some kitchens bake fruit pies by the dozen; others keep a steady churn of cream pies and cobblers. Regulars trade slices like stories at the counter. Use this guide to plan a weekend route. Bring a cooler for a pie to-go, and leave room for one more slice.
Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery — Shipshewana
Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery is a beloved destination for pie lovers in Shipshewana. Visitors are greeted with the scent of freshly baked pies that are as heartwarming as the Amish hospitality. The restaurant offers a variety of flavors, from classic apple to the unique rhubarb.
The cozy setting inside makes every bite feel like a hug from grandma. Families enjoy gathering here, sharing stories over a slice. The pies are not just a dessert; they are a tradition passed down through generations.
Did you know? The bakery churns out over 25,000 pies annually, drawing pie enthusiasts from far and wide.
Das Dutchman Essenhaus — Middlebury
In Middlebury, Das Dutchman Essenhaus stands as a symbol of comfort and delight. Known for their expansive buffet, the pies steal the show with each bite offering a taste of home. The rich, flaky crust and perfectly blended fillings are a testament to their culinary expertise.
The bustling atmosphere inside echoes with laughter and clinking silverware, adding to the warm experience. This is a place where memories are made, and pies are shared with love.
Fun fact: The Essenhaus has the largest number of dining rooms in Indiana, offering a pie for every palate.
Back 40 Junction — Decatur
Back 40 Junction in Decatur is not just a buffet; it’s a nostalgic journey. With its unique décor, the restaurant is a feast for the eyes and the taste buds. Their pies, made with love and tradition, are a staple among locals.
Each slice tells a story, with flavors that range from classic chocolate to the tangy lemon meringue. The inviting aroma wraps around you like a warm blanket.
Known for its quirky memorabilia, Back 40 Junction offers an experience as unforgettable as their pies. Every visit promises a sweet ending.
Stoll’s Lakeview Restaurant — Loogootee
Perched by the serene waters in Loogootee, Stoll’s Lakeview Restaurant offers more than just a meal. Their legendary pies are crafted with ingredients that echo the whispers of the past. Each bite is a harmonious blend of texture and flavor.
The lake view adds a touch of tranquility, making every dining experience memorable. Locals come here to enjoy not just the pies but the serenity that envelops the area.
A slice of pie here is a slice of paradise, making it a beloved local treasure.
Gasthof Amish Village — Montgomery
Tucked away in Montgomery, Gasthof Amish Village provides a genuine taste of Amish culture. Pies at Gasthof are made-from-scratch, capturing the essence of simplicity and authenticity. Flavors like cherry and custard delight the senses.
The village ambiance offers a glimpse into a slower-paced life, where tradition thrives. Dining here feels like stepping back in time, where every meal is crafted with care.
Gasthof’s reputation for pies is well-deserved, with locals and visitors alike savoring every crumb.
Knepp’s Restaurant & Gift Shop — Washington
Knepp’s Restaurant & Gift Shop in Washington welcomes you with open arms and irresistible pies. The warm, inviting setting is perfect for indulging in a slice of their famed pecan or banana cream pie.
With a rustic charm and friendly staff, the restaurant feels like a second home. Many locals frequent Knepp’s not just for the food, but for the welcoming atmosphere.
Beyond the dining experience, the gift shop offers unique finds, making every visit memorable.
Stone’s Family Restaurant — Millhousen
Nestled in the charming town of Millhousen, Stone’s Family Restaurant offers a slice of home with every pie. This beloved local spot is famed for its convivial ambiance and homemade pies that taste just like grandma’s.
Each pie is crafted with love, from the flaky crust to the succulent fillings, using recipes passed down through generations. Regulars rave about the seasonal fruit pies, especially the apple and cherry variations.
Even if you’re just passing through, Stone’s promises a warm welcome and a sweet escape from the ordinary. A visit here is like returning to a cherished family tradition.