Columbus is a city where pasta, pizza, and passion come together on one plate. Step into any of these Italian spots, and you’ll find generous portions, bold flavors, and recipes that feel like they came straight from Nonna’s kitchen. Forget tiny bites and sky-high bills—these restaurants serve hearty dishes that satisfy your cravings without emptying your wallet. From wood-fired pizzas with bubbling cheese to handmade pastas tossed in rich, savory sauces, each plate tells a story. Neighborhood favorites mix casual charm with memorable flavors, while cozy trattorias offer an escape into the heart of Italy right in Columbus.
Whether you’re a local hunting for comfort food or a traveler chasing authentic bites, these eight Italian restaurants prove that indulgence doesn’t have to come with a hefty price tag. Grab a fork, a friend, and get ready for a flavorful adventure.
Marcella’s — Short North
Nestled in the Short North, Marcella’s captures the heart with its housemade pastas and wood-fired pizzas. The lively atmosphere complements the generous portions, making it a favorite for group outings. Diners can enjoy seasonal specials and a well-priced happy hour.
The bustling dining room adds to the charm, ensuring a vibrant experience without upscale markups. Sharing family-style dishes is a must to maximize variety and savings. Reservations are a smart choice, especially during busy evenings.
Forno Kitchen + Bar — Short North
Forno Kitchen + Bar is a Short North hotspot known for its stone-fired pizzas and approachable pastas. Perfect for budget-conscious diners, it offers fast, casual service with chef-driven ingredients. Enjoy brunch, weekday happy hours, and late-night pizza specials. Ideal for sharing, bring friends and experience seasonal menu touches without the fine-dining price.
Located at 721 N High St, reservations are recommended on busy nights. Embrace the fun atmosphere and tasty bites.
Basi Italia — Victorian Village
In the heart of Victorian Village, Basi Italia offers a cozy retreat with its seasonal produce and handmade pastas. The menu’s simplicity keeps costs reasonable, spotlighting fresh ingredients. A sunny patio and wine-by-the-glass options make it perfect for casual dates or weeknight dinners.
Neighborhood charm blends with sensible pricing, delivering thoughtful flavors. Located in Victorian Village, Columbus, reservations are wise on busy nights. Enjoy the easygoing service style.
Trattoria Roma — Grandview Heights
Trattoria Roma, in Grandview Heights, combines family warmth with refined Italian cooking. Classics like lasagna and veal come as generous plates, perfect for sharing. The intimate dining room offers an attentive service, making regular dining feel special.
Chef specials and sensible wine options add variety without hefty costs. Visit them at 1447 Grandview Ave, Columbus. Reservations are recommended to enjoy this welcoming environment.
Villa Nova Ristorante — North High Street
Villa Nova Ristorante is a Columbus favorite on North High Street, known for hearty, traditional Italian-American dishes. Baked pastas, veal parm, and fried appetizers offer comfort without high prices. Daily and early-bird specials make it easy to enjoy large portions.
Expect a family-run atmosphere with classic comfort foods. Perfect for families or sharing entrees. Visit 5545 North High St, Columbus, for a taste of nostalgia. Reservations suggested.
Lola & Giuseppe’s Trattoria
Lola & Giuseppe’s operates as a bakery and trattoria, offering handmade pastas and simple plates. The compact menu highlights classics like cacio e pepe and meatballs, with a bakery counter offering fresh breads to take home.
Cozy space and nightly specials provide authentic flavors economically. Portion sizes suit sharing, ideal for budget-conscious groups. Located at 100 Granville St, Columbus, reservations recommended on busy nights. Experience the neighborhood warmth.
Pelino’s Pasta — University District
Located in the University District, Pelino’s Pasta focuses on chef-driven, seasonal pasta dishes. The menu changes monthly, showcasing regional Italian techniques and fresh local produce. Portions and pricing are reasonable for students and locals.
Splitting plates with a starter provides variety without a high bill. The intimate dining room rewards repeat visits with bold flavors. Visit 245 King Ave, Columbus, for a taste of this culinary gem. Reservations are recommended.
Milano’s Italian Restaurant — East Columbus / Reynoldsburg
Milano’s in East Columbus/Reynoldsburg is a no-frills spot where classic comfort dishes shine. Spaghetti and meatballs, chicken parm, and lasagna come in generous portions. Daily specials and combo options keep costs manageable for families.
The focus on homestyle recipes keeps prices low while delivering dependable flavors. Located at 6916 E Broad St, Columbus, it’s perfect for takeout or dine-in. Reservations are recommended for a hassle-free experience. Experience comforting flavors without the fuss.