Across Pennsylvania, shepherd’s pie quietly shows up on menus at a handful of restaurants that take comfort food seriously. These lesser-known spots focus on rich gravies, well-seasoned meat, and mashed potatoes that feel intentionally made, not like an afterthought.
They’re the kinds of places locals return to when they want something familiar done right. Here are 11 Pennsylvania restaurants where shepherd’s pie is consistently worth ordering.
McGillan’s Olde Ale House, Philadelphia
Stepping into McGillan’s Olde Ale House feels like a journey back in time. Philadelphia’s oldest pub, founded in 1860, offers a shepherd’s pie that stands out with its rich, hearty flavors. The dish is carefully crafted with ground lamb and topped with a perfectly crisp layer of mashed potatoes.
The atmosphere here is lively, filled with stories from the past echoing through its walls. Patrons can enjoy live music alongside their meals, amplifying the authentic experience. It’s not just the pie that draws crowds, but the welcoming ambiance that makes everyone feel at home.
Regulars swear by the consistency in quality and flavor. McGillan’s manages to keep it simple yet delightful, making each visit memorable.
The Dubliner Irish Pub, New Hope
Nestled in the charming town of New Hope, The Dubliner Irish Pub exudes warmth and friendliness. Their shepherd’s pie is a must-try, featuring tender lamb and a hint of herbs that elevate its taste. The pie’s rustic presentation adds to its charm.
Guests often remark on the pub’s inviting atmosphere, with its cozy nooks and corners perfect for intimate conversations. The staff’s friendly demeanor makes every visit enjoyable, ensuring that diners feel part of the local community.
The Dubliner offers more than just great food; it provides an experience that resonates with patrons, creating lasting memories with every savory bite of their signature pie.
Molly Maguire’s Irish Pub, Phoenixville
Molly Maguire’s Irish Pub in Phoenixville is where tradition meets taste. Known for its vibrant community feel, the pub’s shepherd’s pie is a blend of tradition and innovation, featuring locally sourced ingredients that make it fresh and delightful.
The pub’s decor reflects Ireland’s charm, with wooden furnishings and Irish memorabilia adorning the walls. It’s the kind of place where laughter is contagious, and friendships are formed over hearty meals.
Their pie is a customer favorite, praised for its authentic taste and generous portions. Molly Maguire’s keeps patrons returning, not just for the food but for the stories shared amid the cozy ambiance.
McGrady’s Pub, Harrisburg
In Harrisburg, McGrady’s Pub offers a shepherd’s pie that’s a local favorite. The pub’s welcoming vibe is matched by a dish that combines savory lamb with a perfectly seasoned potato crust, creating a comforting meal.
The pub is a gathering spot for both locals and visitors, with friendly faces and engaging conversations all around. McGrady’s ambiance is casual, making it an ideal spot for relaxed dining.
Their commitment to quality is evident in every bite, with flavors that remind diners of home-cooked meals. Patrons often leave satisfied and eager to return for more of what McGrady’s has to offer.
Kildare’s Irish Pub, West Chester
Kildare’s Irish Pub in West Chester is a place where culinary expertise meets Irish traditions. Known for its shepherd’s pie, the pub offers a dish that’s both comforting and satisfying, featuring tender meat and a creamy potato topping.
The atmosphere is lively, with an energetic crowd that enjoys the pub’s various offerings. Kildare’s creates a sense of community among its patrons, making everyone feel at home.
Their pie is well-loved for its hearty flavors and perfect seasoning. The combination of good food and a fun environment ensures that every visit is a memorable one.
The Gables Restaurant & Pub, Chadds Ford
Tucked away in Chadds Ford, The Gables Restaurant & Pub offers a unique take on shepherd’s pie. This version uses fresh ingredients and innovative techniques to deliver a dish that’s both classic and inventive.
The ambiance is charming, with rustic decor that complements the restaurant’s culinary offerings. Guests appreciate the warm hospitality and relaxing atmosphere that The Gables provides.
Their pie is praised for its balanced flavors and satisfying portions. The Gables has managed to create a dining experience that leaves a lasting impression on all who visit.
Fadó Irish Pub, Philadelphia
Fadó Irish Pub in Philadelphia brings a taste of Ireland to the City of Brotherly Love. The shepherd’s pie is a standout, offering a rich and flavorful experience with its perfectly seasoned lamb and fluffy potatoes.
The pub’s lively atmosphere is enhanced by traditional Irish music and decor. It’s a place where the community gathers to enjoy good food and great company.
Patrons often rave about the authenticity and quality of the pie, making it a dish they return for time and again. Fadó is more than just a pub; it’s a slice of Ireland in the heart of Philly.
The Quiet Man Pub, Philadelphia
The Quiet Man Pub in Philadelphia is a haven for those seeking traditional Irish fare. Known for its shepherd’s pie, this pub serves a dish that’s both hearty and flavorful, with a savory filling topped with golden, creamy potatoes.
The pub’s cozy interior is reminiscent of an Irish countryside inn, providing a warm and inviting atmosphere. It’s a place where patrons come to unwind and enjoy good company.
Regulars love the welcoming environment and the quality of the food, making each visit feel like a celebration of Irish culture and cuisine.
PJ Whelihan’s Pub, Exton
PJ Whelihan’s Pub in Exton is where great food meets a lively atmosphere. The shepherd’s pie is a crowd-pleaser, featuring a savory lamb filling enveloped in fluffy mashed potatoes.
Known for its friendly service and vibrant atmosphere, the pub attracts a diverse crowd. It’s the perfect place for social gatherings, where laughter and conversation flow freely.
The pie is praised for its comforting flavors and generous portions. PJ Whelihan’s is a spot where quality food and a fun environment come together seamlessly.
The Irish Horne, Richboro
In Richboro, The Irish Horne offers a shepherd’s pie that’s a true delight. The dish is crafted with care, featuring a savory blend of lamb and potatoes that’s both comforting and delicious.
The pub’s ambiance is welcoming, with a cozy interior that invites relaxation. It’s a place where patrons can unwind and enjoy the simple pleasures of good food and company.
Regulars appreciate the consistent quality and taste of the pie, making it a favorite among locals. The Irish Horne is a testament to the charm of traditional Irish hospitality.
McCarthy’s Red Stag Pub, Bethlehem
McCarthy’s Red Stag Pub in Bethlehem offers a taste of Ireland with its exceptional shepherd’s pie. The dish is a harmonious blend of flavors, featuring tender lamb and fluffy potatoes.
The pub’s interior is warm and inviting, with Irish music adding to the lively atmosphere. It’s a place where patrons feel at ease, enjoying the authentic taste of Ireland.
The pie is renowned for its rich taste and perfect seasoning, making it a standout choice. McCarthy’s provides more than just a meal; it’s an experience that celebrates Irish culture.