Maine’s whoopie pies are more than just desserts; they are a testament to tradition and innovation.
Across the state, bakeries compete to create the most delicious, unique, and memorable whoopie pies, contributing to an enduring rivalry.
Each bakery brings its own twist, story, and flavor to this beloved Maine treat.
Labadie’s Bakery (Lewiston)
Labadie’s Bakery proudly claims to be where Maine’s first whoopie pie was sold. Since 1925, this Lewiston staple has been serving the community with its classic chocolate rounds filled with vanilla cream.
The recipe has largely remained unchanged, preserving the nostalgic taste that has captured the hearts of many for decades. Wholesale production and distribution to supermarkets ensure that their beloved whoopie pies reach a broader audience.
Locals cherish Labadie’s for not just the taste, but the tangible connection to heritage and tradition it represents. This small-town bakery is a cornerstone of Maine’s whoopie pie history.
Wicked Whoopies (Gardiner / Freeport)
Starting from a home kitchen, Wicked Whoopies has grown into a whoopie pie powerhouse, producing thousands daily. With a flagship store in Freeport, this bakery offers a plethora of flavors, pushing the boundaries of creativity.
Their role in the rivalry is significant, setting records with innovative variants that highlight Maine’s fame for this sweet treat. Wicked Whoopies not only delights locals but attracts visitors from far and wide.
Their strong brand presence symbolizes modern innovation, making them a key player in the ongoing whoopie pie competition.
The Pastry Corner (Houlton)
The Pastry Corner has become a known name in festival competitions, being a repeat finalist in both traditional and flavored categories.
This Houlton-based bakery has a reputation for producing crowd-pleasing whoopie pies that keep locals returning for more. The attention to detail and commitment to quality make The Pastry Corner a beloved community fixture.
Their participation in local competitions showcases their dedication to upholding and enhancing the tradition of whoopie pie making. The bakery embodies the spirit of small-town pride.
Katherine’s Bakery & Café (Norway, ME)
Tucked in the lakeside town of Norway, Katherine’s Bakery & Café has quietly become a festival favorite.
Known for their creative spin on Maine’s beloved treat, they’ve taken home honors like Best Flavored Whoopie Pie and Most Creative Name at the Maine Whoopie Pie Festival. Their Apple Pie whoopie — complete with spiced cake and cinnamon cream filling — is a standout, blending comfort-food roots with inventive flair.
Katherine’s shows how small-town bakeries are pushing the rivalry forward one delicious twist at a time.
Sheila’s Maine Treats (Clifton, ME)
This small-town bakery made a big splash when its Raspberry Biz whoopie pie went viral on TikTok, turning Sheila’s Maine Treats into a must-visit destination almost overnight.
Known for playful flavors like peanut butter & jelly and raspberry cream, Sheila Bryant’s creations combine nostalgic charm with bold, modern twists.
Her rapid rise proves that in Maine’s whoopie pie rivalry, even newcomers with fresh ideas can earn a loyal following — and maybe even steal the spotlight.
Bangin’ Whoopie (Bangor)
Bangin’ Whoopie is renowned for its creative and unusual flavor combinations, marking its place in the festival scene.
Located in Bangor, this bakery thrives on innovation, crafting whoopie pies that surprise and delight. The bold flavors and unique concepts set them apart, making each visit an adventure for the taste buds.
Their presence in the festival circuit highlights their dedication to pushing the boundaries of traditional whoopie pie flavors. Bangin’ Whoopie continues to enchant both locals and visitors with its imaginative offerings.
Elaine’s Basket Café & Bakery (Milo)
Elaine’s Basket Café & Bakery in Milo is celebrated for its award-winning creative names and flavors. This small-town bakery focuses on quality and character, offering whoopie pies that are as delightful to hear about as they are to taste.
Each pie tells a story, captivating customers with its charm and taste. Elaine’s not only competes in flavor but in presentation, making every whoopie pie an experience.
Their dedication to creativity and quality ensures they leave a lasting impression in the whoopie pie scene.
Governor’s Restaurant & Bakery (Old Town, Maine, plus multiple locations)
Governor’s Restaurant & Bakery, affectionately known as “The Gov,” is a longstanding comfort-food chain with multiple locations in Maine.
Their whoopie pies are a staple, enjoyed alongside hearty meals. This bakery’s dedication to classic flavors ensures a satisfying experience for traditional whoopie pie lovers. With a reputation for quality and consistency, Governor’s maintains a beloved presence in the community.
Their role in the whoopie pie rivalry is as a keeper of tradition, offering consistency and comfort to every customer who walks through their doors.
Honey & Lace Baking Co. (Sedgwick, Maine)
Honey & Lace Baking Co., based in Sedgwick, Maine, may be smaller but it shines in the whoopie pie festival scene. This bakery-vendor’s presence at the Maine Whoopie Pie Festival highlights its commitment to excellence and innovation.
Each whoopie pie is crafted with care, showcasing flavors that delight and surprise. Despite its size, Honey & Lace stands tall in the rivalry, proving that dedication and creativity can leave a significant mark.
Their rustic charm and quality compositions make them a beloved choice for whoopie pie enthusiasts.