Portland, Maine, isn’t just a coastal city—it’s a secret food lover’s paradise. Beyond the bustling waterfront and tourist spots, hidden neighborhood restaurants are quietly serving dishes that locals swoon over. These are the spots where recipes are perfected over decades, and every bite tells a story.
These 9 neighborhood gems are the kind of places visitors stumble upon and fall in love with. Skip the crowds, follow your appetite, and get ready to taste Portland the way locals do—one unforgettable meal at a time.
The Thirsty Pig
Tucked into the heart of the Old Port, The Thirsty Pig is Portland’s go-to for craft beer enthusiasts and sausage lovers. Known for their house-made sausages, each bite is a savory delight.
The “Pig in a Blanket,” featuring a sausage wrapped in a soft pretzel, is a unique must-try. With communal seating and a laid-back ambiance, it’s the perfect spot to relax with locals.
Open daily, its vibrant atmosphere invites guests to stay a while, enjoying both the food and the hearty conversation that often fills the space.
Blyth & Burrows
Hidden away on Exchange Street, Blyth & Burrows offers an intriguing speakeasy experience. With dim lighting and sophisticated decor, it provides a perfect backdrop for enjoying expertly crafted cocktails.
Their “B&B Old Fashioned” is a standout, blending tradition with innovation. Patrons often find themselves lost in conversation over small plates that are as artful as they are delicious.
Open from Tuesday to Saturday, this clandestine spot is ideal for those seeking a cozy retreat from the bustling city streets.
Papi
Papi is a burst of Latin flavor located in Portland’s East End. Known for its “Peruvian Chicken” and “Cuban Sandwich,” it offers bold tastes that capture the spirit of Latin cuisine.
The restaurant’s vibrant decor and friendly staff create an inviting atmosphere that keeps patrons coming back. Its lively ambiance makes it a staple for anyone seeking a taste of Latin America.
Open daily, Papi is a joyful celebration of culture and community through food.
J’s Oyster Bar
J’s Oyster Bar is a beloved fixture on Portland’s waterfront, known for its fresh oysters and no-frills charm. The seafood chowder and lobster rolls are local mainstays.
With views overlooking the harbor, diners enjoy their meals accompanied by the gentle lapping of waves. Its casual vibe makes it a favorite among those who appreciate unfussy, quality seafood.
Open daily, J’s Oyster Bar captures the essence of Portland’s maritime heritage.
Terlingua
Terlingua brings a fusion of Tex-Mex and BBQ to Portland, celebrated for its “Brisket Tacos” and “Smoked Ribs.” The vibrant decor and festive atmosphere make it a lively gathering spot.
Patrons are greeted with the tantalizing aroma of smoked meats, creating an irresistible draw. It’s a place where friends and family come together over shared plates and laughter.
Open from Tuesday to Sunday, Terlingua promises a flavorful journey into the heart of Tex-Mex cuisine.
Isa Bistro
Isa Bistro offers a cozy retreat with a menu inspired by French and Mediterranean flavors. Dishes like “Duck Confit” and “Moules Frites” highlight the chef’s culinary artistry.
The intimate setting is perfect for romantic dinners or quiet celebrations. With a focus on quality and presentation, each dish is crafted to delight the senses.
Open from Wednesday to Monday, Isa Bistro is a testament to the elegance of simple, well-executed cuisine.
Dimo’s Apizza
Dimo’s Apizza delivers the taste of New Haven-style pizza to Portland. Known for unique creations like “White Clam” and “Tie-Dye,” each pie is a flavorful adventure.
The twice-baked crust provides the perfect balance of chewiness and crispness. It’s a favorite among pizza enthusiasts who appreciate creativity and tradition in equal measures.
Open from Tuesday to Sunday, Dimo’s is where pizza dreams become reality.
The Knotted Apron
The Knotted Apron specializes in seasonal dishes crafted from locally sourced ingredients. Their “Pappardelle with Wild Mushrooms” showcases the restaurant’s dedication to fresh, vibrant flavors.
With a warm, intimate setting, it’s the perfect place for a serene meal. The emphasis on quality and local produce resonates with Portland’s eco-conscious diners.
Open from Thursday to Sunday, The Knotted Apron is a hidden gem for those seeking an authentic farm-to-table experience.
Cantina Calafia
Cantina Calafia brings a taste of Mexico to Portland with dishes like “Tacos al Pastor” and “Chiles Rellenos.” The vibrant decor sets the stage for a culinary fiesta.
Each dish is crafted with authenticity, honoring traditional Mexican flavors. It’s a lively spot where the spirit of Mexico comes alive through food and atmosphere.
Open from Tuesday to Sunday, Cantina Calafia is a feast for the senses.