The Fluffernutter sandwich, a classic New England treat of marshmallow fluff and peanut butter, gets a gourmet twist at a handful of creative local shops. From toasted perfection to inventive flavor combos, these spots take a nostalgic snack and turn it into a dessert-worthy experience.
For anyone with a sweet tooth or a love for quirky regional foods, these New England shops show that simple ingredients can create extraordinary flavor. Here are 7 places where the Fluffernutter is elevated to an art form.
Union Square Donuts – Somerville, Massachusetts
Union Square Donuts in Somerville is not just about donuts; it’s a haven for unique culinary creations. Here, fluffernutter sandwiches are reimagined as delightful donut hybrids. The shop’s inventive approach sees marshmallow fluff and peanut butter sandwiched between their signature, airy donuts.
Each bite offers a whimsical twist on tradition, making it a fan favorite. The cozy and welcoming atmosphere adds to the enjoyable experience, perfect for a casual meet-up with friends. A visit here promises more than just a sandwich; it’s a journey into creative comfort food.
Flour Bakery + Cafe – Boston, Massachusetts
Boston’s Flour Bakery + Cafe takes the fluffernutter sandwich to gourmet levels. Known for their artisanal breads and pastries, the cafe offers a version that highlights quality ingredients. The marshmallow and peanut butter are perfectly balanced, nestled in freshly baked bread that adds a satisfying crunch.
This spot is ideal for those seeking a refined take on a childhood favorite. The buzzing atmosphere of the cafe reflects the vibrant city life, making it a perfect pitstop for both locals and tourists looking to enjoy a touch of nostalgia with sophistication.
Mike’s Pastry – Boston, Massachusetts
Mike’s Pastry is a Boston icon, renowned for its decadent desserts. Their take on the fluffernutter sandwich is a testament to their creativity. By incorporating creamy marshmallow and rich peanut butter into their pastries, they offer a delightful twist for the adventurous foodie.
The bustling environment of this North End staple is part of the charm, drawing both locals and tourists. Each visit is an opportunity to experience a beloved classic reimagined with flair. This is not just a stop for sweets but a destination for culinary innovation.
Toscanini’s – Cambridge, Massachusetts
Toscanini’s in Cambridge is renowned for its inventive ice cream flavors, including a playful nod to the fluffernutter sandwich. This ice cream shop offers a unique experience for those looking to indulge their sweet tooth with a twist.
The fluffernutter ice cream combines creamy marshmallow with peanut butter swirls, creating a delicious homage to the classic sandwich. This spot is popular among students and locals alike, providing a cool retreat with a touch of whimsy. Toscanini’s is the perfect place to savor a childhood classic in a refreshing new form.