Lobster rolls are a quintessential New England summer treat, but not all spots deliver the freshness and flavor that justify their steep price tags. For those craving the perfect balance of buttery bun and tender lobster meat, finding the right place can make all the difference.
Across New England, some hidden gems and well-loved classics stand out for their quality ingredients, generous portions, and authentic taste. These lobster roll spots combine coastal charm with expert preparation, making every bite worth it.
If you’re planning a foodie trip or just want to indulge in a true taste of the coast, these 8 lobster roll destinations prove that great lobster rolls don’t have to disappoint—even at a premium price.
Eventide Oyster Co.
Eventide Oyster Co. is a culinary gem in Portland, Maine, known for its innovative take on the classic lobster roll. The lobster roll here is served on a soft, steamed bun, diverging from the traditional approach, yet capturing the essence of coastal flavors. The brown butter enriches the lobster, creating a taste sensation that’s both modern and timeless.
Patrons are often drawn to its vibrant atmosphere and creative menu. The combination of fresh lobster and unique ingredients makes it a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts exploring New England.
Red’s Eats
Red’s Eats in Wiscasset, Maine, is legendary among lobster roll aficionados. This roadside stand offers an authentic experience with gargantuan portions of succulent lobster, simply served to highlight its natural flavor.
The no-frills setting adds to its charm, allowing the lobster to take center stage. Locals and tourists alike form long lines for a taste of what many consider the best lobster roll in Maine.
With its rich history and commitment to quality, Red’s Eats is a quintessential stop for anyone exploring the culinary delights of New England.
Luke’s Lobster
Luke’s Lobster is not just a restaurant; it’s a movement toward sustainable seafood. With multiple locations, this popular chain offers a classic lobster roll that emphasizes simplicity and quality. The lobster is fresh and served with a touch of mayo and lemon butter, letting the seafood shine.
Luke’s commitment to sustainability ensures that each lobster is sourced responsibly, making it a favorite among eco-conscious diners. The rustic ambiance adds to the experience, turning a meal into a meaningful connection with the ocean.
Luke’s Lobster is a beloved spot for both locals and travelers.
The Lobster Shack
The Lobster Shack in Cape Neddick, Maine, combines stunning ocean views with delectable lobster rolls. This picturesque spot offers rolls made from local lobster, seasoned to perfection and served with a side of breathtaking scenery.
Visitors can enjoy their meals while gazing at the Atlantic, creating a dining experience that feeds both the body and soul. The tranquil setting and friendly service make it a favorite among tourists and locals alike.
For those seeking a quintessential New England experience, The Lobster Shack delivers in every way.
Pearl Oyster Bar
Pearl Oyster Bar in New York City might seem an odd inclusion, but its lobster roll rivals those found on the New England coast. The roll is packed with juicy lobster, lightly dressed, and served on a buttered bun that complements perfectly.
Despite its urban location, the restaurant captures a coastal vibe, offering a brief escape to the sea. Diners appreciate the authenticity and quality that mirror the best of New England’s offerings.
For city dwellers craving a taste of the coast, Pearl Oyster Bar is a delightful haven.
Bite Into Maine
Bite Into Maine, a food truck in Portland, offers a refreshing twist on lobster rolls with its inventive menu. Known for creative variations, this spot delights diners with options like the curry or wasabi lobster roll.
Each bite bursts with flavor, thanks to the fresh ingredients and imaginative combinations. Parked near scenic spots, it provides an ideal casual dining experience.
Whether you’re a traditionalist or adventurous eater, Bite Into Maine promises something special, making it a must-visit during a trip to Portland.
The Clam Shack
The Clam Shack in Kennebunkport, Maine, is renowned for its classic approach to lobster rolls. The roll is filled with succulent lobster, dressed with a light touch of mayo, and served on a fresh, toasted bun.
Its small-town charm and loyal following make it a cherished spot for both locals and tourists. The simplicity of the flavors speaks to the quality of the ingredients, making each bite a memorable experience.
With its charming location and authentic taste, The Clam Shack embodies the spirit of New England dining.
Maine Diner
Maine Diner in Wells, Maine, offers a hearty lobster roll experience in a classic diner setting. Known for its generous portions and friendly atmosphere, this spot is a favorite among those seeking comfort and quality.
The lobster roll is packed with fresh meat, lightly seasoned, and served with a smile. It’s a taste of Maine’s hospitality and culinary tradition all in one.
With its rich history and welcoming vibe, Maine Diner provides a satisfying meal that resonates with locals and visitors alike.