New York City is renowned for its culinary diversity, and its steakhouses are no exception.
While tourists often flock to the well-advertised restaurants, locals know the hidden gems where the steak is unmatched.
These are the under-the-radar spots where New Yorkers indulge in juicy cuts and old-school charm, far from the bustling crowds.
Each establishment offers a unique slice of the city’s rich dining culture, making them cherished secrets that locals guard closely.
St. Anselm (Brooklyn)
In the heart of Williamsburg, St. Anselm is a steakhouse that shuns the typical white tablecloth for a more rustic, laid-back vibe.
The allure here is the expertly grilled meats, particularly lesser-known cuts that are wood-fired to perfection. Locals adore its straightforward approach to dining—no frills, just superior taste.
The interior’s warm, inviting atmosphere coupled with the aroma of the grill creates a setting that feels like home. It’s a local favorite where the focus is always on the flavor, making each visit a culinary delight.
Uncle Jack’s Steakhouse (Manhattan/Queens)
Uncle Jack’s Steakhouse offers a slice of old New York charm, away from the usual tourist paths. With its vintage feel and impeccable service, it’s a place where locals gather to celebrate special occasions.
The USDA Prime steaks are aged to perfection, ensuring a tender and flavorful experience. Each visit feels like a step back in time, with the restaurant’s rich decor and intimate ambiance enhancing the dining experience.
Here, the focus is on quality and tradition, making it a cherished spot for those in the know.
Benjamin Steakhouse
Nestled in Midtown, Benjamin Steakhouse is a testament to the timeless appeal of New York steakhouses. Its reputation for consistently excellent dry-aged beef makes it a go-to for locals seeking quality without compromise.
The service is impeccable, with staff going above and beyond to ensure a memorable meal. The cozy, club-like setting provides a warm backdrop for an indulgent dining experience.
Regular patrons appreciate the attention to detail, from the perfectly cooked steaks to the carefully curated wine list, making it a staple in their dining repertoire.
Keens Steakhouse
Keens Steakhouse is not just about the meat; it’s a journey through New York’s rich history. The restaurant’s unique pipe collection and storied past make it a fascinating destination in itself.
Known for its legendary mutton chop, Keens offers a dining experience steeped in tradition. The ambiance, filled with historical artifacts, transports diners to a bygone era. Locals cherish the sense of nostalgia and the consistent quality of the food.
It’s a place where each meal is a trip back in time, blending culinary excellence with rich history.
Gallagher’s Steakhouse
In the heart of the Theater District, Gallagher’s Steakhouse stands as a testament to the enduring allure of classic New York dining.
Its hickory-grilled steaks are a highlight, drawing locals who appreciate authenticity and flavor. The vintage meat locker window at the entrance sets the tone for a meal steeped in tradition. Post-theater diners find solace in the quieter atmosphere, where the focus is on savoring each bite.
The restaurant’s soul is in its simplicity, offering an unpretentious yet satisfying dining experience that keeps locals coming back.
Strip House
Strip House is where locals go for a steakhouse experience that’s as stylish as it is delicious. The sultry, red velvet interior adds a touch of glamour, while the beautifully charred steaks deliver on taste.
It’s a place where the atmosphere is as much a draw as the menu itself. Diners are treated to an experience that blends old Hollywood elegance with modern culinary excellence.
The intimate lighting and rich decor create a setting that’s perfect for a special night out, making it a beloved spot for those in the know.
Smith & Wollensky
Smith & Wollensky is a steakhouse that epitomizes the classic New York dining experience. Known for its high-end cuts and expertly crafted martinis, it’s a place where simplicity reigns supreme.
The decor is understated yet elegant, allowing the food to take center stage. For locals, it’s a reliable choice where quality is never compromised.
Each visit promises a taste of tradition, with dishes that are executed with precision and care. It’s a stalwart of the city’s dining scene, beloved for its consistency and timeless appeal.
Hawksmoor NYC
Hawksmoor NYC offers a refreshing take on the traditional steakhouse experience, blending British influences with New York flair.
The menu is a delightful mix of seafood starters and rich, flavorful steaks that have quietly won over locals. The sophisticated yet unpretentious setting provides a welcoming backdrop for a memorable meal. Patrons appreciate the thoughtful approach to flavors and the relaxed yet refined atmosphere.
It’s a hidden gem where the emphasis is on quality and innovation, making it a favorite among those who seek something different.
Royal 35 Steakhouse
Located just steps from Midtown’s bustling landmarks, Royal 35 Steakhouse offers an oasis of calm and refinement.
The polished service and elegant setting make it a preferred choice for locals seeking a sophisticated dining experience. Each steak is prepared with meticulous attention to detail, ensuring a consistently excellent meal.
The quiet charm of the restaurant creates a serene atmosphere, perfect for unwinding after a busy day. Regulars appreciate the seamless blend of elegance and quality, making it a reliable choice for a refined evening out.
Empire Steak House
Despite its Times Square location, Empire Steak House manages to maintain a sense of exclusivity that locals love.
The vibrant, flashy interior is balanced by a focus on high-quality meats that deliver on flavor and presentation. It’s a place where knowing what to order and when to visit pays off, allowing diners to experience the best the restaurant has to offer.
The juxtaposition of its tourist-heavy location with its dedicated local following creates a unique dining experience that’s both exciting and satisfying.