Ohio takes its pizza seriously. Forget the big chains—this is where family-owned parlors, corner shops, and long-loved neighborhood joints rule the scene. Each slice comes with its own story, its own flavor, and a loyal crowd of regulars who swear it’s the best they’ve ever had. Picture gooey cheese stretching from the pan, crusts baked to golden perfection, and toppings piled so generously they almost fall off the plate. Whether it’s square-cut, thin-crust, or loaded deep-dish style, Ohio’s pizza game is bold, comforting, and unforgettable. From Cleveland to Columbus, small towns to hidden alleys, these ten parlors aren’t just restaurants—they’re community legends. Step inside, grab a slice, and you’ll understand why locals can’t stop talking about them.
Rubino’s Pizza – Bexley
Rubino’s Pizza in Bexley is a slice of history, serving locals since 1954. Known for its thin-crust, square-cut pizzas, it features a distinctive provolone cheese topping. The ambiance is no-frills, and the establishment remains cash-only, adding to its nostalgic charm. The original oven, believed to be the soul of the place, still bakes each pie to perfection.
Generations have visited Rubino’s for its classic pies and the warm, familiar atmosphere it offers. It’s no wonder locals keep this gem close to their hearts.
Terita’s Pizza – Columbus
A true Columbus institution, Terita’s Pizza has been delighting taste buds since 1959. Their square-cut pizzas boast a crispy crust with caramelized cheese edges, making every bite a flavor-packed experience. The secret-spiced Italian sausage topping is particularly beloved.
With its cozy setting, Terita’s has been a venue for countless family celebrations over the years. Its cherished status among locals is a testament to its consistent quality and warm hospitality. A visit to Terita’s is a journey into Columbus’s culinary tradition.
Panzera’s Pizza – Grandview Heights
Since 1957, Panzera’s Pizza has been a beloved favorite in Grandview Heights. Known for its hand-tossed pizzas, the slightly sweet, herb-infused sauce offers a unique taste sensation.
The cozy atmosphere is filled with Ohio State spirit, especially during football season. Loyal customers often line up for a taste of their cherished pies, reminiscing about college days or creating new memories. Panzera’s blend of nostalgia and flavor keeps it at the forefront of local favorites.
The Original Josie’s Pizza – Columbus
Downtown Columbus has been home to The Original Josie’s Pizza since the 1960s. Famous for its square-cut pizza, the crust develops delightful air pockets during baking, offering a unique texture. The ambiance is steeped in nostalgia, with decor that brings back memories of simpler times.
The consistent quality of Josie’s pizzas is why locals return time and again. It’s a place where pizza lovers gather to savor both delicious food and cherished memories.
JT’s Pizza & Pub – Columbus
JT’s Pizza & Pub is where gourmet pizza meets the friendly vibe of a neighborhood bar. Known for its creative pizza offerings, the Buffalo chicken pizza, topped with homemade ranch dressing, is a crowd favorite. It’s the innovative menu and casual setting that attract a diverse crowd seeking something different.
Regulars and newcomers alike appreciate the unique culinary experience JT’s provides, making it a cherished spot among locals.
Mikey’s Late Night Slice – Columbus
Mikey’s Late Night Slice began as a small pizza window and has grown into a cult favorite for those late-night cravings. Offering New York-style slices with eclectic topping choices, it caters to the after-hours crowd.
The lively atmosphere, combined with extended hours, makes it a hotspot for night owls. Mikey’s playful spirit and dedication to quality slices make it a standout in the Columbus pizza scene.
Ohio Pie Co. – Brunswick
Ohio Pie Co. in Brunswick offers a unique twist with its Ohio Valley-style pizza. The crunchy base topped with fresh, cold ingredients like pepperoni and cheese has won the hearts of many. This innovative preparation method delivers bold flavors that stand out.
Locals flock to Ohio Pie Co. not just for the taste but for the novelty of this style of pizza. It’s a must-visit for anyone exploring distinctive pizza experiences in Ohio.
Alteri’s Ristorante – Stow
Alteri’s Ristorante, family-owned since 1965, offers a warm blend of Italian-American cuisine. The hand-tossed crust and generous toppings make their pizzas a staple in the Stow community.
With a welcoming atmosphere, Alteri’s is more than just a dining spot; it’s a place where memories are made. Its longstanding reputation is a testament to its commitment to quality and community warmth.
Fat Jack’s Pizza – Lima
Fat Jack’s Pizza in Lima is renowned for its hearty, flavorful pizzas and generous portions. The no-frills setting offers a comforting and familiar dining experience. Regulars praise the consistent quality and the variety of options available, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Fat Jack’s has become a beloved part of the local dining scene, cherished for its delicious offerings and welcoming environment.
The Pizza Parlor V – Sugarcreek
Nestled in Ohio’s Amish Country, The Pizza Parlor V in Sugarcreek is famous for its hearty pizzas and subs. The cozy, family-friendly atmosphere invites locals and visitors alike to enjoy generous portions of comfort food.
It’s a popular stop for those exploring the region, offering a taste of local hospitality and flavor. The Pizza Parlor V’s inviting charm makes it a must-stop for pizza enthusiasts.