6 Old-School Pennsylvania Candy Shops That Still Sell Penny Candy By The Scoop

One candy shop on this list will let you cram a small box with as much candy as you can fit, as long as the lid still closes. I love a challenge with rules that simple.

Another spot sells candy right beside an elephant museum. A different shop stocks more than 350 kinds of glass-bottled soda.

Pennsylvania clearly takes its sweet tooth seriously.

I went looking for shops that still treat candy like a treasure hunt. You grab a scoop or a bag, wander the bins, and pick your own mix one piece at a time.

No pre-packed bags. No boring checkout aisle grab.

Just you, a pile of old favorites, and the very real risk of leaving with way more than you planned.

1. Baldinger’s

Baldinger's
© Baldinger’s

Penny candy, nickel candy, and a whole table of fifteen-cent treats? Your pocket change finally has a job again.

Baldinger’s sits on Perry Highway in Zelienople, a historic Butler County borough with real main-street charm. The shop leans hard into nostalgia, with older candies you probably begged for as a kid.

Bulk candy is a big part of the fun here. You can mix those vintage favorites with trendy new picks, so the old-school crowd and the kids both win.

Then the shelves take a surprising turn. You’ll find baking supplies, teas, pancake mixes, jelly, and jams sharing space with the sweets.

Chocolates from Switzerland show up too, along with cheese and soda. It feels a little like a candy shop and a country pantry decided to become roommates.

Plan for a quick stop, though browsing may stretch it. Saturday afternoons get the busiest, so a weekday visit gives you more elbow room at the bins.

The shop opens daily from 10 AM to 6 PM. That makes it an easy add-on to any drive north of Pittsburgh.

Address: 519 Perry Hwy, Zelienople, PA 16063

2. Ballyhoo – Purveyors of Fine Ice Cream

Ballyhoo – Purveyors of Fine Ice Cream
© Ballyhoo – Purveyors of Fine Ice Cream

Ice cream gets top billing in the name, but the candy counter quietly steals the show. That’s a pretty good problem for a sweets lover.

Ballyhoo is an old-fashioned soda shoppe in West Pittston, a small borough along the Susquehanna River. The retro theme runs throughout, so the whole visit feels like a trip back a few decades.

At the penny candy counter, you pick your own assortment. Gummies, chocolates, and Swedish fish are part of the lineup, and prices stay friendly.

Homemade ice cream handles the other half of the job. Floats and sundaes fill the menu, including the Wet Walnut Sundae, a classic that suits the setting.

Kids fit right in, and groups work well too. Table service keeps things relaxed, and coffee is available if a grown-up needs a boost.

Timing matters here. The shop closes Mondays, opens at 5 PM on Tuesdays, and runs 2 to 10 PM the rest of the week.

Friday and Saturday evenings get lively. Try a Wednesday afternoon for a calmer scoop.

Address: 128 Luzerne Ave, West Pittston, PA 18643

3. Port Clinton Peanut Shop

Port Clinton Peanut Shop
© Port Clinton Peanut Shop

Peanuts may be in the name, but candy fans won’t feel left out. Not even a little.

Port Clinton is a tiny rural borough in Schuylkill County, and this shop is a big reason folks pull over there. It works as both a candy store and a nut shop, which is a smart combo for anyone torn between sweet and salty.

Fresh roasted peanuts anchor one side of the experience. The other side belongs to penny candy and traditional bulk sweets you pick out yourself.

The shop is built around stepping back in time. Still, you’ll spot some modern touches mixed in with the classic treats.

Free street parking makes the stop easy. Hours run a bit later toward the weekend, until 7 PM on Thursday and Friday and 8 PM on Saturday.

Weekend afternoons are the busiest stretch. A weekday morning gives you more space to wander and fill a bag slowly.

Here’s a fun Pennsylvania pairing for you. Grab peanuts for the ride and candy for later, if later ever happens.

Address: 97 Centre St, Port Clinton, PA 19549

4. Mister Ed’s Elephant Museum & Candy Emporium

Mister Ed's Elephant Museum & Candy Emporium
© Mister Ed’s Elephant Museum & Candy Emporium

Elephants and penny candy under one roof? Somebody had a brilliant idea, and it worked.

Mister Ed’s sits on Chambersburg Road in Orrtanna, a rural Adams County village not far from Gettysburg. Half the fun is the elephant museum, and the other half is a candy emporium carrying more than 1,200 varieties.

That number is not a typo. You’ll find old-fashioned penny candy plus large bulk bins for scooping your own mix.

The sweets don’t stop at the bins. Homemade fudge and fresh roasted nuts round out the counters, so you can build a snack plan for the whole trip home.

It’s an easy pick if you’re touring Gettysburg and want a lighter detour. Kids get candy, adults get candy, and everyone gets elephants.

A free parking lot keeps things simple. The doors open daily from 10 AM to 6 PM.

Saturday afternoons draw the biggest crowds. Tuesday mornings are among the quietest times, which is handy if you like to browse slowly.

Address: 6019 Chambersburg Rd, Orrtanna, PA 17353

5. Grandpa Joe’s Candy Shop

Grandpa Joe's Candy Shop
© Grandpa Joe’s Candy Shop

Can you close the lid? That’s the only rule that matters at the candy buffet here.

Grandpa Joe’s in Pittsburgh offers a small box you can pack with as much candy as fits, as long as it still shuts. Strategy suddenly becomes very important.

Tiny candies are your friend in this game. The buffet stocks a good spread of small retro and penny candies, so you can squeeze in plenty of variety.

Beyond the buffet, the shop goes floor to ceiling with retro sweets. Rare glass-bottled sodas add another layer of temptation.

The location helps too. It sits on Penn Avenue in the Strip District, a historic market neighborhood that’s great for wandering.

Hours are generous, running until 9 PM daily. Saturday opens early at 8 AM, which is perfect for morning Strip District shoppers.

Parking comes from paid lots and paid street spots. Delivery and in-store pickup are options if you’d rather skip the hunt for a space.

Address: 2124 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222

6. Grandpa Joe’s Candy Shop – York, PA

Grandpa Joe's Candy Shop - York, PA
© Grandpa Joe’s Candy Shop – York, PA

Three hundred fifty glass-bottled sodas. That’s enough fizz to try a new one every day for most of a year.

This York location sits at 2 S. George Street on Continental Square, right in the historic heart of downtown.

The shop covers 3,500 square feet, and it’s packed with nostalgic candy and quirky gifts.

The bulk candy buffet is the star for scoop fans. You fill your own box with classic bite-sized sweets, picking only what you love.

Walls of retro candy surround you while you shop. Then there’s hand-scooped ice cream, plus floats and milkshakes for a cold finish.

Downtown York makes a great backdrop for a sugar stroll. Market Street and the city’s murals are close by, so you can walk off a little of your haul.

Hours stretch late, until 10 PM on Fridays and Saturdays. Those weekend evenings get the busiest crowds.

Weekdays stay calmer for relaxed browsing. It’s a sweet way to end a Pennsylvania candy road trip.

Address: 2 S George St, York, PA 17401

Sharing is caring!