Skip to Content

8 old-school taverns in Pittsburgh still serving pub favorites

8 old-school taverns in Pittsburgh still serving pub favorites

Sharing is caring!

Pittsburgh’s taverns are where history, comfort food, and local stories come together. These old-school spots have been serving generations of regulars with hearty plates and classic drinks.

Step inside and you’ll find more than a meal—you’ll find tradition. These taverns keep the spirit of neighborhood gathering places alive in the Steel City.

Monterey Pub – North Side

Monterey Pub – North Side
Image Credit: © Tripadvisor

Step into Monterey Pub, where the heart of Pittsburgh beats in a cozy, welcoming environment. This North Side gem is famed for its hearty pub fare served with a side of local history. Wooden accents and vintage decor evoke a sense of nostalgia, drawing you into its warm embrace.

Known for its friendly service, Monterey Pub offers classic dishes that transport you back in time. The signature fish and chips is a crowd favorite, embodying comfort on a plate.

Monterey Pub is a haven for those seeking delicious food and a genuine sense of community.

Gooski’s – Polish Hill

Gooski’s – Polish Hill
Image Credit: © TribLIVE.com

In the heart of Polish Hill, Gooski’s stands as a testament to Pittsburgh’s eclectic nightlife. Known for its unassuming facade, it hides a vibrant interior buzzing with energy. The jukebox plays an eclectic mix, setting the tone for memorable evenings.

Gooski’s walls are adorned with local art, creating a quirky yet intimate atmosphere. Their pierogies are a must-try, perfectly embodying the area’s Polish roots.

A favorite among locals, Gooski’s is where stories are shared and memories are made, offering a slice of Pittsburgh you won’t find anywhere else.

Kelly’s Bar & Lounge – East Liberty

Kelly’s Bar & Lounge – East Liberty
Image Credit: © Pittsburgh Magazine

Kelly’s Bar & Lounge, nestled in East Liberty, radiates retro charm. Neon signs flicker outside, beckoning patrons into a space that blends nostalgia with a modern twist. Known for its carefully curated cocktails, the lounge offers flavors that tickle the palate.

Inside, the vibrant crowd mingles amidst the vintage decor. The menu features pub classics with a unique twist, such as their famed mac and cheese.

Kelly’s is more than a bar; it’s a community hub where laughter and good times flow effortlessly, inviting everyone to be part of its story.

Jack’s Bar – South Side

Jack’s Bar – South Side
Image Credit: © Wikimedia Commons

Jack’s Bar, a South Side staple, captures the spirit of Pittsburgh in every corner. It’s a place where history meets the hustle and bustle of today. The moment you walk in, the vintage signage and lively atmosphere envelop you.

Known for its affordable drinks and no-nonsense attitude, Jack’s attracts a diverse crowd looking to unwind. The jukebox plays classic tunes, adding to the vibrant ambiance.

Whether you’re a regular or a newcomer, Jack’s Bar offers a slice of authentic Pittsburgh life, one drink at a time.

Sieb’s Pub – Ross Township

Sieb’s Pub – Ross Township
Image Credit: © Patch

Sieb’s Pub in Ross Township is a haven for those craving traditional German fare. Stepping inside feels like a journey to a Bavarian inn, with beer steins lining the shelves and a cozy atmosphere that invites relaxation.

The menu features hearty dishes like schnitzels and bratwursts, each bite a nod to the pub’s heritage. Sieb’s is renowned for its extensive beer selection, offering brews that perfectly complement its rustic menu.

Whether it’s the food, the beer, or the friendly faces, Sieb’s Pub creates an authentic German experience in the heart of Pittsburgh.

Fat Head’s Saloon – South Side

Fat Head’s Saloon – South Side
Image Credit: © Roadfood

Fat Head’s Saloon is a cornerstone of Pittsburgh’s South Side, known for its extensive beer selection and larger-than-life sandwiches. The atmosphere is lively, drawing in locals and beer enthusiasts alike.

The menu boasts an array of hearty options, but it’s the signature Headwiches that truly stand out. Each sandwich is a meal in itself, packed with flavor and character.

At Fat Head’s, you’re not just having a meal; you’re part of a tradition that celebrates good food and even better company. It’s a slice of Pittsburgh hospitality.

William Penn Tavern – Shadyside

William Penn Tavern – Shadyside
Image Credit: © Thrillist

The William Penn Tavern in Shadyside is where history and sports fandom collide. Known for its cozy booths and walls adorned with memorabilia, it’s a haven for sports enthusiasts and history buffs alike.

The menu is a tribute to classic pub fare, with wings and sandwiches that hit the spot. The tavern’s laid-back atmosphere makes it a favorite for game days and casual nights out.

For those seeking a place with character and charm, the William Penn Tavern is a must-visit, offering a slice of Pittsburgh’s rich heritage with every visit.

Archie’s – South Side

Archie’s – South Side
Image Credit: © Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Archie’s on the South Side is a culinary gem, known for its unique decor and ever-changing chalkboard specials. The intimate setting invites patrons to relax and enjoy the creative twists on classic dishes.

The menu is a delightful surprise, with options that cater to adventurous palates. Regulars appreciate the homey feel and the friendly banter with staff.

At Archie’s, every visit is a new adventure. It’s a place where culinary creativity and community spirit thrive, making it a beloved spot for those in the know.