One Pennsylvania bakery will sell you a slice of apple pie and a hot dog as a combo. I love that someone looked at those two very different foods and thought, yes, obviously, that works.
That pairing says a lot about how seriously this state takes its apple pie. You’ll find slices inside a 1948 stainless-steel dining car and in a glass case by the door of a neon-lit diner.
One Pennsylvania Dutch smorgasbord even offers a no sugar added apple pie for folks watching their sweet tooth. Another stop serves deep dish slices in a small family restaurant right in apple orchard country.
I can’t think of a better excuse to plan a whole road trip around dessert. So grab a fork, find a map, and decide which slice gets your very first bite.
The Apple Bin Grill & Bakery
With the word apple right in its name and orchards all around, this Biglerville restaurant had better serve a great slice. Good news, it does.
The Apple Bin is a country-style family restaurant in Adams County, one of Pennsylvania’s best-known apple growing areas. Home-style diner classics and baked goods fill the menu, with a true small-town feel.
The deep dish apple pie is the one to order here. It fits right in with the orchard scenery you passed on the way in.
Get here early, since this is a morning and midday kind of place. Most days run from 6 AM to 2 PM, while Sunday opens at 7 AM and closes at noon.
Tuesdays are closed, so don’t drive out that day hoping for pie. Saturday mornings get busy, and weekday afternoons are usually quieter.
The staff earn kind words for being friendly and efficient. Outdoor seating is available, and dogs are welcome outside if your pup tags along.
Reservations are accepted, which helps when you’re bringing a group. Free parking makes the stop easy, especially during a scenic fall orchard drive.
Address: 674 Arendtsville Rd, Biglerville, PA 17307
Lancaster Pie & Coffee
A shop with pie and coffee right in its name doesn’t leave much room for confusion. You know exactly why you showed up, and that’s a fine thing.
This Lancaster spot on North Prince Street makes handmade sweet and savory pies and serves specialty coffee alongside them. Apple pie is a highlight, made from scratch for a classic homemade taste.
The flaky crust makes each slice even more tempting. Add vanilla ice cream if you want to make your dessert extra special.
Can’t commit to one flavor? Cherry, triple berry, pumpkin, chocolate silk, and chocolate peanut butter pies offer plenty of alternatives.
Quiche and hand pies round out the selection.
Breakfast lovers have options, too, including a Liège waffle and espresso. A slice of apple pie with coffee in the morning totally counts as breakfast, right?
Plan around the schedule: Lancaster Pie & Coffee is closed Monday through Wednesday. Thursday through Saturday, the shop is open from 9 AM to 5 PM, while Sunday hours run from 9 AM to 8 PM.
Friday evenings and Saturday afternoons can be busy. A Thursday visit or an early Sunday stop may offer more breathing room.
Paid street parking and garages are available nearby.
Address: 136 N Prince St, Lancaster, PA 17603
Village Farmer and Bakery
Apple pie and a hot dog, sold together as a combo. It’s an odd couple, and you’ll want to try it at least once.
Village Farmer and Bakery has been family owned and operated in Delaware Water Gap since 1976. It started as a small produce stand before growing into the bakery it is today.
More than 30 pie flavors are baked daily, including a 10-inch deep-dish apple pie made from scratch. The bakery uses pure cane sugar, with no chemical preservatives or high fructose corn syrup.
Apple fans can branch out with apple crumb, apple walnut, and French apple pies. Visitors can even watch pies being made right on the premises.
Savory cravings are covered with chicken pot pie, lobster rolls, and hot dogs. Apple cider donuts, jams, and local hot sauces round out the shelves.
Summer brings outdoor barbecue food, which makes the stop even more tempting. It’s an easy break while you explore the Delaware Water Gap area.
Monday through Thursday runs 8 AM to 6 PM, stretching to 8 PM Friday through Sunday. Weekends draw the biggest crowds, so a weekday visit feels calmer.
Address: 13 Broad St, Delaware Water Gap, PA 18327
Ritter’s Diner
Cash only, old-fashioned, and baking pies daily? This Pittsburgh diner sounds like it rolled straight out of the jukebox era, and that’s the whole appeal.
Sitting on Baum Boulevard, Ritter’s serves omelettes, sandwiches, and hearty home-style plates. Homemade desserts, cakes, and pies come out of the kitchen daily.
The apple pie has a reputation as some of the best in Pittsburgh. That’s a bold title in a city that takes comfort food very seriously.
Coconut cream pie and cheesecake also get plenty of love, so you may need a second fork. Or a second visit, which nobody will judge.
Before you go, remember the cash rule. An ATM sits on site, so an empty wallet won’t wreck your dessert plans.
Hours run from 7 AM to 8 PM daily, with breakfast, lunch, and dinner on the table. Fried green tomatoes, pumpkin pancakes, and Coco Loco pancakes show up on the menu too.
Saturday mornings and afternoons get busy, while Saturday evenings tend to be calmer. Counter seating works nicely if you’re flying solo with a slice and a coffee.
Address: 5221 Baum Blvd, Pittsburgh, PA 15224
Katie’s Kitchen
Amish-style cooking and homemade ice cream on the same menu? Ronks makes a strong case for skipping straight to dessert.
Katie’s Kitchen serves classic American diner food alongside Amish-style dishes in Lancaster County. Think country ham steak, chicken pot pie, and mac and cheese.
The apple pie comes with homemade ice cream, a combo that feels right at home here. It’s simple, sweet, and wonderfully old fashioned.
Apple dumplings also tempt fruit lovers, and shoo-fly pie gets plenty of attention. You could easily turn one visit into a Pennsylvania Dutch dessert sampler.
Pot roast with butter noodles and stewed tomatoes makes a hearty lead-in. Save room, though, because the dessert list is the real headline.
Picnic tables add a casual touch, and dogs are allowed outside. The staff keep things moving efficiently, even when it gets busy.
Hours run Tuesday through Friday from 7:30 AM to 7 PM, and Saturday until 6 PM. The restaurant closes Sunday and Monday, and reservations aren’t taken.
Saturday afternoons get the busiest. Weekday mornings are usually quieter, which is perfect for a breakfast that somehow ends with pie.
Address: 200 Hartman Bridge Rd, Ronks, PA 17572
Miller’s Smorgasbord
All-you-can-eat and apple pie belong in the same sentence. In Ronks, they share the same building, too.
Miller’s is a Pennsylvania Dutch eatery serving a buffet of local favorites all day. Fried chicken, carved meats, ham balls, chicken and waffles, and a big soup lineup fill the spread.
The house apple pie, listed as Miller’s Apple Pie, is considered a must-try. Pair it with homemade ice cream if you have any room left.
That’s a big if after the salad bar, bread smorgasbord, and steamed shrimp bar. Pace yourself, because the dessert area deserves a fair shot.
Miller’s own creamy cheesecake also sits among the sweets. Still, apple pie is the classic way to finish a Pennsylvania Dutch feast.
A fireplace adds charm to the casual, historic setting. Families and groups fit right in, and a kids’ menu keeps younger diners happy.
Reservations are recommended, and a wait is common. Saturday afternoons and evenings bring the biggest crowds.
Doors open at 11:30 AM Monday through Saturday and 11 AM on Sunday. Closing time is 7 PM most days, or 8 PM on Friday and Saturday.
Address: 2811 Lincoln Hwy E, Ronks, PA 17572
Bird-in-Hand Family Restaurant & Smorgasbord
Watching your sugar but still craving pie? A no sugar added apple pie sits on the lineup here, and that’s a thoughtful touch.
This long-standing landmark serves Pennsylvania Dutch home cooking two ways. Pick the smorgasbord or order à la carte, depending on your appetite.
The homemade apple pie can be heated up and topped with vanilla ice cream. That homemade crust is a big part of the appeal.
Pie variety is a real strength, with shoo-fly pie among the local favorites. You’ll find plenty of reasons to try more than one.
The buffet includes a soup and salad bar, broasted chicken, and Lancaster County roast turkey with filling. Ham balls and hot bacon dressing add more regional flavor.
Breakfast buffet fans get an early start, since doors open at 7 AM. Hours run Tuesday through Saturday until 7 PM, with Sunday and Monday closed.
Saturday afternoons and evenings draw crowds. Midweek mornings tend to be calmer, and reservations are accepted.
Bird in Hand sits in the heart of Lancaster County. It’s an easy addition to a day of exploring Amish country.
Address: 2760 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird in Hand, PA 17505
Capitol Diner
Neon outside, a pie case inside the door. This Harrisburg diner knows exactly how to tempt you before you even sit down.
Capitol Diner offers a vast menu of waffles, burgers, and other staples. Scrapple, eggs Benedict, chicken pot pie, and broiled haddock all make appearances.
The classic pie display greets you the moment you step through the entrance. Even breakfast visitors may catch themselves staring at it.
Apple caramel pie is a sweet pick for anyone who likes extra richness with their apples. Ordering a slice to go is smart if your meal fills you up first.
Hours are generous, from 6 AM to 10 PM most nights. Friday and Saturday stretch to 11 PM, which is great for late dessert runs.
Weekend mornings and afternoons are the busiest stretch. Weeknight evenings are quieter, so that’s a good time to sneak in for pie.
Seating is plentiful, and reservations are accepted. Free parking keeps the whole visit simple.
Harrisburg is the capital of Pennsylvania, so the name fits nicely. The Eisenhower Boulevard location makes it an easy stop for travelers passing through.
Address: 800 Eisenhower Blvd, Harrisburg, PA 17111
Glider Diner
Since 1948, a shiny stainless-steel dining car has been serving hungry visitors in Scranton. Train fans, this one has your name on it.
The Glider Diner has an atmosphere inspired by the classic railroad era. Its menu covers diner favorites, from roast beef to seafood platters.
The roast beef is a popular choice, alongside French dips, Texas cheeseburgers, and chicken pot pie.
For dessert, the apple cream pie puts a twist on an old favorite. The slices are generous, so sharing is optional but wise.
Big portions feature throughout the menu, and the diner offers plenty of familiar comfort food. Plan on leaving full and maybe a little sleepy.
Fish and chips, hot hamburgers, and the Glider sandwich round out the lineup. A veggie burger is available for meat-free diners.
Hours run from 8 AM to 9 PM Monday through Saturday and 8 AM to 8 PM Sunday. Evenings can get busy, and reservations aren’t accepted, so a little patience helps during peak times.
Free parking makes the stop easy. Scranton’s long railroad history makes this dining-car setting feel especially fitting.
Address: 890 Providence Rd, Scranton, PA 18508
Lyndon Diner
A fully stocked dessert bar is a dangerous thing to find in York. Here, it practically waves at you.
Lyndon Diner serves American comfort food for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. The menu is huge, with crab dip, Philly cheesesteak omelettes, egg casserole, and Belgian waffles.
Apple pie fits right in with the well-kept display of cakes, pies, and baked goods. It’s a dependable, classic way to close out a meal.
Lemon meringue pie, pumpkin bread, and an all the way chocolate fudge cake also compete for attention. Choosing might take a minute, and that’s okay.
The interior is bright, clean, and pretty. Service is friendly and quick, even when the dining room hums.
Doors open at 5:30 AM and stay open until 11 PM daily. Late-night pie cravings have a happy home here.
Weekend mornings and afternoons get the busiest. Weeknights are calmer, and reservations are accepted if you want to plan ahead.
Free parking makes it easy to swing by. Another York stop on this list sits across town, so a two-slice pie crawl is very doable.
Address: 1353 Kenneth Rd, York, PA 17404
Stonybrook Family Restaurant
Opening at 5 AM means you could technically have apple pie before sunrise. Whether you should is between you and your fork.
Stonybrook Family Restaurant in York serves hearty breakfast favorites in generous portions. Eggs Benedict, western egg sandwiches, and bagel stuffers headline the morning menu.
Apple pie holds its place among the homestyle desserts. Takeout is available, so bringing a slice home for later is easy.
The kitchen leans on simple ingredients with a family-owned feel. It’s the kind of food that reminds you of the good old days.
Servers are friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive. The family-friendly atmosphere and solid value make it a reliable pick.
Lunch and dinner are served too, with hours running daily until 9 PM. Outdoor seating is available when the weather cooperates.
Weekend mornings are the busiest stretch. Weekday afternoons are usually quieter, which is perfect for a lazy pie break.
Reservations are accepted, and delivery is offered. Free on-site parking makes the East Market Street location simple to reach.
Address: 3560 E Market St, York, PA 17402
Founding Farmers King of Prussia
Farmers own this restaurant, which feels like the perfect backstory for a slice of apple pie. It’s owned by a cooperative of growers, so the farm-to-table theme runs deep.
Founding Farmers King of Prussia serves American fare in rustic digs. Chicken pot pie, spicy fried chicken, fried green tomatoes, and a Farmers Platter all appear on the menu.
The apple pie comes in a generous serving with vanilla ice cream. It’s a big, comforting finish after a hearty meal.
Key lime pie is another dessert favorite, tangy and creamy. If you can’t decide, bring a friend and split both.
Breakfast starts early, and a Farmers Market Buffet Brunch is available too. Founding Farmers Hot Chocolate makes a sweet sidekick for your pie.
A fireplace adds charm, and outdoor seating is offered. Full vegan and vegetarian menus mean more of your crew can join the fun.
Reservations are recommended, and a wait is common. Saturday afternoons and evenings get the busiest, while weekday mornings stay calmer.
It’s a fitting final stop on a Pennsylvania pie tour. After all, who better to serve apple pie than farmers?
Address: 255 Main St Ste 180, King of Prussia, PA 19406
