Cheese curds, a jam called F.R.O.G., and a scoop of ice cream to reset your taste buds between samples. That’s a perfectly normal Saturday shopping trip at one small, cheese-packed Texas shop.
The shelves hold scorpion cheddar, blueberry cheese, Amish butter, local honey, and jars of pickled just about everything. Staff hand out samples freely, so your basket fills up much faster than planned.
On weekends, a hot grilled cheese basket can show up at the counter for lunch. One past special even let customers choose which cheese went inside the sandwich.
I like how a store this small makes a long drive across Texas feel completely reasonable. Honestly, I can’t imagine leaving with just one jar, and I doubt you could either.
A Cheese Lover’s Detour Waiting In Historic Downtown Montgomery
Slice of Amish sits right in the historic heart of Montgomery, Texas, a small town with big old-town charm. Google lists it as a cheese shop, but that label barely covers half the shelves.
Inside, you’ll find cheeses, jams, jellies, preserves, dips, honey, coffee, candies, and more. Think of it as a country pantry that happens to be obsessed with cheese.
The store is set in a neighborhood made for wandering. Nearby shops make it easy to turn one quick stop into a slow afternoon of shop hopping.
There’s also a fun detail tucked into the name. At least one shopper called this spot Slice of Amish #1, which suggests the Montgomery store came first.
For Texas families, that combination is hard to beat. You get a stroll through a historic downtown plus a store where tasting is part of the deal.
Grandparents can browse the preserves while the kids eye the ice cream case. Everybody wins, and nobody leaves empty-handed without putting up a real fight.
It’s the kind of old-fashioned stop that rewards anyone willing to slow down. Montgomery makes that very easy to do.
The Sample Tray Will Talk You Into Buying More
Free samples are the quiet troublemakers at this shop. One taste leads to another, and suddenly your shopping list has doubled.
The staff at Slice of Amish don’t just hand over cubes and walk away. Shoppers describe getting explanations with each sample, along with suggestions that fit what they actually need.
Helpful staff come up again and again in what people share about the store. Folks call the team knowledgeable, friendly, and genuinely passionate about what they sell.
The owner has a reputation for knowing her cheeses inside and out. That kind of expertise makes picking a party tray much less of a guessing game.
Shoppers have also mentioned staff members by name, which says a lot about a small business. When customers remember who helped them, the service clearly left a mark.
So go ahead and ask questions. Want something sharp, something creamy, or something with a little heat?
Somebody behind the counter will likely point you in a tasty direction. Just know that your wallet may feel lighter than expected by checkout.
Consider that a warning and an invitation. The samples are part of the fun, and the fun is very persuasive.
Cheese Curds This Far South Seem Almost Too Good To Be True
Cheese curds in South Texas? Yep, and they’re one of the most talked-about items on the shelves.
One shopper who once worked in Wisconsin admitted to being pickier than most Texans. Even so, they called Slice of Amish about as close as you’ll get down here.
The cheese lineup goes well beyond curds. White sharp cheddar and scorpion cheddar have both landed in shopping bags, sometimes by the pound.
Blueberry cheese shows up in conversations too, which sounds wild until you try it. Sweet and savory fans can finally share a cutting board in peace.
Then there’s Amish Butter Cheese, a name that practically sells itself. It’s a popular suggestion for anyone building a spread for a dinner party.
Deli cheeses round things out for everyday sandwich duty. You can grab something fancy for guests and something simple for Monday lunches.
Not sure where to start? Ask for a taste of a few before committing.
The variety means there’s a good chance something will surprise you. Just about any kind of cheese you could want seems to be hiding somewhere in this cheerful little shop.
Jams, Jellies, And One Jar Called F.R.O.G.
F.R.O.G. jam sounds like something a kid made up. Instead, it’s a real jar that one recent shopper happily carried home with summer sausage and cheese curds.
Jams and jellies are among the most mentioned treats at Slice of Amish. The shelves hold a strong lineup of preserves, perfect for toast, biscuits, or a fancy cracker board.
Local honey is another reason to linger in this aisle. One shopper even pointed out that a big jar felt reasonably priced, which is music to any budget-minded family.
The store also carries local homemade selections. Those handmade touches give the shelves a personal feel that big grocery stores rarely match.
Not everything here is small batch, though. One honest shopper wished for more mom-and-pop items, but still called the visit wonderful overall.
That mix actually works well for families. You can pick up a trusted favorite and gamble on a quirky homemade jar in the same trip.
Jars also make easy gifts for teachers, neighbors, or that relative who’s impossible to shop for. Stock up now, and holiday shopping suddenly looks a lot less stressful.
Party Table Supplies Hiding In Plain Sight
Hosting a get-together soon? This shop could handle half your grocery list in one cheerful stop.
Shoppers describe it as having everything for your party table. That includes cheeses, summer sausage, Amish butter, and candies for the sweet tooth crowd.
Dip mixes and cheese ball mixes are a big deal here too. Ready-made dips also show up, so you can skip the stirring if time is tight.
Then there’s the pickled section, which one shopper said covers seriously everything. If it fits in a jar with brine, it may well be on the shelf.
Jerky adds a road-trip-friendly snack to the mix. Some meats appear alongside the cheeses, giving you easy pairings without a second stop.
The Amish butter deserves its own shout. More than one shopper has singled it out as a highlight worth bringing home.
For parents chasing real food with simple ingredients, the store has struck a chord. One mom said she was learning these kitchen skills with her kids and found exactly what she needed.
That’s a pretty handy pantry for a small-town storefront. Slice of Amish keeps entertaining refreshingly easy.
Weekend Grilled Cheese Baskets Make Lunch An Easy Decision
Buttery, hot, and cheesy is how one fan described the grilled cheese here. That’s a tough sales pitch to ignore around lunchtime.
Grilled cheese is one of the most talked-about items at Slice of Amish. On weekends, the grilled cheese basket has been called a real treat.
Specials can change, so it pays to check what’s cooking. One day featured a choice of grilled cheese or a Reuben sandwich.
That same special let customers pick which cheese went into the grilled cheese. Getting to choose from a cheese shop’s own lineup feels like a small luxury.
Another lunch paired tomato soup with grilled Mediterranean cheese sandwiches. Comfort food doesn’t get much cozier than that combo.
For road-tripping families, a hot meal makes the stop even more worthwhile. You can shop, eat, and stretch your legs without hunting for another restaurant.
Kids usually understand grilled cheese without any explanation. Grown-ups get to feel a little fancy about their cheese selection.
Plan your visit around lunch if you can swing it. Showing up hungry to a cheese shop is a strategy, not a mistake.
Ice Cream Officially Counts As A Palate Cleanser
One retired Marine has a brilliant excuse for his scoop of ice cream. He insists it cleanses his palate between cheese tastings, and honestly, who’s going to argue?
Ice cream is part of the lineup at Slice of Amish. That makes it an easy win for kids who aren’t quite sold on sharp cheddar yet.
One parent bought ice cream for a daughter while sampling cheeses. It’s a smart way to keep little ones happy while grown-ups browse.
Coffee lovers get attention here too. Shoppers mention flavorful and specialized coffees, so the caffeine crowd won’t feel left out.
Teas sit on the shelves for anyone who prefers a gentler cup. Candies add one more temptation for every sweet tooth in the car.
All of this gives the store a wide appeal across generations. Grandparents, parents, and kids can each find something that feels like a treat.
That matters on a family road trip, when moods can turn quickly. A cone and a bag of candy can rescue the afternoon nicely.
Consider dessert part of the itinerary. Your palate, apparently, will thank you.
Check The Clock Before You Gas Up The Car
Timing is everything with a small-town shop. Slice of Amish keeps hours that shift a bit through the week, so plan ahead.
Find it at 401 College St Ste 170, Montgomery, TX 77356. Montgomery sits north of the Houston area, making it a manageable day trip for many Texas families.
Thursday through Saturday, doors open from 10 AM to 6 PM. Wednesday runs from 10 AM to 5 PM.
Tuesday hours are shorter, from 10 AM to 3 PM. Sunday visitors can stop by from 11 AM to 3 PM.
Mondays are closed, so don’t make that the day you drive out. Nobody wants to stare longingly at cheese through a window.
Saturdays can get busy, according to one recent shopper. If you prefer elbow room, a weekday visit may feel calmer.
Still, weekends bring that grilled cheese basket. You’ll have to decide whether crowds or sandwiches matter more.
Leave extra time for the neighborhood around the store. Historic Montgomery invites a slow stroll and a little shop hopping before heading home.
A cooler in the trunk is a smart idea. Cheese and butter travel happier when they stay chilled.
Worth Every Mile Of The Drive Home
A 4.8-star rating across 76 Google reviews tells a pretty clear story. People who stop here tend to leave smiling and loaded with bags.
Slice of Amish nails the small-town experience that so many Texans crave. It’s friendly, focused, and stocked with treats that feel like a reward for making the trip.
The cheese case alone could justify the drive. Add jams, honey, pickles, dips, and a weekend grilled cheese, and the case gets even stronger.
Service may be the real secret ingredient. Shoppers keep coming back to how helpful and welcoming the staff are.
Families will find something for every age group. Kids get ice cream, parents get pantry staples, and grandparents get a taste of old-fashioned shopping.
Pair it with a stroll through historic Montgomery for a full, easygoing afternoon. It’s a relaxed day trip that doesn’t require a big budget or a packed schedule.
I believe the best Texas stops are the ones that feel personal. This little shop fits that description nicely.
Just bring a cooler and a little restraint. You’ll probably need the cooler more than the restraint.
