In a world of over-the-top toppings and gourmet experiments, Maine’s best pizza shops prove that simplicity never goes out of style. Here, it’s all about perfectly baked crusts, rich tomato sauce, and just the right balance of cheese — no frills, no fuss, just flavor.
From cozy neighborhood spots to family-run kitchens, these pizzerias celebrate the timeless art of a great slice, the kind that keeps locals coming back week after week.
Otto (Portland)
Ever wonder what happens when creativity meets simplicity? Otto in Portland delivers just that with its unique approach to traditional pizza. The shop’s ambiance, blending modern and rustic elements, sets the stage for a memorable dining experience.
Famous for its mashed potato and bacon pizza, Otto isn’t afraid to experiment without losing sight of classic flavors. Each slice is crafted with care, ensuring that the fusion of ingredients is both surprising and satisfying.
Pizza enthusiasts will appreciate the attention to detail and the quality of ingredients. Otto’s commitment to innovation, while respecting the basics, makes it a must-visit.
Slab Sicilian Street Food (Portland)
Thick, hearty slices are the hallmark of Slab Sicilian Street Food in Portland. Known for its robust atmosphere and bold flavors, this spot transports you straight to the heart of Sicily.
The dough is the star here, airy yet substantial, providing a perfect base for generous toppings. It’s a place where indulgence meets authenticity.
Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Slab offers a slice of comfort with a dash of Mediterranean flair. Every bite is an invitation to savor the rich culinary heritage of Sicilian street food.
Portland Pie Company (Portland)
Portland Pie Company is where pizza meets creativity in an urban setting. Known for its flavored dough options, each choice adds a unique twist to the classic pizza experience.
The atmosphere is vibrant, making it a perfect spot for both casual outings and special occasions. Their dedication to using local ingredients ensures freshness in every bite.
Whether it’s their signature beer dough or their creative topping combinations, Portland Pie Company delivers a delightful surprise. It’s a place where innovation and tradition coexist in harmony.
Pizza Villa (Portland)
Stepping into Pizza Villa is like stepping back in time. This family-run establishment has been a staple in Portland for decades, offering classic pizzas that resonate with nostalgia.
The no-frills approach focuses on quality ingredients and time-tested recipes. Each pizza is a testament to tradition and the love of good food.
Pizza Villa’s charm lies in its simplicity, where each slice carries the warmth of family gatherings. It’s a reminder of why sometimes, the old ways are the best ways.
Pat’s Pizza (Orono)
In the heart of Orono, Pat’s Pizza has become synonymous with community and comfort food. Known for its thin crust and generous toppings, each pizza is a celebration of flavor and simplicity.
The atmosphere is welcoming, making it a favorite for locals and students alike. Pat’s Pizza is more than a dining spot; it’s a cherished gathering place.
With a history dating back to the 1930s, Pat’s continues to serve up slices that connect generations. Here, every pie is a piece of local history.
Hilltop Superette (Portland)
While Hilltop Superette may not be a traditional pizzeria, its pizza offerings have garnered a loyal following. Known for its casual vibe and friendly service, it’s a gem in Portland’s food scene.
The pizzas are straightforward, focusing on fresh ingredients and balanced flavors. Each bite is a reminder of the joys of uncomplicated food.
Hilltop Superette is where simplicity shines, creating an inviting experience for everyone who walks through its doors. It’s a testament to the enduring appeal of the simple things in life.
Corsetti’s (Westbrook)
Corsetti’s in Westbrook is the epitome of a neighborhood pizzeria. Known for its warm atmosphere and hearty slices, it’s a place where everyone feels like family.
The focus here is on traditional pizza-making, with an emphasis on fresh, local ingredients. It’s a slice of comfort in every sense.
Corsetti’s dedication to its craft ensures that each pizza is a delightful journey through flavors. It’s a haven for those who appreciate the enduring simplicity of good pizza.
Otto (Yarmouth)
Otto’s second location in Yarmouth continues to uphold its reputation for innovative yet simple pizzas. Known for its creative combinations, this location offers a fresh take on the familiar.
The atmosphere is modern and inviting, making it a popular spot for pizza aficionados. Each slice presents a blend of unexpected ingredients and classic tastes.
Otto in Yarmouth is where experimentation meets tradition, offering pizzas that are both intriguing and comforting. It’s a testament to the versatility of this beloved dish.
Brickyard Hollow Brewing Company (Freeport)
At Brickyard Hollow Brewing Company in Freeport, pizza pairs perfectly with craft beer. Known for its artisanal approach, the pizzas here are as thoughtfully crafted as the brews.
The ambiance is lively, making it a perfect spot for gatherings. Each pizza features fresh ingredients, striking a balance between creativity and tradition.
Brickyard Hollow embraces the art of pizza-making, offering a dining experience that is both flavorful and fun. It’s a celebration of local craftsmanship in every bite.
Maine Beer Company (Freeport, pizza nights)
Maine Beer Company in Freeport is known for its pizza nights, where simplicity meets quality. The focus is on fresh, local ingredients that complement their craft beers perfectly.
The modern, welcoming atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for enjoying good food and great company. Each pizza is a testament to the beauty of understated elegance.
Maine Beer Company proves that sometimes, the simplest flavors are the most satisfying. It’s where the art of pizza-making and brewing come together seamlessly.
Lewiston House of Pizza (Lewiston)
Lewiston House of Pizza offers a slice of comfort with a side of community spirit. Known for its extensive menu and welcoming environment, it’s a favorite among locals.
The pizzas are crafted with care, focusing on traditional flavors that evoke a sense of nostalgia. Each visit promises a taste of home.
This pizzeria captures the essence of Maine’s love for simple, honest food. It’s a place where every slice tells a story, and every meal is an opportunity to connect.