Explore the vibrant culinary scene in Key West, where every meal tells a story.
From local favorites to tourist traps, discover which dining experiences are worth every penny and which ones might leave you wanting more.
With diverse flavors and unique atmospheres, Key West offers something for every palate.
This guide highlights eight must-visit eateries renowned for their delectable offerings and five you may want to think twice about before visiting.
Whether you’re a seafood lover or a fan of international cuisine, our list provides the insights you need for a memorable dining adventure.
El Siboney (Cuban Food, Old Town)
El Siboney is a haven for Cuban cuisine enthusiasts. Located in Old Town, this no-frills establishment offers generous portions of authentic dishes like ropa vieja and vaca frita.
The vibrant atmosphere mirrors the rich flavors on the plate, making it a favorite among locals. Perfect for those seeking a hearty meal with a touch of Cuban flair. Don’t miss their signature roast pork, served with sweet plantains.
The rustic decor adds to the charm, creating a lively dining experience that captures the essence of Cuban culture. A must-visit for any Key West traveler.
Hogfish Bar & Grill (Stock Island)
Hogfish Bar & Grill is Stock Island’s hidden gem, offering the best hogfish sandwich you’ll ever taste. Nestled behind the marina, this casual spot provides a laid-back atmosphere with stunning views.
Savor the Key West pink shrimp while watching boats drift by. The ambiance is relaxed, inviting seafood lovers to indulge in fresh flavors. Known for its friendly service and unbeatable location, Hogfish Bar & Grill is more than just a meal—it’s an experience.
A perfect spot for those looking to enjoy quality seafood away from the tourist crowds.
Blue Heaven (Breakfast & Brunch)
Blue Heaven is a delightful brunch destination in Key West, famed for its quirky courtyard and lively atmosphere. Roaming roosters and a vibrant setting make every visit memorable.
Indulge in their renowned lobster Benedict and finish with a slice of Key lime pie. The eclectic vibe attracts both locals and tourists, creating a bustling environment filled with laughter and chatter.
Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a regular, Blue Heaven’s charm and delicious offerings ensure a unique dining experience. A must-visit for breakfast lovers exploring the island’s culinary delights.
Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria
Nestled off Duval Street, Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria is a hidden gem for pizza aficionados. This charming eatery is set in a garden courtyard, offering a serene escape from the bustling streets.
The wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas, crafted with fresh mozzarella, are a testament to authentic Italian flavors. The oak-burning ovens infuse each pie with a unique aroma, making every bite a delightful experience.
Perfect for those seeking a slice of Italy in Key West. Enjoy a casual meal amidst lush greenery, where the ambiance is as inviting as the food.
Santiago’s Bodega
Santiago’s Bodega stands out in Bahama Village for its vibrant atmosphere and eclectic menu. Specializing in tapas, this lively spot offers globally inspired dishes perfect for sharing.
Pair your meal with their famous sangria, and enjoy a night filled with flavors and fun. The warm, inviting decor and friendly service make it a popular choice for both locals and tourists.
With a diverse menu that caters to all tastes, Santiago’s Bodega promises a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re a tapas enthusiast or new to the concept, it’s a culinary adventure worth taking.
Louie’s Backyard
Louie’s Backyard offers a blend of elegance and casual dining along Key West’s waterfront. Known for its stunning sunset views, this restaurant provides a picturesque backdrop for any meal.
Try the cracked conch with wasabi cream, a dish that perfectly captures the essence of coastal cuisine. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or enjoying a quiet evening, Louie’s Backyard delivers with its refined menu and attentive service.
The serene ambiance and exquisite flavors make it a top choice for discerning diners seeking a memorable culinary experience.
The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.
The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. combines retro charm with innovative cuisine, offering a unique dining experience in Key West.
This chic spot is known for creative dishes like bacon-wrapped scallops and ricotta cheesecake. The vibrant decor and fun atmosphere make it a standout choice for those seeking something different. Each dish is crafted with care, delivering big flavors in a playful setting.
With its bold menu and lively energy, The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. A delightful destination for adventurous eaters.
Café Solé
Tucked away in a charming Creole cottage, Café Solé offers a taste of French-Caribbean cuisine in Key West. Known for its intimate setting and flavorful dishes, this restaurant is a hidden treasure.
Signature offerings like hogfish with hollandaise and delicate ceviche delight the palate. The cozy ambiance, combined with attentive service, creates a dining experience that feels both special and inviting.
Perfect for a romantic dinner or a quiet retreat from the bustling streets. Café Solé promises a culinary journey filled with elegance and taste.
Southernmost Beach Café
This place has the view, no doubt. Steps from the sand with an ocean breeze and pastel umbrellas, Southernmost Beach Café looks like vacation on a plate.
But for all the prime real estate, the food doesn’t always hold up its end of the deal. Expect small portions at big prices, with quality that can swing from decent to forgettable. Service can be hit-or-miss, especially during peak hours, and several diners report the best part of the meal was the view—not the flavor.
It’s a great spot for a drink by the water, but if you’re looking for a memorable meal, you might want to wander a little farther off Duval.
Latitudes – Sunset Key Cottages
Latitudes offers a dining experience with panoramic views, but recent reviews suggest the food doesn’t live up to expectations.
While the ambiance is undeniably appealing, with breathtaking ocean vistas, the menu has been deemed underwhelming by some diners. High prices further exacerbate the disappointment, leading many to question whether the view justifies the cost.
For those seeking a culinary adventure, Latitudes may not deliver the desired flavors. It’s a spot where the setting shines, but the cuisine may leave you wanting more. Consider it for the scenery, but temper your expectations for the food.
Conch Republic Seafood Company
Conch Republic Seafood Company presents itself with attractive seafood dishes, yet some diners have reported a lack of freshness.
Despite the picturesque presentation, the use of frozen ingredients has left a few patrons underwhelmed. Located in a prime spot, this restaurant tends to attract tourists, leading some to label it a tourist trap. While the lively atmosphere draws in crowds, seafood lovers seeking authenticity might be disappointed.
It’s a place where looks can be deceiving, and those in search of true local flavors may want to explore elsewhere. A caution for discerning diners.
Sloppy Joe’s Bar & Grill
Sloppy Joe’s Bar & Grill is renowned more for its history than its cuisine. A staple in Key West, it attracts tourists eager to soak in the lively atmosphere.
However, locals often describe the food as mediocre, overshadowed by the bar’s storied past. While the energy is infectious, those seeking a remarkable meal might leave disappointed.
It’s a place where the experience outweighs the culinary offerings, providing a lively backdrop for drinks but not necessarily gourmet dining. A reminder that sometimes history and ambiance can outshine the menu.
Garbo’s Grill @ Hank’s
Garbo’s Grill @ Hank’s is a food truck with a reputation that doesn’t quite match reality. Known for its tacos and hot dogs, some diners have found the flavors lacking.
Despite the intriguing menu, the taste often falls flat, leaving patrons questioning the premium prices. The pressure to tip adds to the dilemma, making the experience feel less than satisfying.
While the setting is convenient, especially for a quick bite, those looking for bold flavors might be left wanting. It’s a reminder that not all street food lives up to its hype.