Seafood lovers, brace yourselves! You don’t need to live on the coast to devour lobster rolls, briny oysters, and buttery crab legs that taste like they just arrived from the Atlantic. Ohio might be landlocked, but its seafood scene is nothing short of magical. From cozy lakeside bistros to bustling urban seafood bars, these 10 restaurants prove that the Buckeye State knows its way around a fish fillet.
Whether you crave classic New England-style seafood, sushi-grade fish, or indulgent shrimp platters, Ohio delivers flavor-packed dishes that rival any coastal city. Get ready to forget about geography and dive fork-first into some of the best seafood experiences you’ll ever have.
Pier W
For over five decades, Pier W in Lakewood has been enchanting diners with its panoramic views of Lake Erie. This iconic eatery, established in 1965, is renowned for its sophisticated ambiance and commitment to fresh seafood. Picture yourself enjoying a bowl of lobster bisque while gazing at the shimmering lake. It’s not just the food that impresses, but the whole experience.
Whether celebrating a special occasion or enjoying a casual meal, Pier W ensures a memorable dining affair. The restaurant’s history and commitment to quality make it a beloved destination.
Blue Point Grille
Nestled in Cleveland’s vibrant Warehouse District, Blue Point Grille offers an urban seafood dining experience. Known for its soaring ceilings and scenic views, this restaurant crafts a cosmopolitan atmosphere that complements its sophisticated menu.
Diners often rave about the freshness of the seafood, with dishes like Blue Point oysters stealing the spotlight. The chic setting makes it perfect for both business dinners and romantic evenings. Recognized as Cleveland’s Most Popular Restaurant by Zagat, it’s a must-visit for anyone craving top-notch seafood.
Salmon Dave’s
Salmon Dave’s in Rocky River is a haven for those seeking Pacific Rim flavors in a cozy setting. This beloved spot is known for its inventive seafood dishes, such as pan-roasted salmon and Chilean sea bass.
The restaurant recently underwent renovations, adding to its charm and allure. Its inviting atmosphere draws locals and visitors alike, all eager to savor a meal that defies Ohio’s landlocked status. The attentive service and commitment to quality have cemented Salmon Dave’s as a favorite in the community.
The Haunted House Restaurant
In Cleveland, The Haunted House Restaurant offers a dining experience that thrills beyond just the taste buds. As its name suggests, the restaurant boasts a horror-themed atmosphere, complete with eerie decor and a menu that features standout seafood offerings.
The unique setting makes for a fun and exciting dining adventure. Open Tuesday to Sunday, it’s a place where the spooky ambiance enhances the enjoyment of every dish. Whether you’re a horror enthusiast or merely seeking a novel gastronomic experience, this restaurant delivers.
Jay’s Seafood Restaurant
Jay’s Seafood Restaurant is a Dayton institution, nestled in the heart of the Historic Oregon District. Since 1976, it has been delighting patrons with its extensive seafood menu and warm, inviting atmosphere. Known for its commitment to quality, Jay’s ensures every dish is crafted to perfection.
Enjoy classics like crab cakes in a setting that feels like a step back in time. The restaurant’s history and charm continue to attract seafood lovers from all over Ohio, making it a cherished spot for locals and visitors alike.
Mitchell’s Fish Market
Columbus houses the renowned Mitchell’s Fish Market, where seafood lovers can indulge in premium selections from New England to the Gulf of Mexico. This contemporary establishment offers a refined yet casual dining experience, perfect for any occasion. With an emphasis on freshness, the menu features a variety of expertly prepared dishes.
The inviting atmosphere and exceptional service make it a top choice for diners seeking quality seafood in the city. Whether for a business lunch or family dinner, Mitchell’s stands out with its culinary excellence.
Real Seafood Company
In Cincinnati, Real Seafood Company brings the ocean’s bounty to the heartland. The restaurant’s contemporary vibe is matched by its impressive menu, featuring fish and seafood from all over the U.S. The casual yet refined atmosphere makes it a versatile spot for any dining occasion.
Known for its fresh ingredients and expertly crafted dishes, Real Seafood Company ensures every meal is a delightful experience. Whether savoring a classic dish or something more adventurous, guests leave with a taste of coastal dining right in Ohio.
Ocean Prime
In Dublin, Ocean Prime offers a luxurious dining experience, blending fresh seafood with classic American steakhouse elements. The modern supper club ambiance creates a sophisticated backdrop for enjoying dishes like seared sea bass or filet mignon.
Perfect for special occasions, Ocean Prime is known for its exceptional service and well-curated menu. Each visit promises a feast for the senses, from the artfully presented dishes to the chic surroundings. It’s a place where diners can indulge in both taste and elegance.
Bonefish Grill
Bonefish Grill in Columbus offers an inviting setting where seafood enthusiasts can enjoy a diverse menu. Known for signature dishes like Bang Bang Shrimp, the restaurant provides a blend of upscale and casual dining. Its warm atmosphere and attentive service make it a favorite for both locals and visitors.
With a focus on fresh, wood-grilled fish, every dish is crafted to satisfy. Whether catching up with friends or enjoying a family meal, Bonefish Grill delivers a delightful seafood experience.
Arthur Treacher’s Fish & Chips
Arthur Treacher’s Fish & Chips brings a taste of British tradition to Cuyahoga Falls. As one of the last remaining locations of this iconic chain, it offers a nostalgic fast-food experience. Known for its crispy fish and chips, the menu also includes other fried seafood delights.
The casual setting provides a quick and satisfying meal, reminiscent of seaside eateries. With a rich history dating back to its peak in the 1970s, Arthur Treacher’s continues to serve up classic flavors that never go out of style.