Tennessee is home to some of the finest pumpkin pies that leave both locals and visitors eagerly awaiting the fall season. These eight cafes are renowned for their delectable takes on this autumn classic, each offering a unique twist that makes them stand out. From family-run bakeries to iconic eateries, here is a guide to the best pumpkin pies in the state.
Loveless Cafe — Nashville area
Nestled near Nashville, Loveless Cafe is a beloved institution known for its Southern hospitality and mouth-watering pies. Their pumpkin pie is a seasonal favorite, featuring a rich, creamy filling and a perfectly flaky crust. You can almost feel the love that goes into each slice.
What makes Loveless Cafe truly special is its commitment to using locally sourced ingredients, ensuring freshness in every bite. The pie is best enjoyed with a cup of their famous coffee, making it a cozy experience on a crisp autumn day.
Visitors often reminisce about the charming ambiance, where time seems to slow down, allowing everyone to savor each delightful flavor.
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop — Knoxville
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop, located in Knoxville, offers a pumpkin pie that’s as aesthetically pleasing as it is delicious. The pie boasts a smooth texture with a hint of nutmeg, capturing the essence of fall.
Known for their creativity, the shop often experiments with different spices and toppings, adding a unique twist to the traditional pumpkin pie. Whether you’re a pie purist or an adventurous eater, there’s something here for everyone.
Step into the shop, and you’ll be greeted by the warm aroma of freshly baked pies, making it nearly impossible to leave with just one slice.
Niedlov’s Bakery & Cafe — Chattanooga
Niedlov’s Bakery & Cafe in Chattanooga takes pride in its artisanal approach, crafting each pumpkin pie with precision and care. The pie’s silky filling is perfectly balanced with a delicate spice blend, ensuring each mouthful is a delightful experience.
What sets Niedlov’s apart is their dedication to quality. They mill their own flour, lending an authentic touch to the crust, which crumbles just right with each bite.
It’s a favorite among locals who flock here not only for the pie but for the warm, inviting ambiance that makes every visit special.
Baked on 8th — Nashville
Baked on 8th is a Nashville gem, known for its innovative takes on classic desserts. Their pumpkin pie, with a drizzle of caramel, is a must-try, offering a deliciously modern twist.
The bakery prides itself on using organic ingredients, ensuring every pie is as wholesome as it is tasty. The caramel adds a sweet, rich layer, perfectly complementing the pie’s creamy pumpkin base.
With its stylish decor and friendly staff, Baked on 8th provides a contemporary setting to enjoy a slice of autumnal delight, making it a hotspot for dessert lovers.
Dozen Bakery — Nashville
In the heart of Nashville, Dozen Bakery serves a pumpkin pie that draws crowds. Known for its minimalistic elegance, the bakery’s pie features a velvety filling with a hint of ginger, offering a subtle twist on the classic.
Each pie is crafted with precision, from the buttery crust to the perfectly spiced filling. The addition of ginger adds a delightful warmth, enhancing the overall flavor profile.
Regulars appreciate the pie’s consistent quality and the bakery’s welcoming atmosphere, making it a beloved spot for both locals and visitors seeking a sweet escape.
The Old Mill Pottery House Café — Pigeon Forge
At The Old Mill Pottery House Café in Pigeon Forge, the pumpkin pie is as much a work of art as it is a dessert. Served on handcrafted pottery, the pie stands out for its rich, rustic flavors.
The pie combines a traditional filling with a robust mix of spices, offering a hearty taste of fall. The café’s charming setting, complete with unique pottery pieces, adds to the overall experience.
Patrons often pair their pie with a warm beverage, enjoying the picturesque surroundings that make this locale a true Pigeon Forge treasure.
Muddy’s Bake Shop — Memphis
Muddy’s Bake Shop in Memphis is famous for its playful take on the classic pumpkin pie. Topped with candied pecans, the pie offers a delightful crunch that complements its smooth, creamy filling.
The shop’s atmosphere is as vibrant as its decor, making every visit an exciting adventure. The addition of pecans not only adds texture but also enhances the pie’s nutty undertones.
Known for its quirky charm, Muddy’s provides a fun, casual environment where everyone feels at home, making it a local favorite for pie enthusiasts and families alike.
Frost Bake Shop — Memphis
Located in Memphis, Frost Bake Shop serves a pumpkin pie that’s nothing short of exquisite. The perfectly whipped cream swirl atop the pie adds a touch of elegance to an already sophisticated dessert.
Each slice offers a harmonious blend of spices and sweetness, providing a balanced flavor that keeps patrons coming back for more. The bakery is renowned for its meticulous attention to detail, evident in every bite.
With its sleek decor and attentive service, Frost Bake Shop offers a refined setting, making it a delightful spot to indulge in a timeless fall treat.