Skip to Content

The debate over the best Pennsylvania hoagie might finally end at this neighborhood deli

The debate over the best Pennsylvania hoagie might finally end at this neighborhood deli

Sharing is caring!

Nestled in the heart of Philadelphia’s Mayfair neighborhood, Marinucci’s Deli has garnered a reputation for crafting some of the most mouth-watering hoagies around. With a stellar 4.7-star rating from over 1,600 reviews, this unassuming deli attracts both locals and visitors eager to experience its generous portions and fresh ingredients.

Whether you’re a hoagie connoisseur or a newcomer to Pennsylvania’s classic sub, Marinucci’s offers a taste that promises to linger in your memory. Dive into the world of Marinucci’s to discover why this deli might just be the answer to the ongoing debate over the best hoagie in Pennsylvania.

Corned Beef Special

Corned Beef Special
© Marinucci’s Deli – Mayfair

If you’re in search of a corned beef experience that rivals the best, Marinucci’s Corned Beef Special is a must-try. This sandwich boasts a generous layer of tender, juicy corned beef, paired with tangy coleslaw and a hint of Russian dressing. Served on a freshly baked roll, the combination of flavors and textures is nothing short of exceptional.

Customers from across the city have been known to seek out this delicacy, skipping other options in favor of Marinucci’s take.The deli’s traditional approach, blending classic techniques with neighborhood authenticity, ensures a satisfying meal that stands out among Philadelphia’s crowded sandwich scene.

The Italian Hoagie at Marinucci’s

The Italian Hoagie at Marinucci's
© Marinucci’s Deli – Mayfair

Some say the magic of Marinucci’s lies in its Italian hoagie. Generously filled with a hearty mixture of meats and cheeses, it’s crowned with fresh vegetables and encased in a perfectly soft roll.

Each bite promises a symphony of flavors, evoking memories of Italian street markets. What’s unique is the deli’s dedication to quality—everything is sliced right in front of you, ensuring every sandwich is as fresh as possible. The staff’s warm familiarity adds to the neighborhood charm, making the experience more than just about the food.Patrons often mention the large size, which makes each hoagie a truly satisfying meal, worthy of repeat visits.

Customer Service and Atmosphere

Customer Service and Atmosphere
© Marinucci’s Deli – Mayfair

Stepping into Marinucci’s Deli feels like entering a family gathering. The friendly staff, comprised of local neighborhood folks, exudes warmth that makes every visit feel personal and welcoming.

Despite its bustling nature during lunch hours, the small space adds an intimate charm.The deli’s popularity means it can get crowded, but the vibrant energy is part of its allure. Watching your hoagie being crafted behind the counter is a testament to their transparency and dedication.While the atmosphere might be compact, the genuine service and community feel more than compensate, making each visit a memorable culinary adventure.

The Mayfair Community’s Favorite

The Mayfair Community's Favorite
© Marinucci’s Deli – Mayfair

Marinucci’s Deli isn’t just a place to grab a quick meal; it’s a beloved institution within the Mayfair community. Locals often share stories of family visits, turning a simple hoagie run into a cherished tradition.The deli’s consistent quality and reasonable prices have earned it a loyal following.

From weekend lunch outings to last-minute dinner solutions, Marinucci’s has become an integral part of daily life in Mayfair.This deep-rooted connection between the deli and its patrons highlights why Marinucci’s is more than a neighborhood eatery; it’s a community cornerstone, uniting generations over shared flavors and fond memories.

Roast Pork with Sharp Provolone and Broccoli Rabe

Roast Pork with Sharp Provolone and Broccoli Rabe
© Marinucci’s Deli – Mayfair

This hoagie leans into Pennsylvania pride with juicy roast pork, sharp provolone, and garlicky broccoli rabe. You get heat from crushed peppers and a tangy swipe of long hots, cut by a drizzle of oil and vinegar.

The seeded roll keeps everything anchored and crackly.

Expect a beautiful bite rhythm: bitter greens, creamy snap, savory pork. The deli trims the pork thin so it folds softly, never chewy.

Ask for extra provolone if you like it bolder, then add a dash of black pepper.

Turkey Diablo with Long Hots

Turkey Diablo with Long Hots
© Marinucci’s Deli – Mayfair

If you love spice, the Turkey Diablo delivers a friendly burn. Thin turkey stacks high beneath provolone, shredded lettuce, and juicy tomatoes.

Long hots bring smoky heat while a creamy spicy mayo cools just enough to keep you going.

There is crunch from onions, sparkle from vinegar, and sesame roll fragrance in every breath. Ask for light oil to keep flavors bright.

This one hits hard but stays balanced so you can actually finish without tongue fatigue.

Roasted Veggie Balsamico

Roasted Veggie Balsamico
© Marinucci’s Deli – Mayfair

Charred zucchini, sweet peppers, and silky eggplant turn this hoagie into a craveable meatless staple. Caramelized onions bring jammy depth, while sharp provolone or a vegan swap keeps it inclusive.

A balsamic reduction threads through like a bright ribbon.

Herbs get tossed right before it hits the roll so you catch a burst of freshness. The texture contrast is the secret: tender roast meets crusty bread.

Order it warmed and the whole thing sings.